What's new

Half of metro bus fleet unutilised in twin cities

mr42O

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Aug 15, 2009
Messages
6,178
Reaction score
4
Country
Pakistan
Location
Norway
RAWALPINDI: Only 35 metro buses are operating between the twin cities of Rawalpindi and Islamabad, while the other half are still parked at the bus depot, due to a lukewarm response from commuters.

The Punjab government procured 68 metro buses to run between Rawalpindi and Islamabad, on a route that cost Rs44.8 billion to construct. The project is considered one of the most expensive in the country.

A senior official from the Rawalpindi Development Authority (RDA) told Dawn that less than 30 buses were operating on the metro bus route due to a lack of passengers.

He said that 80,000 passengers, on average, use the service to commute between the twin cities daily, despite the government’s claim that 150,000 passengers would use the service every day.

He said the government’s estimates had proven incorrect, and that the number of commuters had not increased in six months. He added that the government planned to procure 32 more buses, since it constructed a bus depot at Peshawar Mor that can accommodate over 100 buses.

Only 35 buses operating between twin cities due to a shortage of passengers
He also said that, at many stations, elevators were not being used by senior citizens as they were defected. He said that most people relied on the escalators and stairs rather than the elevators.

“Third party evaluation of the project will start soon, after the project’s two main components – the Peshawar Mor interchange and the command and control building – have been completed. These issues will appear before the government after this,” he said.

However, many bus stations have seen crowds and long queues – which the passengers blame on a shortage of buses. “I tried to catch the bus at Chandni Chowk to go to Saddar, and after waiting for 20 minutes, I couldn’t find a seat because people were crammed into the buses coming from Islamabad,” Ashar Ahmed, a passenger, said.

Another passenger, Mohammad Naseem, said the bus service was good, but that the government needed to increase the number of buses operating on the route.

He said the government was saving fuel and running fewer buses. “An artificial crowd was created deliberately to show that people thronged to metro bus stations to avail the service provided by the government,” he claimed.

The Metro Bus Project Monitoring Committee chairperson, former MNA Hanif Abbasi, confirmed that half of the total fleet of buses was being used due to lower passenger numbers.

He said that, at present, 35 buses are operating on the route, and that the operational manager would increase the number of buses when the number of passengers increases.

He said that, at present, 130,000 people travel between Rawalpindi and Islamabad on the metro bus.

When contacted, Rawalpindi Commissioner Sajid Zafar Dall said more than 35 buses were operating, to cater to 135,000 daily commuters.

Published in Dawn, January 7th, 2016


Half of metro bus fleet unutilised in twin cities - Pakistan - DAWN.COM
 
. .
They are just Had Harram and want to save fuel and make more money...
from 8am-6pm there never is a chance to get a seat easily while from 12-3pm you can just dream!
Yeah after 6pm there is some space to get seats in bus and travel with some dignity!
 
.
They are just Had Harram and want to save fuel and make more money...
from 8am-6pm there never is a chance to get a seat easily while from 12-3pm you can just dream!
Yeah after 6pm there is some space to get seats in bus and travel with some dignity!
where is the person who is supposed to manage these of which timing needs more buses? oh wait maybe its too costly to run soo many buses....it is probably cheaper to run less buses

mismanagement zindabad!
 
.
It takes time to adopt as same situation was there in Lahore. Secondly whatever people say about metro it is still serving thousands every day. People dont change their habbits over nights like using cheap wagons for transport. They are still cheapest source of travel in twin cities.
 
.
He said that 80,000 passengers, on average, use the service to commute between the twin cities daily, despite the government’s claim that 150,000 passengers would use the service every day.

He said that, at present, 130,000 people travel between Rawalpindi and Islamabad on the metro bus.

Which one is right ???
 
.
It takes time to adopt as same situation was there in Lahore. Secondly whatever people say about metro it is still serving thousands every day. People dont change their habbits over nights like using cheap wagons for transport. They are still cheapest source of travel in twin cities.
when you spend as much as Noon spent you EXPECT 100% efficiency... no room for slacking , ignorance and diverted priorities
 
.
Which one is right ???

U tell me :)

A senior official from the Rawalpindi Development Authority (RDA) told Dawn that less than 30 buses were operating and 80,000 passengers, on average, use the service to commute between the twin cities daily, despite the government’s claim that 150,000 passengers would use the service every day.

The Metro Bus Project Monitoring Committee chairperson, former MNA Hanif Abbasi, said 35 buses are operating and 130,000 are traveling

When contacted, Rawalpindi Commissioner Sajid Zafar Dall said more than 35 buses were operating, to cater to 135,000 daily commuters.
 
. . .
I believe the early lack of availability and delays may have put off consumers. However, a good way to bring them back would be to place greater taxes on the ownership of private vehicles in the area.
 
.
I believe the early lack of availability and delays may have put off consumers. However, a good way to bring them back would be to place greater taxes on the ownership of private vehicles in the area.

That won't work as people would find ways around it in a corrupt society such as ours and plus the oil and automotive lobbies would strongly resist such moves and I am not sure they wont be wrong - The better option is to give them no choice by levying usurious charges and tolls in peak times like in London.
 
.
That won't work as people would find ways around it in a corrupt society such as ours and plus the oil and automotive lobbies would strongly resist such moves and I am not sure they wont be wrong - The better option is to give them no choice by levying usurious charges and tolls in peak times like in London.

That is not going to happen in any case even if happens it won't help, because Metro for these twin cities mainly suits government employees who commute from Rawalpindi to Islamabad. The route for this bus also suggests that. For majority metro is useless and suppose if the government really wants to increase its utilization by forceful means................. It should crackdown on rampant sale of bikes on installments and license issuing for bikes, lesser bikes would help the environment and better traffic management on roads and fewer nuisances. Otherwise metro would see increase in passengers numbers in summers only :lol:
 
.
That is not going to happen in any case even if happens it won't help, because Metro for these twin cities mainly suits government employees who commute from Rawalpindi to Islamabad. The route for this bus also suggests that. For majority metro is useless and suppose if the government really wants to increase its utilization by forceful means................. It should crackdown on rampant sale of bikes on installments and license issuing for bikes, lesser bikes would help the environment and better traffic management on roads and fewer nuisances. Otherwise metro would see increase in passengers numbers in summers only :lol:

Thanks! I was making a general point as I am utterly unaware of the geography, traffic patterns and distances involved.

However your arguments suggest that Metro has a very limited demand restricted to the Govt employees in that case wasn't the feasibility done? In resource restricted poor countries like India and Pakistan it is imperative that we don't go for vanity projects and instead look for optimum allocation of resources. This is one reason why I dont favor HSR in India
 
.
Thanks! I was making a general point as I am utterly unaware of the geography, traffic patterns and distances involved.

However your arguments suggest that Metro has a very limited demand restricted to the Govt employees in that case wasn't the feasibility done? In resource restricted poor countries like India and Pakistan it is imperative that we don't go for vanity projects and instead look for optimum allocation of resources. This is one reason why I dont favor HSR in India

No problem.

Frankly I have no idea about any feasibility reports for this project and have never heard if such reports were ever made public, but what I concluded from media talks and hearing to people is that this was more of a political decision, may be to increase and please the vote bank as PMLN lost in Rawalpindi one of their strong holds in 2013.

About resource utilization …… I don't know about India but Pakistan has not seen a government for long time that had its priorities right when it comes to development projects, the ranking critical, urgent, can wait seems missing. Plus another thing that happens in Pakistan is any positive project initiated by predecessors for helping people is not supported and is made to shutdown sometimes immediately and at others slowly by cutting its budgets, the only projects that are carried are the ones that give the opportunity of increasing the vote bank and making some money.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom