Imran Khan Announces to give Pak Citizenship to Afghan Refugees

[SoulSpokesman]

@Kabira

I just hope you didn't meant to say Afghanistan as civilisation.

Ha, ha, that was a good one Kabira bhai!

Regards

 

[Zibago]

@Zibago

Thoughts?

Scroll above
Stupid statement which will be ignored by all power sectors and will face opposition from all provinces he controls particularly Balochistan

 

[Fawadqasim1]

There are some nationalists Punjabis here who think Pakistan is just for them and all other federating units and their inhabitants must take certificate of loyalty from them this is the real and present danger to our country. There is no other threat bigger
Then this to my country. You should be ashamed of your attitude
You just sound like ANP BLA Jeay Sindh Qaumi Mahaz etc all of whom are rejected by their respective ethnicities by and large.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Below is the constituency map of Pakistan. There are over 200 of them covering each region of the country. Do you think all the 'sound' you hear on PDF reflects all of these districts in equal proportion? Like ball oxes. The reality is most of the screaming you get here from people who think they own the entire country is probably just about dozen plus districts. You know the better off from the big urban centres followed by sliver from the rural districts, even these are from the periphery of the major urban cities. Rest of the 200 million are on 'mute' mode. They never get to express their views.

The whole point the emphasis by PTI on socio-economic uplift of the poor and the 'mute' is provide education, health and opportunities so that they can go on to play their role in Pakistan. This will increasingly begin to happen as these districts that are neglected whose people never get to have say on the media - which of course only covers the voice of the urban in big cities like Karachi or get to shout on PDF because they don't even have internet connection.

However as we move forward increasingly these disenfranchized communities will get to play their role and you will see a Pakistani narrative that more balanced and representative of the Pakistani demography. This might well be the biggest legacy of PTI government. Bringing about a social wakening in the voice of the neglected masses.

And by the way people tend to pick guns up when they don;t have a stake or share in the society. If your pushed to margins why should you care about the state? A more inclusive and reflective society is more at peace and stable; stronger.

Ps. And I think it is same in India. Only in your country the Dalit, Shudra, Austro-Aborginal tribes are pushed out of the mainstream. Also I think your marginalized are more docile on account of being squashed by the Hindu caste order. They will also awake in time but it willtake time. The Maoist insurgency is a expression of that latent repressed peoples.

@padamchen

 

[padamchen]

Below is the constituency map of Pakistan. There are over 200 of them covering each region of the country. Do you think all the 'sound' you hear on PDF reflects all of these districts in equal proportion? Like ball oxes. The reality is most of the screaming you get here from people who think they own the entire country is probably just about dozen plus districts. You know the better off from the big urban centres followed by sliver from the rural districts, even these are from the periphery of the major urban cities. Rest of the 200 million are on 'mute' mode. They never get to express their views.

The whole point the emphasis by PTI on socio-economic uplift of the poor and the 'mute' is provide education, health and opportunities so that they can go on to play their role in Pakistan. This will increasingly begin to happen as these districts that are neglected whose people never get to have say on the media - which of course only covers the voice of the urban in big cities like Karachi or get to shout on PDF because they don't even have internet connection.

However as we move forward increasingly these disenfranchized communities will get to play their role and you will see a Pakistani narrative that more balanced and representative of the Pakistani demography. This might well be the biggest legacy of PTI government. Bringing about a social wakening in the voice of the neglected masses.

And by the way people tend to pick guns up when they don;t have a stake or share in the society. If your pushed to margins why should you care about the state? A more inclusive and reflective society is more at peace and stable; stronger.

Ps. And I think it is same in India. Only in your country the Dalit, Shudra, Austro-Aborginal tribes are pushed out of the mainstream. Also I think your marginalized are more docile on account of being squashed by the Hindu caste order. They will also awake in time but it willtake time. The Maoist insurgency is a expression of that latent repressed peoples.

@padamchen

I completely agree on the paradigm doctrine that if you cant get rid of them, make sure they join you first. And fast.

Cheers, Doc

 

[fitpOsitive]

Post source of your claim, Germany doesn't give citizenship. They are deporting afghanis as we write.

I met 10s of such people. I can speak punjabi as well.

And these refugees are not exploding themselves after getting money from German enemy.

Yes, because German law enforcement is tight.

 

[Imran Khan]

mubarak ho nya pakistn will be aalmi yateem khana

 

[TMA]

Pray that this does not become Law.

Pray that this does not become Law.

 

[N.Siddiqui]

Everyone should listen to what PM Imran Khan has said, all the discussion here is focused on something which is blown out of proportion, it was put out of context.

Imran Khan speech here cut to the actual time talking about deprived class and the need to give CNIC and Passport to them.

 

[TMA]

Child born in Pakistan shud be Pakistani...

Regardless

No.
The Japanese have common sense...the Europeans are reganing it...but Pakistanis are losing it....

The Devil has never accepted Adam (PBUH)...what makes you think that Afghanistan will ever accept Pakistan???

This is foolishness....

 

[UnitedPak]

I am against the level of mindless scapegoating that generally takes place whenever someone mentions Afghans, and believe me I have personally met plenty of Urdu speaking anti-Pakistan Afghans in the west. Saying that, it would be a nightmare to deport Afghans who are born in Pak. We are already feeding them and the current status forces them to work illegally and resort to crime. There are plenty of bad apples but we need to face the reality that majority are normal people. Let them work and contribute to the economy. As far as I know, we are deporting the new comers.

 

[MBT 3000]

what about the anti pakistan ones? will they be deported?

 

[Enigma_]

As far as I know, we are deporting the new comers.

Lol delusion is high.

 

[TMA]

There are some nationalists Punjabis here who think Pakistan is just for them and all other federating units and their inhabitants must take certificate of loyalty from them this is the real and present danger to our country. There is no other threat bigger
Then this to my country. You should be ashamed of your attitude
You just sound like ANP BLA Jeay Sindh Qaumi Mahaz etc all of whom are rejected by their respective ethnicities by and large.

The biggest threat long term among the many threats is demography. It is utterly foolishly to allow people citizenship who are from a century which does not accept your right to EXIST.

Can you imagine if I allowed you into my house and gave you free roam, if you did not accept my right to exist?

Pakistan is already poor. Focus on the Pakistanis. Let Afghanistan worry about her people.
This will not curry favour overall as they see Pakistan “occupying” their land anyways...there will be no gratitude....why are Pakistani blind....have they been infected with the cultural Marxism of the West??? Or is a lopsided intrepreatation of Muslim-Brotherhood?
If your brother stabs you in the back and does not accept your right to exist, there is no obligation to consider him your brother....?

 

[Enigma_]

The biggest threat long term among the many threats is demography. It is utterly foolishly to allow people citizenship who are from a century which does not accept your right to EXIST.

Can you imagine if I allowed you into my house and gave you free roam, if you did not accept my right to exist?

Pakistan is already poor. Focus on the Pakistanis. Let Afghanistan worry about her people.
This will not curry favour overall as they see Pakistan “occupying” their land anyways...there will be no gratitude....why are Pakistani blind....have they been infected with the cultural Marxism of the West??? Or is a lopsided intrepreatation of Muslim-Brotherhood?
If your brother stabs you in the back and does not accept your right to exist, there is no obligation to consider him your brother....?

Nonsense. Brothers come first.