Does Pakistan need whole Indian occupied Jammu and Kashmir region?

[bitter_truth]

Whole falsely occupied Jammu & Kashmir....not an inch given to Indian illegal occupation.

your all theories end here-
kashmir is an integral part of India

 

[Judge]

Need? Not at all.
Want? More than anything else in the world.

 

[Green Arrow]

Jo bhi mil jaye woh bonus ho ga

 

[vayuu1]

Jo bhi mil jaye woh bonus ho ga

Soch lo ,thik hai to tumhe Hindutva diya bonus me.

 

[lionheart1]

Pakistanis should ideally be worried about saving the territory that they have right now. But no point telling them that.

wow what an appropriate answer for the thread .........

not even a single inch of kashmir will be given back

kashmir is an integral part of India ....... it will be an integral part of India till last indian is alive

you can come fight and die ..... we are always ready to...... help you guys in meeting 72 virgins

 

[Iggy]

So there will be no Azad Kashmir right?? Its all an hogwash to provoke those innocent Kashmiries to be get killed by Indian forces..

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

The term "Indian Subcontinent" is bs.
Majority of Pakistan is NOT on the Indian Plate.
Also whole Kashmir region is NOT on the Indian Plate.

Go back to Australia.

So you mean countries are divided according to tectonic plates ?

 

[PakhtunGuy]

So you mean countries are divided according to tectonic plates ?

If an earthquake sends the Indian plate back to the Australian plate than you can see yourself if "countires" are devided by tectonical plates.

 

[NALANDA]

Guys , days of Confused, Kind, Congressi India is passe. Article 370 ( a temporary provision) will be a history next year and demographic change ( India's USP and Braham Ashtra) will take over and all this discussion will be a comedy. China is doing the demographic change is Tibet and other areas, Pakistan did, Israel , US, Austarlia did. Now is the time for India.

 

[third eye]

If an earthquake sends the Indian plate back to the Australian plate than you can see yourself if "countires" are devided by tectonical plates.

Great

Going by this logic US must have no lien on Hawaii , nor UK on Falkland Islands.

Pakistan then had no lien on East Pakistan too !

@ Subject, Pak woul be keen on Kashmir region alone for two reasons - Water & Muslims

Why would it want a change in demography by including Hindus from Jammu or Buddhists from Laddakh.

Not that its getting anything any time.

 

[Imran Khan]

no i think its not real pakistan need elections let kashmiris select

 

[pursuit of happiness]

no i think its not real pakistan need elections let kashmiris select

--
you mean in indian kashmir.. our Elect commiosn is relaible so ok
pak kashmir.. imran kahn agian will say its riggeed..
and china kashmir.. Democratic election in china

 

[Parul]

Jammu and Kashmir is a multi ethnic state.
In Kashmir valley there live the dardic people, the Kashmiris who are muslims.
In Ladakh there live the Ladakh people who are Sino Tibetan and are mainly buddhists.
In Jammu there live the Dogras, who are some kind of punjabi/mongolian mixture, who are mainly hindus.

In my opinion Pakistan needs only the Kashmir valley because:

1. Kashmiris are dardic people and related to the dardic people of Pakistan (Shinas and Chitralis) and in extend also to Pashtuns (East-Iranian people).
2. Kashmiris always were part of Pakistan's predecessor states (like the Sikh empire, Durrani empire or Indus valley civilisation etc.)
3. Kashmiris are Muslims

In conclusion Kashmiris share ethnical, historical, religious and cultural ties with all Pakistanis.

Whereas Ladakh and Jammu people don't share these connections.
Only thing Ladakh could be relevant is the Indus river which flows through Ladakh to China.

So do we need whole IO Jammu and Kashmir or only the Kashmir valley?

Here is also a map displaying the kashmir valley:

Only Kashmir would do: River. After all it's fight for Water.

 

[pursuit of happiness]

Only Kashmir would do: River. After all it's fight for Water.

--
even if they get kashmir.. just imagine..
they will fight again.. as due to climate change more ice melts so more floods.. again hindu baniya did it. and Nepal
so Jihad against Nepal and india for climate change
--
confused souls..

 

[OrionHunter]

Well,we don't need ladakh as it is considered a dud territory but we would be more than willing to take the rest of IOK and if possible we should also seek land access to our strategy partner Nepal

If wishes were horses, beggars would ride!

And talking of 'Kashmiri Muslims' which is the core issue on which the Pakistanis are basing their argument. Apart from the Buddhists of Ladakh and Hindus of Jammu, how about the Shias of Kashmir? They don't want to touch Pakistan even with a bargepole!