Rot sets in’ at Shaikh Zayed Hospital
By
Asif Chaudhry
Published Dec 03, 2013 07:53am
Comment
Print
LAHORE, Dec 2: Shaikh Zayed Hospital is facing some administrative, academic and financial challenges which are being seen as the emerging crisis in coming days if the government continues to be indifferent to its affairs.
The hospital was known as one of the state-of-the-art institutes for the treatment of top bureaucrats and other VIP patients with more than Rs400 million annual budget when it was under the administrative control of the cabinet division.
The issues started piling up since it was transferred to the Punjab government in February 2012 along with all other components, an official privy to the development told Dawn.
The components included Shaikh Khalifa Zayed Bin Sultan Al Nahyan Medical and Dental College, Shaikh Zayed Postgraduate Medical Institute and Sheikh Fatima Institute of Nursing and Health Sciences.
“The institute is fast losing its dignity both in medical and healthcare sectors and one of the major factors behind its downfall is said to be the indifferent attitude of the Punjab government,” he said.
He said Shaikh Zayed Hospital suffered a major dent in the form of drastic annual budget cut which was reduced from Rs480 million to Rs220 million. The budget curtailment adversely affected financial, administrative, academic and even service care matters.
The official said: “It is yet unclear as to who will run it – the Punjab government or the federal government – as a parliamentary panel has again recommended to giving back administrative control of the Sheikh Zayed Hospital, Lahore, to the federal government.”
He said the Senate Standing Committee on National Health Services, Regulations and Coordination in its recommendations in October this year stated that the patients and employees had been suffering ever since its control was given to the Punjab province.
Owing to the financial crunch, the hospital has been facing an acute shortage of medicines and funds for salaries of faculty, doctors as well as other employees.
“Currently, the institute is facing a deficit of approximately Rs220 million and the major factor is annual budget cut.
“Inactive Board of Governors (BoG) is another critical issue which has brought several affairs of the institute to almost ‘standstill’. The Punjab government has failed to reconstitute BoG of the institute since it got its administrative control,” he said.
The official said the Punjab government had constituted a transition committee. Headed by Senator Ishaq Dar, the committee was given full mandate to run all matters of the institute in the absence of the BoG.
Unfortunately, the official said, the committee did not meet for the last one year or so as Ishaq Dar could not spare time.
Shortage of senior faculty and financial crisis of Shaikh Khalifa Zayed Bin Sultan Al Nahyan Medical and Dental College have also emerged as major problems as the Punjab government has recently reduced its fee structure from Rs400,000 to Rs41,000 only.
“Neither the government has allocated funds for tuition fee against allocated seats for the college nor evolved any proposal in this regard.
“The college does not have its own faculty and more than 25 medical teachers have been hired to impart education to undergraduates from the Shaikh Zayed Postgraduate Medical Institute for the last five year or so,” he said.
These teachers were being paid each Rs100,000 as additional monthly incentive since then. “As the major source of their salaries was the handsome tuition fee structure of the medical college, its administration has no funds to pay them due to revised fee structure,” he said, adding that the college is still functioning without its own faculty.
Shaikh Zayed Hospital Chairman/Dean Prof Dr Zafar Iqbal is going to retire from his service by June and Professor of Anaesthesia Dr Muhammad Nauman Ali is said to be the next contender for this top post for being senior among his colleagues.
The official said: “Since the BoG and the transition committee are not active, the selection of a suitable candidate as head of the institute may delay.
Health Additional Secretary (Technical) and Focal Person for Shaikh Zayed Hospital Dr Anwar Janjua clarified the position of the government saying that the Board of Trustees of the institute is the supreme body which actually reconstitutes BoG.
He said as the Board of Trustees was also to be reconstituted, the health department had sent a summary to the Punjab chief minister to forward it to the President of Pakistan a year ago.
“The President of Pakistan is the chairman/patron-in-chief of the Board of Trustees. As a representative of King of UAE is also made a member of the board, the process of its constitution may take time,” he said.
About scarcity of funds and faculty, Dr Janjua said he had already asked the SZH chairman to submit a proposal to the finance department for the supplementary grant to run financial affairs of the institute.
He said the health department had not yet received any proposal from the institute to forward it to the authorities concerned for subsidised medical education.
Ward woes: In Rawalpindi hospitals, everything is at own risk
By
Fawad Ali /
Photo: Zafar Aslam
Published: June 5, 2014
Share this articlePrint this pageEmail
Patients and attendants wait in outside in the lawn due to the boiling-hot waiting rooms. PHOTO: ZAFAR ASLAM/ EXPRESS
RAWALPINDI:
Barriers at main entrances, unreasonably high parking fees and cramped waiting lounges have compounded the problems of patients and visitors to the allied hospitals.
Contractors have been awarded parking contracts charging the motorists at will. They charge Rs10 per hour for a motorcycle and Rs30 for a car, yet the receipt still reads, ‘Parking at your own risk’.
Visitors from other cities such as Chakwal, Attock, or Azad Jammu and Kashmir also complained about being overcharged parking fees.
“My mother has been admitted here for a week and I had to pay Rs1,000 as car parking fee to the contractor at the District Headquarters (DHQ) Hospital,” said Wahid Saeed.
“We have paid Rs5.7 million to get the contract. We also have to pay our staff,” said Altaf, who collects parking fees at the main gate of DHQ hospital.
Parking conditions at Benazir Bhutto Hospital (BBH) are even worse.
Bikes and cars are left in no-parking areas to avoid paying parking fees, making it difficult for patients, especially those with limited physical mobility, to even enter the hospital.
As a result of this, scuffles between visitors and parking contractors are a common sight at BBH.
“Why should I pay the fee if I have to park my motorcycle at my own risk,” a visitor wrangled with a contractor when he saw the receipt handed to him at the gate.
Blocked entrances
Barriers placed at the entrances to the three main public hospitals — DHQ, BBH and Holy Family Hospital — to regulate the traffic have also created difficulties for walk-in patients who must duck and weave their way in.
Besides, the doorways of various wards are blocked with chains, which are opened only in an emergency. Patients, including the elderly and women, have to either cross over the chains or go through the narrow space on one side.
The pain of waiting
According to figures provided by the hospital administrations, around 4,000 people visit the three hospitals every day.
Unfortunately, waiting lounges in the hospitals, which already have limited seating, also lack fans and clean drinking water. Most of the water coolers installed at the hospitals are in poor shape and visitors are forced to purchase bottled water.
When asked about the parking fee, the DHQ medical superintendent said he can only comment after reading the contract and hung up. BBH MS Asif Qadir Mir was not available for comment
Published in The Express Tribune, June 5th, 2014.
Govt’s claims of healthcare provision fall short
By
The Newspaper's Correspondent
Updated 2 days ago
The social and public circles have appealed to Interior Minister Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan to take note of the deplorable condition of the THQ hospital. - File photo
TAXILA: Punjab chief minister’s much publicised health reforms programme seems like a distant dream for the residents of Taxila and Wah Cantonment.
Tehsil Headquarters (THQ) Hospital Taxila has proved that the only provincial government-run health facility in the twin cities is incapable of dealing with the large influx of patients, especially road accident victims. The patients have been deprived of basic medicines, even syringes and bandages, due to paucity of funds.
The 40-bed THQ hospital, which caters to the residents of Taxila and Wah Cantonment along with the neighbouring town of Khanpur, sees a large influx of about 154,000 patients per year.
Patients at THQ hospital have to bring their own medicines for treatment, while surgeries are conducted in candle light
However, the hospital only has a meagre Rs0.8 million sanctioned budget for medicines.
Keeping in view the number of patients, the budget expires during the first three months.
For the rest of the year, the poor patients, even those coming in for emergency cases, have to bring their own medicines, syringes and bandages for treatment.
Due to the absence of lifesaving drugs, patients, especially road accident victims, either die here or on their way to hospitals in Rawalpindi.
Sources say that there are 87 lifesaving drugs that the Punjab government announced it would provide to patients in emergencies, but only a few of these are available at the trauma centre.
The hospital also has limited funds for generator fuel, resultantly, during the loadshedding hours, small operations and labour deliveries are conducted under candle or torch light.
A number of patients told Dawn that 90 per cent of them bring their own medicines from the open market, as they are even denied basic medicines at the hospital.
A patient, Perveen, said: “We are poor people and cannot afford the costly treatment at private hospitals, but we have failed to get any relief here at the government hospital, despite the tall claims of the provincial government, which, using electronic and print media, made announcements of provision of better healthcare facilities to the people.”
Sources say that THQ hospitals in Kahuta and Gujar Khan, which see lesser number of patients per year, get funds worth Rs3.8 million and Rs4 million for medicines, respectively, while THQ Hospital Taxila gets merely Rs0.8 million, despite catering to a large number of patients.
When contacted, THQ Hospital Taxila Medical Superintendent Dr Mohammad Shahid confirmed that the hospital has limited funds of Rs0.8 million, which is insufficient to deal with the high number of patients. Therefore indoor and outdoor patients are asked to bring their own medicines from the local market.
He added that around 700 patients visit the Out-Patient Department (OPD) of the hospital daily.
The social and public circles have appealed to Interior Minister Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan to take note of the deplorable condition of the THQ hospital, which is in dire need of basic facilities, for the poor patients of his own constituency.
Published in Dawn, July 16th, 2014