M. Sarmad
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Oct 27, 2013
- Messages
- 7,022
- Reaction score
- 62
- Country
- Location
I am sorry but your first link doesn't fully answer the point I raised and stressed upon, straight forward prohibition.
Please show me where I claimed about a "straight forward prohibition" ??
Trying Red Herring now ???
Read again what I had written ... And then read those Quranic verses ... They say exactly what I am saying
I had clearly mentioned in my opening post (you may not like calling him Ameer, but for me he is Ameer). That was supposed to let you know that you are entitled to your opinion and view and I am entitled to mine.
Anyways here is link to some research work that got banned in both Pakistan and india, and was equally disliked by Deo bandis and everyone. You can give it a reading if you want (I think I should have said if you can, beware you won't blame me for hurting your emotions after reading this). And its also necessary to mention that I still don't agree with the event as described in this research. I am of firm opinion that Hazrat Hussain was governor of Iraq when he was assassinated, they were people's people, they didn't prefer keeping personal guards and that's what led to targeted assassination of all of them from Omer to Hussain May ALLAH be pleased with all of them.
Bhai, Firstly, let me make it clear to you that I won't get offended even if you call Yazeed your prophet (let alone your Ameer)... You are free to believe in whatever you want and that's none of my concerns ..
Secondly, I asked you to provide primary source for your made-up story regarding Yazeed and Abu Ayyub ... And I asked you your opinions/comments on it .... But you have posted a link to a third rate sectarian book instead about Yazeed and Kerbala !!! ... You are better than that I believe
I remember we had this discussion in the past as well. I had at that time mentioned that Muslims in their time in Makkah weren't in position of any power, so they couldn't do much about the insults thrown at them and Messenger of ALLAH. Muslims in power after expansion couldn't think of disrespecting Messenger of ALLAH, they were still
And it had been pointed out to you that those verses which tell us to ignore blasphemers were from Madni Surahs !! In our times Remaining ignorant is a choice bro