What's new

India likely to cancel $500 million Spike ATGM deal after they reportedly failed during trials

Anik101

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Nov 15, 2018
Messages
644
Reaction score
1
Country
India
Location
India
India said planning to scrap $500 million missile deal with Israel
Massive sale was already called off last year in favor of domestic weapons development, but resurrected after diplomatic push by Netanyahu
By TAMAR PILEGGI 9 Dec 2018, 8:08 pm 0

Illustrative. Israeli soldiers launch a Spike anti-tank guided missile during a training exercise. (Rafael Advanced Defense Systems)
  • 41shares
India is reportedly planning to scrap a $500 million deal to purchase Spike anti-tank missiles from Israeli defense contractor Rafael, in what would be New Delhi’s second time abandoning the half-billion dollar arms deal.

The Israeli business daily The Marker on Sunday said Indian officials have requested the Spike missiles produced by government-owned Rafael Advanced Defense Systems undergo additional testing next year, saying the weapon’s infrared system has failed to withstand high temperatures in previous rounds of testing. The Indian military is reportedly concerned about the missiles’ performance in hot, desert conditions.

On Thursday, an Indian government official told the My Nation Indian news website that the defense establishment was planning to back out of the deal with Rafael in favor of developing missiles domestically.

Get The Times of Israel's Daily Edition by email and never miss our top storiesFREE SIGN UP

The official said development of the Man Portable Anti Tank Guide Missile (MP-ATGM) was progressing “very fast,” would enter its second stage of testing soon.

He said the government’s Defense Research and Development Organization could deliver thousands MP-ATGMs in two or three years, the same amount of time he said it would take Raphael to fulfill the same order.

AP_473097031834-640x400.jpg

Israeli-made Spike missiles are displayed during a street parade marking the 65th anniversary of the Armed Forces Day in Seoul, South Korea, October 1, 2013. (AP/Lee Jin-man/File)
According to the Marker, Israeli officials have interpreted the request as a sign that New Delhi is looking for a way out of the approximately half-billion-dollar deal that is seen as a major milestone in relations between the two countries.

The deal was initially struck in 2014, and Rafael Advanced Defense Systems had begun preparations to fulfill the order of 8,000 Spike missiles. Last August, it opened a production facility in India with its local partner, the Kalyani Group, in accordance with the government’s requirements that the weapon be “made in India.”

Three months later, India pulled out of the deal, reportedly in favor of producing an anti-tank missile domestically. Indian media reports at the time said the reversal was made to protect the government’s DRDO, which was developing its own version of the missile.

But in January, during an official visit to India that sought to foster closer economic ties, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Narendra Modi’s government was “reauthorizing the Spike deal.”

According to Indian media, Modi’s government scaled down the order and awarded part of the contract, 5,000 missiles, to domestic manufacturers, and the remaining 3,000 missiles to the Raphael-Kalyani facility.

000_WO7WI-e1516070405875-640x400.jpg

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi hugs Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during a press conference at Hyderabad House in New Delhi on January 15, 2018. (AFP PHOTO / MONEY SHARMA)
India, which has longstanding territorial disputes with neighbors China and Pakistan, has signed several big-ticket defense deals since Modi came to power in 2014.

It has been moving away from relying on traditional ally Russia for military hardware, and has deepened its ties to Israel, diplomatically and militarily.

Israel and India trade some $5 billion annually, with the majority of the deals in arms and diamonds.

Last year, Israel and India signed a $2 billion military arms deal, which includes the supply over several years of medium-range surface-to-air missiles, launchers, and communications technology.

Times of Israel staff contributed to this report.
 
. .
During 2009 hot summer trials in Rajasthan 8 out of 9 Spike missiles had failed to hit their targets
 
. . .
DRDO MPATGM has performed better than Spike in initial user trials.
All thanks to lessons learned from Nag. Continuous rejection by Indian Army due to its failure to differentiate between targets in hot desert conditions of Thar encouraged our engineers to develop highly advance IR seekers which can now differentiate b/w targets with temperature difference of 0.02°C.
 
.
It failed in the desert. Hmmm interesting. So India needs to use anti tank missile in the desert are of Rajasthan in summers. Very interesting. So that means India wants to go defensive in the desert because it's MBTs are not performing well there?
 
.
It failed in the desert. Hmmm interesting. So India needs to use anti tank missile in the desert are of Rajasthan in summers. Very interesting. So that means India wants to go defensive in the desert because it's MBTs are not performing well there?

These are man portable ATGMs.
 
. . . . .
Anti-tank is defensive weapon only used as an offensive weapon as part of urban guerilla war which never happens in desert.

In World War 2 German panzer divisions had regiments with anti-tank weapons. it was standard practice.
 
.
In World War 2 German panzer divisions had regiments with anti-tank weapons. it was standard practice.
In world war 2 they never had drone equipment and surveillance we have these days. If India is planning to send infantry regiments to Pakistan with anti-tank missiles I think our job is not so difficult then?
 
.
Indian Army conducts twin tests of DRDO-built MPATGM weapon system
September 17, 2018...

The Indian Army has successfully conducted the first and second flight tests of its newly developed man portable anti-tank guided missile (MPATGM).

The twin tests on the indigenously built low-weight missile were carried out on two consecutive days at the army’s Ahmednagar range in Maharashtra, India.

Once deployed into service, the anti-tank guided missiles will enable the Indian Army to attack and destroy hostile tanks in the battlefield.

The flight trials were conducted in association with the missile manufacturer Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) to demonstrate the MPATGM’s ability to be launched from different ranges, including testing the weapon’s maximum range capability.

According to a statement by the Indian Defence Ministry, all the mission objectives of the two trials have been successfully met.

“According to a statement by the Indian Defence Ministry, all the mission objectives of the two trials have been successfully met.”
Indian Defence Minister Nirmala Sitharaman congratulated the team from DRDO, the Indian Army and other associated industries for the successful completion of the two missile launches.

MPATGM is a third-generation anti-tank missile that has been designed to replace the Indian Army’s second-generation Milan and Konkurs ATGMs.

The 14.5kg fire-and-forget weapon system, equipped with a detachable command launch unit (CLU), will weigh approximately 20kg in carrying mode, reported idrw.org.

With an operational range between 200m and 2.5km, the missile features a single kill probability of more than 90%, in addition to soft launch capabilities.

VEM Technologies is manufacturing the missile sub-systems for the weapon system.

https://www.army-technology.com/news/indian-army-twin-tests-mpatgm-weapon/
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom