What's new

I hope Trump is right (and I’m wrong) on Afghanistan

pakistani342

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jan 20, 2013
Messages
3,485
Reaction score
6
Country
United States
Location
United States
Interesting comments from neo-con and occasional Pakistan basher Ralph Peters (Christina Fair one famously quipped "what does he know?"):

Article here

Where is the US general with the integrity to ask himself why, after 16 years of American support and self-sacrificing combat, the Afghan central government has been losing province after province to ill-equipped, poorly trained guerrillas who were characterized to me by one of our top generals as tactically inept “idiots”?

I could hear a proud and complacent British general saying the same thing about George Washington’s army. In Afghanistan, we’re the Redcoats.

The Afghans just don’t want what we want them to want. All but crushed, the Taliban came back to conquer. Yes, they received austere aid from Pakistan, but it was nothing compared to the funding and training we lavished on “our” Afghans. The Taliban didn’t have air support, but its fighters believed in their cause.


 
.
Interesting comments from neo-con and occasional Pakistan basher Ralph Peters (Christina Fair one famously quipped "what does he know?"):

Article here

Where is the US general with the integrity to ask himself why, after 16 years of American support and self-sacrificing combat, the Afghan central government has been losing province after province to ill-equipped, poorly trained guerrillas who were characterized to me by one of our top generals as tactically inept “idiots”?

I could hear a proud and complacent British general saying the same thing about George Washington’s army. In Afghanistan, we’re the Redcoats.

The Afghans just don’t want what we want them to want. All but crushed, the Taliban came back to conquer. Yes, they received austere aid from Pakistan, but it was nothing compared to the funding and training we lavished on “our” Afghans. The Taliban didn’t have air support, but its fighters believed in their cause.

lol, the Afghan Taliban is going to come back to power.

Just wait and watch. :lol:
 
.
the Afghan central government has been losing province after province to ill-equipped, poorly trained guerrillas who were characterized to me by one of our top generals as tactically inept “idiots”?

ill-equipped, yes. Poorly trained, no.
 
.
The US pays the Taliban to not attack their supplies! people in afghan army take their weapons and join the Taliban and as a result the taliban has gotten better arms!! Infact I am sure taliban join the army as well!!! Taliban are becoming a afghan force and NOT just a Pashtun force!!!! The Tajik followers of Ahmed Shah Masood are the latest to join the Taliban or take up arms against occupation after the disgusting leaflets they dropped!!!!!!

BUT its all because Pakistan and the connection of Haqqani network.
 
.
Earlier to talk with Talibans will be better for the region and whole world. Let them contain Indian terrorism ISIS Khurasan.

Remaining terms can be negotiated.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom