What's new

Has Intel's Indian-American Techie Risked America's Global Technology Leadership?

RiazHaq

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
Messages
6,611
Reaction score
70
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
http://www.riazhaq.com/2020/07/has-intels-indian-american-techie.html

Intel has recently fired its Indian-American chief engineer Venkata Murthy Renduchintala, who also served as Group President of the Technology, Systems Architecture and Client Group (TSCG), for failure to deliver 7 nanometer semiconductor technology on schedule, according to Reuters. The news has knocked the market value of Intel by tens of billions dollars. The American company, the biggest global chip manufacturer with in-house fabrication plants, has also decided to outsource manufacturing. This could deal a serious blow to America's global leadership in chip manufacturing which is fundamental to all other computer and communications related technologies.



Intel's Global Leadership:

Intel Corp. (INTC), founded in 1968 in Silicon Valley, is the world's largest and the most advanced semiconductor company, larger than the second-ranked Samsung Semiconductors, and more than triple the size of the next-largest domestic producer, Qualcomm Inc. (QCOM).

What distinguishes Intel from most other semiconductor companies is that it manufactures its products in-house. The bulk of semiconductor “manufacturers” outsource the actual work of building their products out to foundries in China and Taiwan.

Last week, the company revealed that its smaller, faster 7-nanometer chipmaking technology was at least six months behind schedule and it would have to outsource manufacturing to keep its products competitive.

Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC):

Taiwan-based TSMC has 6 nanometer technology in production already. There is widespread speculation that Intel will turn to it to manufacture its most advanced microprocessors.

TSMC manufactures chips for the vast majority of the leading fabless semiconductor companies including Advanced Micro Devices (AMD), Apple Inc., Broadcom Inc., Marvell, Nvidia, and Qualcomm.

US Technology Leadership Under Threat:

Semiconductor manufacturing technology is fundamental to all other computer and communications technologies. While the U.S. still has most of the leading chip design companies, there are very few leading semiconductor manufacturing facilities in the country. In fact, the US, which invented the chip technology, has slipped from being first in semiconductor manufacturing at the dawn of the industry to fifth in the world.

Recognizing the issue of foreign sourcing of critical technologies, the US has forced TSMC to start a fab in Arizona. But TSMC’s proposed fab in Arizona will have relatively small capacity, sufficient to meet only a fraction of the manufacturing demand of top companies like Apple, AMD, Marvell, Nvidia, etc. The US Congress is in the process of legislation that will provide greater incentives to companies to manufacture chips in the United States.

US-China Tech War:

TSMC is caught in the cross-fire of US-China technology war. Almost all major semiconductor manufacturers, including TSMC, rely on equipment made by US companies. The US government is attempting to leverage the dominance of US chipmaking equipment industry to shut out the Chinese technology companies.

US Commerce Department has recently announced that henceforth, any semiconductor chips made with equipment built by American companies cannot be sold to Huawei without prior approval and license from the DOC.

Summary:

Silicon Valley tech giant has revealed that its smaller, faster 7-nanometer chipmaking technology is at least six months behind schedule and it would have to outsource manufacturing to keep its products competitive. The company has blamed the failure on its Indian-American chief engineer who has since been fired. What is at stake here is the US technology leadership because semiconductors are fundamental to all computers and communications products. Taiwan-based TSMC appears to be the biggest beneficiary of Intel's failure.

Related Links:

Haq's Musings

South Asia Investor Review

Can Pakistan Benefit From US-China Trade War

Caste Discrimination Among Indian-Americans in Silicon Valley

Marvel Pays $7.5 Billion For Cavium Co-Founded by Pakistani-American

OPEN Silicon Valley Forum 2017: Pakistani Entrepreneurs Conference

Pakistani-American's Tech Unicorn Files For IPO at $1.6 Billion Valuation

Pakistani-American Cofounders Sell Startup to Cisco for $610 million

Pakistani Brothers Spawned $20 Billion Security Software Industry

Pakistani-American Ashar Aziz's Fireeye Goes Public

Pakistani-American Pioneered 3D Technology in Orthodontics

Pakistani-Americans Enabling 2nd Machine Revolution

Pakistani-American Shahid Khan Richest South Asian in America

Two Pakistani-American Silicon Valley Techs Among Top 5 VC Deals

Pakistani-American's Game-Changing Vision

Minorities Are Majority in Silicon Valley

Riaz Haq's Youtube Channel

PakAlumni Social Network


http://www.riazhaq.com/2020/07/has-intels-indian-american-techie.html
 
.
Intel has recently fired its Indian-American chief engineer Venkata Murthy Renduchintala, who also served as Group President of the Technology, Systems Architecture and Client Group (TSCG), for failure to deliver 7 nanometer semiconductor technology on schedule, according to Reuters.

The Indian government should get Murthy and the much-hyped "Father of the Pentium processor" Vinod Dham to move to India and contribute to design India's local processor. The chip can be manufactured at TSMC to begin with.

@Arulmozhi Varman @Joe Shearer @xeuss
 
. .
The Indian government should get Murthy and the much-hyped "Father of the Pentium processor" Vinod Dham to move to India and contribute to design India's local processor. The chip can be manufactured at TSMC to begin with.

@Arulmozhi Varman @Joe Shearer @xeuss

True. India does not have any deficiency of talent but if these guys come back, we can push it faster.
 
.
True. India does not have any deficiency of talent but if these guys come back, we can push it faster.

It isn't designing the chips that is a challenge. It is making them. Check the value of a fab, and the risks involved. In my opinion, doing programmable gate arrays is good enough.
 
.
In my opinion, doing programmable gate arrays is good enough.

As far as I know, programmable gate arrays still have a fixed ASIC controller / processor and that pose a challenge for strategic requirements ( they may have a network-enabled kill switch ).

Hence the Chandigarh-based mini fab SCL which produces bigger-sized but secure chips for India's space, military and possibly power-generation applications.

It isn't designing the chips that is a challenge. It is making them. Check the value of a fab, and the risks involved.

From this Wikipedia page :
Estimates put the cost of building a new fab over one billion U.S. dollars with values as high as $3–4 billion not being uncommon. TSMC invested $9.3 billion in its Fab15 300 mm wafer manufacturing facility in Taiwan


From here :
On 1 February 2020, the Finance Minister of India, Nirmala Sitharaman presented the budget. The allocation for defence during the fiscal year 2020-21 stood at ₹471,378 crores (US$65.86 Billion)


Compare the two bolded amounts. I am sure a ten billion dollar figure can be diverted from the military budget to establish a fab.
 
Last edited:
.
The Indian government should get Murthy and the much-hyped "Father of the Pentium processor" Vinod Dham to move to India and contribute to design India's local processor. The chip can be manufactured at TSMC to begin with.

@Arulmozhi Varman @Joe Shearer @xeuss

I gave you an voluminous example of how making an new chip isn't an problem. We have lots and lots of companies sitting in Chennai, Bang and HYD doing chip design, testing and consultant works for world's top design companies. But none has the capital to design and market it under their own brand.

The govt challenge here is making an fab for electronics related to domestic fabs. Even computers sold in India is less. Its the accessory IC like DIO, timers, frequency chips which has more capacity and we need to manufacture them here.
 
.
We have lots and lots of companies sitting in Chennai, Bang and HYD doing chip design, testing and consultant works for world's top design companies.

Can you compare the ISA, performance and applications of such designs with ARM, Intel x86, SPARC etc ?

The govt challenge here is making an fab for electronics related to domestic fabs.

My post# 6.
 
Last edited:
.
Can you compare the ISA, performance and applications of such designs with ARM, Intel, SPARC etc ?



My post# 6.

I told before. Intel has thousands of chips and different varieties. In my previous company we have an Intel processor which was like an memory card which we can add or remove from the system as we please. That product never came into market and was exclusively designed for us by Intel. And from discussion I found it was designed by some company doing consultant work for Intel sitting in India. We never know the company.

Let's say I start an company. You know how much investment i have to do to market those products initially? It would even more than chip design investment. If I am designing an PCB I will go with ICs which has a proven track record and brand name. Moreover everything is not about Processors and comparison with Intel or ARM. The MP or MC manufacturing quantity is less than associated chips like from Texas Instruments or STM which are simple logical.ICs. they are the ones manufactured in hundreds of millions and we need to bring the manufacturing here. Only then a chip design company can start fab here, do testing with less time and try to market.

No one can jump to the level Intel is today just by having money. Intel has more product which never even came to the market and has planned product release for the next 5 years. Let's say if they release I9 this year, they would have tested till I13 by now. But they will release it slowly. How can anyone match that?
 
.
What’s the purpose of this post besides to defame Indian-Americans? If the person in question was not non-Indian, would the author say the same thing?
 
.
What’s the purpose of this post besides to defame Indian-Americans? If the person in question was not non-Indian, would the author say the same thing?

Agree with this. His being an Indian is inconsequential to his rise and downfall at Intel.
 
.
What’s the purpose of this post besides to defame Indian-Americans? If the person in question was not non-Indian, would the author say the same thing?

If there was no India, would PDF even exist or have any traffic?
Answer this and you’ll have your answer.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom