The Quran, Hadith, and Sunnah have no such command, implied or otherwise.
So all those Ahadith supporting Blasphemy Law are void according to you? I am quoting them again, so you can base your claims against actions and words of Prophet P.B.U.H:
Narrated Abdullah Ibn Abbas
:A blind man had a slave-mother who used to abuse the Prophet (ﷺ) and disparage him. He forbade her but she did not stop. He rebuked her but she did not give up her habit. One night she began to slander the Prophet (ﷺ) and abuse him. So he took a dagger, placed it on her belly, pressed it, and killed her. A child who came between her legs was smeared with the blood that was there. When the morning came, the Prophet (ﷺ) was informed about it.
He assembled the people and said: I adjure by Allah the man who has done this action and I adjure him by my right to him that he should stand up. Jumping over the necks of the people and trembling the man stood up.
He sat before the Prophet (ﷺ) and said: Messenger of Allah! I am her master; she used to abuse you and disparage you. I forbade her, but she did not stop, and I rebuked her, but she did not abandon her habit. I have two sons like pearls from her, and she was my companion. Last night she began to abuse and disparage you. So I took a dagger, put it on her belly and pressed it till I killed her.
Thereupon the Prophet (ﷺ) said:
Oh be witness, no retaliation is payable for her blood.Sunan Abi Daood H-4361, Nisai
In fact, the Quran does have aprox. 54 different instances of commanding the Muslims to ignore and walk away when faced with insults against Allah (S.W.T) himself.
Can you claim the same about Prophet P.B.U.H? And were all those commands belong to Makki period or Madni?
Then, as you rightly pointed out, the Prophet's (S.A.W) entire life stands directly opposed to this idea. He was physically assaulted and yet he forgave.
Prophet P.B.U.H can forgive His blasphemers, but how can you assume the place of Prophet and forgive His blasphemers?
Furthermore, according to Islam itself, religious minorities are not subject to Islamic religious laws. In fact, they can choose to have their own independent courts.
Religious minorities form a contract with Islamic state and they can not break that contract. When some non Muslim citizen of Islamic state abuses Prophet P.B.U.H, he is breaking that contract and Islamic state has the right to take his life.
Where does this supposed law come from then?
From Sunnah and Ijma. Muslims have general consensus about the Punishment of blasphemer for 1400 years. Do I need to repeat those names again who have given the Fatwa of capital Punishment for blasphemer? Or according to you, Islamic laws are directly revealed to Ghamdi and likes of you?
From emotions of those who know nothing of the religion and yet claim to be its thekedars, those who choose to twist established laws to further their own religious and political agendas.
From Imam Shafai to Imam Ghazali, from Imam Malik to Qazi Ayyaz, from Imam Muhammad bin Hassan Shaibani to Sana ullah Panipati; all of them knew nothing. All of them issued fatwas and decrees based on their emotions. All of them were furthering their political agendas.
However, the true spirit of Islam and its laws are only revealed to Ghamdi and his disciples. They can reject Ahadith, they can change meaning of Quran, the can change Quranic Aam to Khas and they can restrict rulings of Quran to few individuals. They can also reject Ijma and no one can contradict them.
A) During the Medani period it was decreed that if a Muslim commits apostasy he will be declared a "Murtad" and could be subjected to capital punishment. This was done in the background of the rampant danger posed by the "Munafiqeen" i.e. the law was administrative and not religious, but that is a separate debate.
So what are your thoughts about law of Irtadad? Is it still applicable?
- The Hanafi school decrees death to an apostate only if he commits unlawful warfare against the state. If he does not, he is free to go.
where is the reference of this claim?
- The Ja'fari and Hanafi schools only ascribe the capital punishment to men.
Why you are hiding the punishment of a women in Hanafi School?
- While the Hanafi, Maliki, and Jafri schools make capital punishment mandatory (as long as the prerequisites are met), the Shafi'i and Hanbali schools only consider it a recommendation.
Reference?
- According to all these schools the apostate has to openly declare his/her apostasy in front of the judge and/or community. If he/she does not, they are free to go. In fact, if the judge asks him to re-confirm it and he/she denies it, he/she is free to go.
What is the punishment of a person who kills a Murtad?
B) Later on, after the time of the Sahabah, a Muslim man insulted the Prophet (S.A.W) and people took him to the law. The jurists of the time agreed that he could not be punished for insulting the Prophet (S.A.W) but then also decided that since a believing Muslim could not ever insult the Prophet (S.A.W), the insult he had hurled meant that he was in fact not a Muslim anymore and hence had become an apostate.
Reference?
Non-Muslims were not subject to this law since 1) it is an Islamic religious law, and 2) Non-Muslims by definition cannot commit apostasy from Islam.
Again, where is the reference of this claim? Or we have to accept all your claims on face value?
C) Still, as time passed, the rabid Mullah and his followers, in their rabid emotions, hatred, and ignorance from the religion, decided that Blasphemy = Death for anyone and everyone. And not just death penalty "as per the law and by the law" but murder by the common man, which ironically does indeed carry the death penalty in Islam. A law that is only enforceable on Muslims as per Islamic Jurisprudence and common sense was now enforced on Non-Muslims as well. It was also enforced in ways contrary to the actual decrees; no waiting periods were allowed, no opportunity to repent/recant was given, in fact recanting and repenting did not save you at all, no confirmation or open declaration by the accused was required either. You can accuse your neighbor of blasphemy today, through him and his family in a brick kiln tomorrow, and be a religious hero the day after. People will even build a mausoleum where your putrid self will lay.
Result? A disgustingly morbid, unethical, and absolutely un-Islamic law made and enforced by those who know nothing of the religion. A law which goes contrary to everything The Book and The Prophet (S.A.W) stand for. A law these illiterate Mullahs and their sheep defend like rabid dogs. A law which is only an excuse to commit atrocities against Non-Muslims. A law which the Prophet (S.A.W) himself will testify against in the hereafter, as is his promise.
Names of Scholars who recorded Ijma regarding capital punishment of blasphemer:
Ibn e Munzar, Abu bakar Farsi, Qazi Ayaz, Ibn e Taimiyah, Imam khatabi, Imam Ishaq bin Rahwae, Imam Abu Bakar Jasas, Ibn e Abdin Shami, Imam ibne Sakhnon Malki, Imam Ibn e Atab Malki,
Names of Scholars who gave the fatwa of Capital Punishment aginst Blasphemour of Rasool Allah:
Allama Ismail Haqqi Sahib e Rohul Bayan, Imam Ibne qayam, Imam Ibne taimiayah, Imam Ibn e Munzar, imam malik, imam lais bin saad, imam ahmad bin Hanbal, imam ishaq bin rahwae, imam shafai, imam abubakar farsi shafai, Qazi Ayaz Malki, imam khatabi, Hazrat Umar bin abdul aziz, imam khalal, Ibn e Aqeel Abul Khatab, Imam Halwani, Qazi Abul Hussain, Ibne Munir, allama Ibn e Kasir, Sana Ullah Pani Pati, Hafiz Saadi, Imam Darqutni, allama waqdi, sheikh muhammad bin abdullah altamartashi, Abu saod hanfi, imam Abdullah bin alhakam, imam abu yousaf, imam tahawi,
, Imam usman bin kanana malki, imam azbakh malki, abu lais samrqandi, imam abu nasar adabusi, imam ibn e bazaz hanafi, imam khair udin ramli hanfi, imam ibn e najim hanfi, abu lais samrqandi, abu nasar adabusi, imam burhan udin mahmud, imam abu ali bin albana, , qazi abu yala, abul mawahib al akbari, qazi abu ali bin abi musa, imam haskafi, , imam abul hassan qabsi, imam muhammad bin abi zaid, imam ahmad bin sulaiman, imam abdullah bin atab, Maulana Hussain ahmad madni, Imam Subki Shafai
All of them were Rabid Mullahs, all of them were full of hatred and ignorance. However, true Islam is only revealed to you.
Please, get out of your hatred of Muslims.
