FIR against Zee News for airing Charlie Hebdo cartoons

[livingdead]

On an occasion when Gautama Buddha was teaching a group of people, he found himself on the receiving end of a fierce outburst of abuse from a bystander, who was for some reason very angry.
The Buddha listened patiently while the stranger vented his rage, and then the Buddha said to the group and to the stranger, “If someone gives a gift to another person, who then chooses to decline it, tell me, who would then own the gift? The giver, or the person who refuses to accept the gift?”
“The giver,” said the group after a little thought. “Any fool can see that,” added the angry stranger.
“Then it follows, does it not,” said the Buddha, “Whenever a person tries to abuse us, or to unload their anger on us, we can each choose to decline or to accept the abuse; whether to make it ours or not. By our personal response to the abuse from another, we can choose who owns and keeps the bad feelings.

small correction: the cartoon in question shows mohamed in good light and not abusive.

 

[ares]

@Zarvan @Selous Can you explain it to her?


In every country where Muslim reside. Doesn't concern you so I suggest you take a hike.

Muslims reside in every country on the planet and the blasphemy laws exist in but a handful.
And it does concern me, for you are talking of murder and terrorism.

 

[mujhaidind]

Muslims reside in every country on the planet and the blasphemy laws exist in but a handful.
And it does concern me, for you are talking of murder and terrorism.

How so?
Muslims can tolerate dis-respect ever towards even their mother and children. But mocking our prophet is beyond forgiveness.

 

[itachiii]

think of this... will indian military/paramilitary/police ever attack sangh parivar camps and offices like they attack maoists or like how pakistan army attacks taliban??
.

did rss/sangh pose as a threat to india ever ??

 

[Razia Sultana]

@Zarvan @Selous Can you explain it to her?

I dont need any explanation but specially for you I will give a story about our prophet mohammad (saw). -
It is about an old woman who made a habit of throwing trash in the way of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (saw) whenever he passed by her house. She tried her best to irritate him by throwing garbage in his way every day. One day, when he walked out of his home there was no garbage. This made the Prophet inquire about the old woman and he came to know that she was sick. The Prophet went to visit her and offer any assistance she might need. The old woman was extremely humbled and at the same time ashamed of her actions in light of the concern that the Prophet showed her.

Why cant we learn from our own prophet to be tolerant.

I dont need any explanation but specially for you I will give a story about our prophet mohammad (saw). -
It is about an old woman who made a habit of throwing trash in the way of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (saw) whenever he passed by her house. She tried her best to irritate him by throwing garbage in his way every day. One day, when he walked out of his home there was no garbage. This made the Prophet inquire about the old woman and he came to know that she was sick. The Prophet went to visit her and offer any assistance she might need. The old woman was extremely humbled and at the same time ashamed of her actions in light of the concern that the Prophet showed her.
Why cant we learn from our own prophet to be tolerant.

 

[ares]

How so?
Muslims can tolerate dis-respect ever towards even their mother and children. But mocking our prophet is beyond forgiveness.

It is murder / terror because there exist no blasphemy law for any Gods or prophets of any religion whatsoever or tomorrow Hindus will argue since cow is considered God like Hinduism, anyone found slaughtering a Cow, should be executed as well.

As long as the person in question has or intends to physical harm or kill you. His/Her/Their killing for any assumed offences against your prophet or God will be considered Murder/Terrorism.

 

[jamahir]

What should Muslims do? Don't post your socialist mantra. Be realistic.

sincerely, there have been 200,000+ syrians dead since 2011 through conspiracy arranged by western governments... more western people have protested against their own governments about the syrian war than have indian muslims... we, the muslims of india, must begin forming protest committees against the western government aggression against syria.

s.m. krishna was in 2011 seen openly attending meetings with nato leaders in the so-called "friends of syria" conferences... india muslims should call out s.m. krishna about his attendances.

Can you tell me what is the difference between Pramod Muttalik and Akbarudin Owaisi and why shouldn't they be alive?

come on... just so that you appear fair, you need not support pramod mutalik and ram sena.

Really??? Are they even comparable? How many armed training camps do they have? How many terror attacks have they conducted? That is the problem with many muslims a lot of hatred for other religions/certain organizations is deeply in grained in their thinking. They just can not think straight..

rss and its affiliates are a bunch of murderous hooligans with delusions about religious mythology... they are the original for later groups like taliban or contemporary ones like ikhwaan.

what is their laathi training for... certainly not for breaking the backs of dogs... what is durga vahini for... certainly not for escorting ladies to performing arts programs.

rss camps should be taken care of by indian government forces... i demand this.

a kafir false-prophet who believed in atheism.

there have been greek philosphers whose works were forwarded by muslim philosphers during the "islami golden age"... those greeks also spoke of human miseries and the wrongs of society... if they are acceptable then so is buddha... hope you understand.

 

[Razia Sultana]

small correction: the cartoon in question shows mohamed in good light and not abusive.

Whatever. but we dont like to picturize our prophet, forget about drawing a cartoon whether praising him or otherwise. But I would want my brothers worldwide to be tolerant and just ignore it.

 

[jamahir]

did rss/sangh pose as a threat to india ever ??

rss and sangh are anti-female anti-male anti-sensibility anti-progress anti-justice anti-socialism anti-human.

The same group has a Islamic channel also.

this is their "expert" on islam... ( http://zeesalaam.com/anchors-experts/shagufta-yasmin/ )

born in kuwait... certainly looks no fan of saddam hussain.

but the below lady seems something...

http://zeesalaam.com/anchors-experts/sadia-khan/

 

[mujhaidind]

It is murder / terror because there exist no blasphemy law for any Gods or prophets of any religion whatsoever or tomorrow Hindus will argue since cow is considered God like Hinduism, anyone found slaughtering a Cow, should be executed as well.

As long as the person in question has or intends to physical harm or kill you. His/Her/Their killing for any assumed offences against your prophet or God will be considered Murder/Terrorism.

The reason why Hindus don't get offended by cow sluaghter is because they know how ridicoulous and bizzare their beliefs are. That's the reason why even Muslims continute and will always continue to slaughter cows irrespective of the laws.

On other Islam is the only true religion and prophet mohammad(pbuh) was the greatest person to ever walk on this planet. So Muslims tolerating any disrespect towards him is out of question.

 

[Razia Sultana]

come on... just so that you appear fair, you need not support pramod mutalik and ram sena.

I can never support the likes of pramod mutalik and his ram sena. They are a fit case to be banned in India. Also I can not support akbaruddin owaisi although I find his brother Asaduddin Owaisi very mature.

 

[livingdead]

Whatever. but we dont like to picturize our prophet, forget about drawing a cartoon whether praising him or otherwise. But I would want my brothers worldwide to be tolerant and just ignore it.

I understand its a islamic practice(pretty sure there is some theological reason behind it). A non muslim not following islamic practice is not offensive.
BTW out of curiosity: what is the theological position about showing face of jesus in islam?

 

[Cheetah786]

Yeah there were no Hindu religious leaders calling for his death. Unlike Salman Rushdie or Taslima Nasreen.

That's because their aren't any books written by opportunist Hindu against Gita by a Hindu. As far as people being killed for their religious beliefs, don't even for a second deny that doesn't happen in india. So off your holier then though attitude.

 

[ares]

The reason why Hindus don't get offended by cow sluaghter is because they know how ridicoulous and bizzare their beliefs are. That's the reason why even Muslims continute and will always continue to slaughter cows irrespective of the laws.

On other Islam is the only true religion and prophet mohammad(pbuh) was the greatest person to ever walk on this planet. So Muslims tolerating any disrespect towards him is out of question.

Well this exactly what other people think about your beliefs also, that is why this entire Charlie Hebdo episode happen and every civilised country on the planet came in their support.

Every one has right to consider other's beliefs are ridiculous or bizzare, just like how I considers yours are or you consider mine are, but that not give you the right to murder me or me the right to murder you.

As far Islam being the only true religion and Prophet the greatest person, there are 5.5 Billion people on this planet, who disagree with this notion, and there ain't a thing you can do about it.

 

[livingdead]

That's because their aren't any books written by opportunist Hindu against Gita by a Hindu. As far as people being killed for their religious beliefs, don't even for a second deny that doesn't happen in india. So off your holier then though attitude.

there is a difference between inter religious violence, which is basically violence between two groups. It happens between tribes, castes, and even linguistic group.
I have not heard any hindu trying to kill another hindu for offending his religious belief by writing a book or making a movie. Yes people have written (especially lower caste authors) criticizing hinduism.. most probably because they are oppressed.