What's new

Even Bangladesh has a higher GDP than India, says Mitra

Black_cats

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 31, 2010
Messages
10,031
Reaction score
-5
Even Bangladesh has a higher GDP than India, says Mitra
c0472c34d36b971d22d8372fc65d8813
SNS Web
5 hours ago

QT-amit-mitra-1024x683.jpg


Bengal Chamber of Commerce and Industry (BCC&I) DG Subhodip Ghosh, West Bengal Finance Minister Amit Mitra, BCC&I Outgoing President Indrajit Sen, Former SEBI Chairman M. Damodaran and BCC&I President Designate B.B.Chatterjee during the 165th Annual General Meeting of Bengal Chamber of Commerce and Industry, in Kolkata on Sep 23, 2019. (Photo: IANS)


The country’s economic growth rate is so slow that even Bangladesh has a higher GDP while China had already surpassed us, said state finance and industry minister Amit Mitra at Nabanna today.

“We are now facing the worst situation with not only inflation on one side or stagnation on the other but both of them together. We have a sort of “stagflation” situation wherein the inflation rate is high, unemployment is the highest in 45 years and GDP is very low,” Mr Mitra said.

Mr Mitra blamed the Centre for its failed policies including demonetisation, which is one of the prime reasons behind the economic slowdown. “Demonetisation was a shock. Within seven weeks, before the shock could be absorbed, came another shock ~ the unprepared GST. Prior to demonetisation our GDP growth was 8.1 per cent and now it has dipped to 5 per cent.

The growth rates of both China and Bangladesh are higher than India. While China had already surpassed India in the growth rate, it is now Bangladesh which has recorded a higher growth rate” said Mr Mitra. Deliberating on the low economic growth of the country, Mr Mitra said that eight core sectors ~ steel, cement, electricity, coal, crude oil, refinery products, fertilisers and natural gas ~ recorded negative 5.8 per cent growth rate in October.

There has been a dip in export and the total investment has plummeted, he added. Mr Mitra also slammed the Centre over unpaid GST dues and said that Bengal is not getting paid the compensation and this is a violation of constitutional provisions. The state government had approached the Centre several times to clear the pending GST dues.

Mr Mitra held a pre-budget discussion with chambers of commerce and trade bodies at Nabanna Sabhaghar to get feedback from the business side. “Today we had a very fruitful discussion with representatives of the various chambers and trade associations to know about their expectations from the state budget,” he said.

Mr Mitra said that the chambers and the trade bodies had given their views to the government on the budget. The state government would weigh all the pros and cons before incorporating their views in the budget, he added.

www.thestatesman.com/bengal/even-bangladesh-higher-gdp-india-says-mitra-1502845455.html/amp
 
You mean GDP growth? India still has a higher GDP per capita.
 
Per capita Income wise Bangladesh is ahead. In terms of per capita GDP Bangladesh has higher gdp than West Bengal. That could be another reason.
India's GDP per capita is close to $2000 while Bangladesh is around $1500. How is that possible?
 
India's GDP per capita is close to $2000 while Bangladesh is around $1500. How is that possible?

You are looking into wrong data. Now Bangladesh’s per capita gdp is 1906 USD and India’s 2172 USD. However India measure’s gdp based on 2011 base year and Bangladesh based on 2005 base year. With upgradation of base year it is expected Bangladesh’s per capita gdp will get a boost of 10-15% which makes both Bangladesh and India’s per capita gdp almost equal. With higher growth it’s just matter of time Bangladesh will overtake India’s per capita gdp officially.
 
Why does india media always say "even" bangladesh? Like its so hard to match indian gdp growth of 5 percent? Wtf these ppl are smoking. Most third world countries have higher gdp growth then india.
India is one of very few third world economies growing at below 5 percent. India has to grow 9 percent to create employment of its 1.3 billion ppl which soon will over take even china in terms of population. Good luck!
 
Even Bangladesh has a higher GDP than India, says Mitra
c0472c34d36b971d22d8372fc65d8813
SNS Web
5 hours ago

QT-amit-mitra-1024x683.jpg


Bengal Chamber of Commerce and Industry (BCC&I) DG Subhodip Ghosh, West Bengal Finance Minister Amit Mitra, BCC&I Outgoing President Indrajit Sen, Former SEBI Chairman M. Damodaran and BCC&I President Designate B.B.Chatterjee during the 165th Annual General Meeting of Bengal Chamber of Commerce and Industry, in Kolkata on Sep 23, 2019. (Photo: IANS)


The country’s economic growth rate is so slow that even Bangladesh has a higher GDP while China had already surpassed us, said state finance and industry minister Amit Mitra at Nabanna today.

“We are now facing the worst situation with not only inflation on one side or stagnation on the other but both of them together. We have a sort of “stagflation” situation wherein the inflation rate is high, unemployment is the highest in 45 years and GDP is very low,” Mr Mitra said.

Mr Mitra blamed the Centre for its failed policies including demonetisation, which is one of the prime reasons behind the economic slowdown. “Demonetisation was a shock. Within seven weeks, before the shock could be absorbed, came another shock ~ the unprepared GST. Prior to demonetisation our GDP growth was 8.1 per cent and now it has dipped to 5 per cent.

The growth rates of both China and Bangladesh are higher than India. While China had already surpassed India in the growth rate, it is now Bangladesh which has recorded a higher growth rate” said Mr Mitra. Deliberating on the low economic growth of the country, Mr Mitra said that eight core sectors ~ steel, cement, electricity, coal, crude oil, refinery products, fertilisers and natural gas ~ recorded negative 5.8 per cent growth rate in October.

There has been a dip in export and the total investment has plummeted, he added. Mr Mitra also slammed the Centre over unpaid GST dues and said that Bengal is not getting paid the compensation and this is a violation of constitutional provisions. The state government had approached the Centre several times to clear the pending GST dues.

Mr Mitra held a pre-budget discussion with chambers of commerce and trade bodies at Nabanna Sabhaghar to get feedback from the business side. “Today we had a very fruitful discussion with representatives of the various chambers and trade associations to know about their expectations from the state budget,” he said.

Mr Mitra said that the chambers and the trade bodies had given their views to the government on the budget. The state government would weigh all the pros and cons before incorporating their views in the budget, he added.

www.thestatesman.com/bengal/even-bangladesh-higher-gdp-india-says-mitra-1502845455.html/amp
When someone from India or Pakistan give the expression, ''even Bangladesh has higher'' to indicate any shortcoming of their own country, we should not take such expression uncritically. It is not any complement, but insult. It only indicate how they perceived Bangladesh in all those years. In their perception, Bangladesh was lowest of low for any denominator. Much much worse than India or Pakistan. In their fertile imagination, India or Pakistan was like USA and Bangladesh like Mexico or even worse, like Somalia. The underlying message is 'you know you are doing really really bad, when even a country like Bangladesh has overtaken you in this particular areas'.

Although even in 1970s and 1980s, the worst period in Bangladesh's history, it was not much behind than these two countries. Indian per capita GDP never reached anywhere closer twice of Bangladesh and for Pakistan it never gone beyond twice. Other socio-economic development indicators was also close by. But still they developed those attitude which still persists.
 
Last edited:
Per capita Income wise Bangladesh is ahead. In terms of per capita GDP Bangladesh has higher gdp than West Bengal. That could be another reason.
Quite wrong on all counts.
2019 BD GNI Per capita (current USD) 1909 (https://www.thedailystar.net/business/news/capita-income-hits-1909-1717606)
2018 India GNI Per Capita (current USD) 2020 (https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GNP.PCAP.CD?locations=IN&year_high_desc=true)

In terms of GDP Per capita (nominal) 2019, BD is : 1909 (IMF)
GDP Per Capita (nominal) 2019, IN is : 2171 (IMF)

I could not find any reliable source for West Bengal GDP Per Capita. I found Wikipedia mentioning USD 2000 but source was not proper. I did see many articles mentioning its growth rate 12.5+% over 2011 - 2019(https://economictimes.indiatimes.co...owth-rate-amit-mitra/articleshow/70621485.cms)

You are looking into wrong data. Now Bangladesh’s per capita gdp is 1906 USD and India’s 2172 USD. However India measure’s gdp based on 2011 base year and Bangladesh based on 2005 base year.
Then in 2021 India will update the base year and again get a boost of 10-15%.
 
Quite wrong on all counts.
2019 BD GNI Per capita (current USD) 1909 (https://www.thedailystar.net/business/news/capita-income-hits-1909-1717606)
2018 India GNI Per Capita (current USD) 2020 (https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GNP.PCAP.CD?locations=IN&year_high_desc=true)

In terms of GDP Per capita (nominal) 2019, BD is : 1909 (IMF)
GDP Per Capita (nominal) 2019, IN is : 2171 (IMF)

I could not find any reliable source for West Bengal GDP Per Capita. I found Wikipedia mentioning USD 2000 but source was not proper. I did see many articles mentioning its growth rate 12.5+% over 2011 - 2019(https://economictimes.indiatimes.co...owth-rate-amit-mitra/articleshow/70621485.cms)
Does it even matter 2171 vs 1900. Point is south asia is one of the poorest region in the world other then sub saharan africa. We have long way to go. Bangladesh or india ppl need good life good jobs good education... health care and good safety net.
 
Quite wrong on all counts.
2019 BD GNI Per capita (current USD) 1909 (https://www.thedailystar.net/business/news/capita-income-hits-1909-1717606)
2018 India GNI Per Capita (current USD) 2020 (https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GNP.PCAP.CD?locations=IN&year_high_desc=true)

In terms of GDP Per capita (nominal) 2019, BD is : 1909 (IMF)
GDP Per Capita (nominal) 2019, IN is : 2171 (IMF)

I could not find any reliable source for West Bengal GDP Per Capita. I found Wikipedia mentioning USD 2000 but source was not proper. I did see many articles mentioning its growth rate 12.5+% over 2011 - 2019(https://economictimes.indiatimes.co...owth-rate-amit-mitra/articleshow/70621485.cms)

INR has been depreciated against USD. Now based on latest data India's per capita income is 1787.28 USD based on present currency conversion rate.

The report says average per capita income in India is ₹10,534 a month in FY19 which translates to ₹126,408 an year.

https://www.livemint.com/politics/p...-rs-10-534-a-month-in-fy19-1559318636062.html

Then in 2021 India will update the base year and again get a boost of 10-15%.

India is unlikely to get boost 10-15%. It never gave India that kind of boost.
 
Yeah I also see india media refers to Sri Lanka as "even". Also met some loud mouthed Indians. Honeslty I pity them. First of all Sri Lanka has always been ahead of India even during war and 2nd, we don't even compare Sri Lanka with India but with South East Asia.
 
INR has been depreciated against USD. Now based on latest data India's per capita income is 1787.28 USD based on present currency conversion rate.
Both INR and Taka have depreciated since the USD rally in Mid to End 2018.

INR
upload_2020-1-15_10-9-53.png


Taka
upload_2020-1-15_10-10-31.png



If I use the latest conversion rate :


GDP:
India (INR 154,600.532) will give 2185 USD
BD ( BD Taka 164,762.890) will give 1942.05 USD
 
Yeah I also see india media refers to Sri Lanka as "even". Also met some loud mouthed Indians. Honeslty I pity them. First of all Sri Lanka has always been ahead of India even during war and 2nd, we don't even compare Sri Lanka with India but with South East Asia.
India can compare it self with Nigeria and Somalia to feel better. super power.
 
Both INR and Taka have depreciated since the USD rally in Mid to End 2018.

INR
View attachment 600023

Taka
View attachment 600024


If I use the latest conversion rate :


GDP:
India (INR 154,600.532) will give 2185 USD
BD ( BD Taka 164,762.890) will give 1942.05 USD

Where did you get the figure INR 154600? It is ₹126,408 yearly per capita income for 2019 which is equivalent to 1787 USD not 2185 USD.

Another thing change in BDT was in the range 80-85 against dollar but for INR it was like 65-75 against USD.
 
Back
Top Bottom