In India Muslim man arrested for marrying Hindu girl

[masterchief_mirza]

Lol How by applying the law equally???



But it equally harasses so it's not discriminatory. It harasses Hindus too.

If the law only applied to a particular group like Muslims then you can say that it discriminates, but it applies equally to Hindus.

What you can say is that you don't like the law, because it stops you from doing what you are doing.

It is discriminatory. Also, the law is unconstitutional as it impinges on the personal choice of an individual to choose or convert religion.

Do you think the police are asking if the "convertee" was willing or not? The example cited above demonstrates quite clearly that any random scum bag could point a finger and cry "love jihad", at which point the accused will be booked regardless of whether the conversion was voluntary or not. Read the examples cited and learn how this law is already being interpreted and applied in a subjective manner with varying outcomes for Hindus vs Muslims, and hence is by design discriminatory.

A civilised nation would laugh at this law and throw it out of parliament.

 

[Gilljutt]

Examples were cited above. Couples happily married and *voluntarily* converted by "love jihadist" action were harassed and booked under the new law, while contrarily, couples converted to Hinduism were not booked - if you read the examples above from Indian sources, the parents of the female were AGAINST the marriage and the conversion of the male to Hinduism, however the police broke the new law by protecting the female from prosecution. The parents protested the union which should have triggered appropriate police action to annul the wedding and book the female under the new law. Technicalities were also broken as the correct notice period and court permission were not sought. Yet, despite these legal breaches, the police protected the couple.

Already, we are seeing the law ignored for conversion to hinduism but applied for conversion to Islam.

Are you truly so stupid? Or are you ignoring the evidence above?

I'm sure if Hindu men are forcing their Muslim wives to convert then they too will be brought before the law. And the law will apply without discrimination.

It is discriminatory. Also, the law is unconstitutional as it impinges on the personal choice of an individual to choose or convert religion.

Do you think the police are asking if the "convertee" was willing or not? The example cited above demonstrates quite clearly that any random scum bag could point a finger and cry "love jihad", at which point the accused will be booked regardless of whether the conversion was voluntary or not. Read the examples cited and learn how this law is already being interpreted and applied in a subjective manner with varying outcomes for Hindus vs Muslims, and hence is by design discriminatory.

A civilised nation would laugh at this law and throw it out of parliament.

Lol, by that definition Pakistan is not civilized.

 

[masterchief_mirza]

I'm sure if Hindu men are forcing their Muslim wives to convert then they too will be brought before the law. And the law will apply without discrimination.

Yet you have been shown examples of a Hindu converting a Muslim, despite her parents' protest, and that hindu woman being protected and allowed by police to elope with her victim. So your "surety" has lasted under a week since the law was passed.

Now you will have to stick your fingers in your ears and sing "lalala all is fine" in view of the failure of your assurances.

 

[Gilljutt]

Yet you have been shown examples of a Hindu converting a Muslim, despite her parents' protest, and that hindu woman being protected and allowed by police to elope with her victim. So your "surety" has lasted under a week since the law was passed.

Now you will have to stick your fingers in your ears and sing "lalala all is fine" in view of the failure of your assurances.

Hindus converting a muslim where? Post a link. I will call the authorities and demand that they investigate and prosecute. I'll be on the Muslim girl's side!

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Hindus converting a muslim where? Post a link. I will call the authorities and demand that they investigate and prosecute. I'll be on the Muslim girl's side!

Post no. 24. No need to pretend you didn't read it. We see right through your little facade of faux "secularism". Enjoy the mouthful of sand.

Muslim man converts to Hinduism to marry, couple under police protection

21-year-old man and 19-year-old woman had approached the Punjab and Haryana high court saying they feared a threat to their life, following which directions were issued to provide them security

m.hindustantimes.com

 

[Saho]

What’s wrong with Indian Muslim women?

I never understood why some of those Muslim men go for hindus.

 

[Gilljutt]

Post no. 24. No need to pretend you didn't read it. We see right through your little facade of faux "secularism". Enjoy the mouthful of sand.

Muslim man converts to Hinduism to marry, couple under police protection

21-year-old man and 19-year-old woman had approached the Punjab and Haryana high court saying they feared a threat to their life, following which directions were issued to provide them security

m.hindustantimes.com

Yes but the couple in the story went to the law for protection. The law is HELPING them not prosecuting them. The couple in the story did nothing wrong. Its the parents who are wrong.

The law in this topic is a different law. That was enacted to prevent forced conversion.

 

[fallstuff]

Lol How by applying the law equally???



But it equally harasses so it's not discriminatory. It harasses Hindus too.

If the law only applied to a particular group like Muslims then you can say that it discriminates, but it applies equally to Hindus.

What you can say is that you don't like the law, because it stops you from doing what you are doing.

Once again your country your laws buddy. If this new law helps poor Indians , I guess it will be great !

 

[colonel rajesh]

Some In India change religion, at least three times per day, morning breakfast Muslim, afternoon Lunch Christians, evening Tea Buddhist and Dinner Hindu again.

Muslims aren't allowed to Marry Hindus period full stop! No exception... The ones who are are also most likely to change religion after or before the ceremony..

yes you are right ,
india is a hindu nation , muslims can marry hindus if they convert to hinduism .

 

[Gilljutt]

yes you are right ,
india is a hindu nation , muslims can marry hindus if they convert to hinduism .

No Muslims can marry Hindus and remain Muslim and on-top of that they can't be forced to convert via marriage. It's protecting Muslims too from coherced conversion.

 

[colonel rajesh]

No Muslims can marry Hindus and remain Muslim and on-top of that they can't be forced to convert via marriage. It's protecting Muslims too from coherced conversion.

its ok .

 

[Suriya]

Free will means a person has the choice to make decisions - if Pakistani muslim women do not want to convert or marry a non -faith person That is their choice! You can be disappointed as you want, but in this day and age you have to seek permission of the woman to seek any relationship; going with arguments like “hey your men sleep with woman of our community, so i come sleep in your bed ok to balance things out” is not the way to go about. Consent is required from the woman in 21st century - even if a million Hindu woman marry Muslims, it doesnt mean Muslims are required to do the same in return (same is true vice versa). One group individually may adhere to its faith or customs more than others.

Listen, buddy, free and liberal Hindu majority India allows marriage between Hindu and Muslim without hindrance.

And the current new law only ask for an affidavit that there was no coercion in change of religion if any of the spouse changes his or her religion before marriage. Unless there is change of religion and couple marry under special marriage act even this affidavit isn't needed.

Now come to Pakistan.

In Pakistan a Non- Muslim can't marry a Muslim unless there conversion to Islam.

More over, what absurd and clear violation rights is that if a non-muslim converts to Islam, his/her marriage is no longer valid.

Firstly, topic here is Indian Discriminatory and unconstitutional Laws, so called love Jihad Law.

Secondly, Islamic Laws are not under discussion here.

When your religion, your society and your country prohibits marriage with non-Muslims and you wont have any of it, it is very hypocritical to get concerned about interfaith marriage in India, and that too only when Hindu girls are involved.

 

[Suriya]

A civilised nation would laugh at this law and throw it out of parliament.

No, India isn't a civilised nation.

Islamic republic of Pakistan can show India the way by allowing marriage btw Hindus and Muslims without conversion. By allowing non-Muslims including Ahmadis equal right to practice and propagate their religion and built their place of worship without Hindrance. By removing blasphemy laws which carries death sentence and Finally, allow non-Muslims to become head of the state.

 

[Hamza913]

How many Pakistani Muslim women have married Hindus and have become Hindus?

Almost none. Many more Hindus want to become Muslim than vice versa. You guys can't swallow this so you chalk it all up to materialistic reasons, when quite frankly that's just a coping mechanism.

 

[Suriya]

Almost none. Many more Hindus want to become Muslim than vice versa. You guys can't swallow this so you chalk it all up to materialistic reasons, when quite frankly that's just a coping mechanism.

Because that's how you treat minorities in ur country, they left with little choice

Not a day goes by when a Hindu girl abducted and his father crying in the middle of road or Ahmadi is shot simply being their identity. When you take pride of this, it looks ugly and inhuman to anyone with sense.

Yes, India is changing as they see what's happening to Hindus in Pakistan and also history of Muslim of the subcontinent.