What's new

Fake News: PSO makes costliest purchase of LNG cargo

Norwegian

BANNED
Joined
Aug 19, 2014
Messages
19,001
Reaction score
11
Country
Israel
Location
Norway
PSO makes costliest purchase of LNG cargo
Khaleeq Kiani Published August 3, 2021 - Updated about 6 hours ago

As a result of the expensive LNG cargoes acquired through spot market by PSO and PPL,  the weighted average sale price for LNG (excluding GST) was notified by the Ogra at $13.61 per MMBTU for August. — Reuters/File

As a result of the expensive LNG cargoes acquired through spot market by PSO and PPL, the weighted average sale price for LNG (excluding GST) was notified by the Ogra at $13.61 per MMBTU for August. — Reuters/File
ISLAMABAD: Making a new record, the state-run Pakistan State Oil (PSO) has purchased a cargo of liquefied natural gas (LNG) at $20.055 per unit (almost 27.9pc of Brent), the highest ever not only in the country but perhaps the second highest summer purchase in the world.
This comes at a time when the government was justifying $15.5 per million British thermal unit (MMBTU) purchases by Pakistan LNG Limited (PLL), another state-run entity, as the lesser evil when compared with alternative fuels.
As a result of the expensive LNG cargoes acquired through spot market by the two entities, the weighted average sale price for LNG (excluding GST) was notified by the Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority (Ogra) at $13.61 per MMBTU for August — up 5.5pc over July prices that were already 25pc expensive when compared to June.
The two entities — PSO and PLL — have of late stopped publishing their procurement rates, but this $20.05 per unit cargo was never conceded by the government. The LNG price notification for August, however, revealed that PSO purchased a cargo of 140,000 cubic meters (about 3.2 million units) at the precise rate of 27.8675pc of Brent or $20.0555 per unit.
The notification suggests that PSO’s average price of five other cargos from Qatar under a long-term contract was about $9.62 per unit at the rate of 13.37pc of Brent, but the most expensive 6th cargo jacked up its average DES (delivered ex-ship) price at $11.42 per unit. This resulted in PSO’s average price for six cargos going well above PLL’s average price for equal number of cargos.
On the other hand, PLL’s one cargo’s price for Qatar LNG stood at $8.6 per unit at the rate of 11.95pc of Brent, but its five other spot cargos ranged between $10.52 and $10.83 per unit. As such, PLL’s average DES price for six cargos worked out at $10.32 per unit when compared to PSO’s $11.42 per unit.
Informed sources said the $20.05 per unit LNG purchase in summer season was the second highest in the world after about $21 per unit procurement by South Korea in 2007-08. Winter LNG prices are a totally different ballgame as last year some cargo ranged between $24 and $36 per unit because of higher demand for heating as well as other uses.
The sources said that at these rates LNG was no more viable for power generation — the key consideration for Pakistan — but the country was also short of diesel and furnace oil to run power plants as electricity shortages affected consumers, particularly households in humid conditions. They said the nascent LNG supply chain could not fully recover from the dry docking of one of the LNG terminals as already fragile stockpile of fuel oils stood exhausted amid financial difficulties being faced by the suppliers and power generators.
These prices would be charged to certain consumers, including power plants, during the current month. Officials said the government entities had been compelled to purchase expensive LNG from spot market over the last couple of months and had to even cancel a series of bids for being too expensive but those cancelled also ranged between $11.6 and $13.99 per unit in these months.
Interestingly, PLL and PSO involved in LNG imports are keeping the bid results secret to avoid public criticism. As a result, only final weighted average sale price for a month computed by Ogra is made public. However, the expensive spot bids are generally camouflaged because of cheaper long-term supply contracts from Qatar. Interestingly, Ogra is not authorised to question the prudent cost of imports and is compelled to only compute the weighted average LNG price of 10-12 vessels per month.
Last week, the government conceded in a public statement that the PLL board was forced to accept four LNG “spot” tenders at about $15 per MMBTU for September 2021, as the lesser evil, otherwise the replacement fuel (furnace oil), which is even more expensive, would have resulted in September power prices higher by at least 20pc.
Published in Dawn, August 3rd, 2021

1627982761365.png
 
.
Hi,

Khaleeq Kiani is not wrong here, Hammad Azhar and OGRA is. If the said tender was cancelled, why was it's price included even provisionally. PSO press release clarifies it and has put Hammad Azhar's "Fake news" claim in a bad light. There is no denying of mismanagement at Ministry of Energy(MOE), specially after change in top management in Petroleum Division(PD).


There are transparency issues with the way recent Lng procurement have been made. Specially for one cargo purchased in July and the recently awarded cargoes for September delivery, whose neither invitation for bid nor evaluation, have been published on PLL or PPRA websites. Both these spot tenders were issued after the change in PD management. Press has a just right to grill government representatives on it.



Also for some inexplicable reason, SNGPL has stopped uploading these provisional RLNG price assessments on their website.


If these transparency issues were to surface during Pmln/ PPP eras, IK and his supporters (including myself) would not have been kind enough to use words like 'mismanagement' or 'incompetency' to describe it.
 
. .
Hi,

Khaleeq Kiani is not wrong here, Hammad Azhar and OGRA is. If the said tender was cancelled, why was it's price included even provisionally. PSO press release clarifies it and has put Hammad Azhar's "Fake news" claim in a bad light. There is no denying of mismanagement at Ministry of Energy(MOE), specially after change in top management in Petroleum Division(PD).


There are transparency issues with the way recent Lng procurement have been made. Specially for one cargo purchased in July and the recently awarded cargoes for September delivery, whose neither invitation for bid nor evaluation, have been published on PLL or PPRA websites. Both these spot tenders were issued after the change in PD management. Press has a just right to grill government representatives on it.



Also for some inexplicable reason, SNGPL has stopped uploading these provisional RLNG price assessments on their website.


If these transparency issues were to surface during Pmln/ PPP eras, IK and his supporters (including myself) would not have been kind enough to use words like 'mismanagement' or 'incompetency' to describe it.

The government who won the election on the slogan of TRANSPARENCY is hiding facts from public.
 
.
The government who won the election on the slogan of TRANSPARENCY is hiding facts from public.
Cant conceal the facts for long!
RLNG price hike notice withdrawn by Ogra

In a rare development, the Oil & Gas Regulatory Authority (Ogra) on Tuesday retracted a notification it issued a day earlier that increased the prices of regasified liquefied natural gas (RLNG) by more than 5.5 per cent for the current month on the basis of an expensive $20.055 per mmBtu cargo.

“As informed by PSO (Pakistan State Oil) that they have scrapped the cargo with offered price of 27.87pc of Brent, RLNG price notified on 2nd August is no more valid and August RLNG price notification is being withdrawn,” said a revised notification issued by the regulator.

Informed sources said the regulator had to withdraw the notification under pressure from the Ministry of Energy which came under public criticism for acquiring expensive LNG import cargo amid mismanagement of various fuels as power consumers faced the brunt of loadshedding in humid weather conditions despite purported surplus generation capacity.

Energy Minister Hammad Azhar, through his social media account, made a scathing attack on a Dawn report that showed PSO’s costliest cargo in the Ogra’s RLNG notification, alleging “fake reporting”, knowing little that the Ogra notification was based on PSO’s own data. His ministry did not issue any press statement.


PSO too, in a separate social media statement, denied that it had contracted the expensive deal in the spot market and claimed it had scrapped the bid and re-invited fresh bid, saying it had scrapped the bid as it was ‘high’ and ‘unacceptable’. The country’s largest company by revenue and largest fuel supplier, however, did not show bid results and its decision to scrap the bid on its official website.

Informed sources said that following the Dawn report based on official notification, PSO informed Ogra through an email about its decision to scrap the expensive bid offer. Ogra withdrew the earlier RLNG sale price notification.

PSO also denied keeping the bid results secret, insisting that it always maintains absolute transparency in all its business dealings and practices but did not show on its website where these results were made public. “All bid results are published on PSO’s website as per Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) rules,” it added.

The company said it had entered into a new long-term supply contract with Qatar Petroleum (QP), supplies against which will start in January 2022 and this will further reduce the basket price of LNG being imported in the country. This deal was announced early this year by then SAPM Nadeem Babar.

Considering the higher demand in the upcoming winter season, PSO has exercised the option in the new QP contract for bringing four additional cargoes in November and December at the new contractual prices, which are expected to be much lower than the market price during winter, it said.

Ogra said the it had issued the RLNG price notification that was computed based on available data at the time of computation. “Since prices are for the month in advance, many pricing components are calculated for determination of prices on a provisional basis based on available data at that time, which was later actualised by Ogra based on actual costs incurred”.

By the time, however, thousands of motorists using compressed natural gas (CNG) as transport fuel, had been charged at the higher rates already notified a day earlier who could not be traced or verified to have been overcharged.

The Aug 2 notification issued by Ogra regarding “determination of LNG weighted average sale provisional price” said the LNG price for the month was computed in the light of federal government’s decision on LNG allocation and pricing and advice from the Ministry of Energy.

The LNG Prices notified by Ogra — and as mentioned in the Dawn report — were based on data/prices provided by PSO. Ogra doesn’t have its own data gathering mechanism about LNG and solely relies on prices contracted by and reported by LNG importers — PSO and Pakistan LNG Ltd (PLL).

Prior to the report, PSO had not issued a public statement about cancellation or tendering. Till filing of this report late in the night, Ogra had not issued any fresh RLNG price notification.

 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom