What's new

Did Pakistan balance ties with Iran for too long?

Yankee-stani

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Aug 22, 2018
Messages
8,100
Reaction score
1
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
The visit of Saudi Crown Prince Muhammad bin Salman has further exacerbated the regional divisions. And before MBS set foot on the Pakistani soil, Major General Mohammad Ali Jafari, chief of Iran’s Revolutionary Guards, only reinforced the regional realignments – particularly among the Sunni-Shia states. When addressing a crowd gathered to mourn the killing of 27 members of his force (on Feb 13), Jafari left little doubt about his country’s ever-growing partnership with India through the Chabahar port.

Although, terror group Jaish al Adl (Army of Justice), an outlawed outfit in Pakistan, claimed responsibility for the attack yet General Jafari chose to deliver warning on Pakistan for ‘inaction’.

Two post-suicide bombing events provide clear pointers to Jafari to deliver charged statements addressing Pakistan, UAE and Saudi Arabia.

Consider the following three, largely intimidating, pronouncements at one of two funeral ceremonies for the victims of the attack near the southeastern city of Zahedan.

#”Why do Pakistan’s army and security body … give refuge to these anti-revolutionary groups? Pakistani government knows where the attackers are harbored. Pakistan will no doubt pay a high price.”

#The United States and Israel ordered Saudi Arabia and the Emirates to carry out the attack.

“We will avenge the blood of our martyrs from the Saudi and UAE governments and ask the President (Hassan Rouhani) to leave our hands free more than ever for reprisal operations.”

“The Saudi and UAE governments should know that Iran’s patience has ended and we will no longer stand your secret support for these anti-Islam criminals,” Jafari said.



As if the Indian finger-pointing were not enough, Brigadier General Mohammad Pakpour, the ground force commander of the IRGC in the border province of Sistan-Baluchestan, dropped another bombshell on Feb 18, claiming the suicide bomber was a Pakistani national. “Two members of the terrorist team were Pakistani and the suicide bomber was someone named Hafiz Mohamed Ali from Pakistan and also there was another person from Pakistan in the team,” Pakpour said, according to Tasnim news agency. Two of the terrorists have been arrested while one is still on the run, he said.

Well, that is quite possible. Lots of Pakistanis have been fighting in Afghanistan as well as carrying out terrorist activities against their own people. Thousands have been killed, injured or arrested in the string of operations that have gone on in the last decade or so.

Should one take these assertions by two key Revolutionary Guards commanders as mere emotional reaction to the suicide bombing or apply the geo-political prism to it?

One would tend to look at them in the context of the latter for various reasons.

Firstly, because the Iranians don’t want to acknowledge that their ‘isolation’ stems from their own self-serving views on issues confronting the Islamic countries. Why should Pakistan get sandwiched between Saudi Arabia and Iran for their rivalry that is rooted in the centuries’ old Arab-Ajam division?

Secondly, it’s the US-led west responsible for its economic miseries and political isolation, and not a country that has itself suffered immensely because of terror outfits. Pakistan has lost nearly 70,000 of its people, including nearly 6,500 army officers and soldiers. Why would it shelter or provide haven to such unwanted entities?

Thirdly, leaders in Tehran seem to forget that Pakistan gravely annoyed both the UAE and Saudi Arabia in April 2015, when its parliament voted overwhelmingly for the country to remain out of their conflict with Yemen. Pakistan as a consequence suffered both political incrimination by UAE as well as economically. The UAE laid off and sent thousands of Pakistani workers back. The UAE in particular displayed unprecedented displeasure, leading to a near diplomatic impasse. It took a while to repair these relations.

Fourth, Tehran expects solidarity but can offer little financial support or employment opportunities – both Saudi Arabia and UAE employ about five million Pakistanis. We understand Iran is itself hamstrung by US-Western sanctions, yet it hopefully recognizes that international relations, even among Muslim countries, are largely determined by mutual economic interests, secured through geopolitical alliances. Faith, morality or emotions hardly matter in such alliances of convenience as a firewall for respective national interests.

Saudi Arabian investments, if most of them eventually materialize, do promise an economic turnaround on the back of the CPEC-related projects. And Pakistan, after suffering economic stagnation that flowed from two geo-political adventures of the United States, has a great opportunity to coopt other countries into its economic development – something very much aligned with the Chinese Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).

All these years, Pakistan has striven hard not to take sides at the cost of one or the other country. It should still try not to offend or alienate Iran but geo-economic realism demands of Tehran not to look at the new phase of Saudi-Pakistan relations through the sectarian prism. Iran indeed was the first country to openly support Pakistan’s position on Kashmir and Babri mosque issue. But today, it maintains the best of relations with India – presumably guided by the doctrine of economic realism. It should therefore grant the same margin to Pakistan – which has begun emerging from the economic morass with the Chinese and Saudi support.

Published in Daily Times, February 20th 2019.
 
. . .
Assurances of friendship from Iranian and Pakistani officials have been more than sufficient in recent years. However, it was enough for a terrorist attack to happen, killing scores of Iranian military, that the rhetoric has changed dramatically.

Tehran warned Pakistan it would “pay a heavy price” for allegedly harboring militants of the Sunni group Jaish al-Adl (Army of Justice), which belongs to the Iranian Baluchi minority, and who claimed responsibility for the attack killing 27 and injuring 13 of its elite Revolutionary Guards near the Iran-Pakistan border last week.

“Why do Pakistan’s army and security body … give refuge to these anti-revolutionary groups? Pakistan will no doubt pay a high price,” Revolutionary Guards Chief Major General Mohammad Ali Jafari said in remarks on state television, Reuters reported.

Iranian authorities are confident that militant groups operating from safe havens in Pakistan have been supported by Saudi Arabia and the UAE: “The treacherous Saudi and UAE governments should know that Iran’s patience has ended and we will no longer stand your secret support for these anti-Islam criminals,” Jafari said.

Pakistan, as well as Saudi Arabia and the Emirates have denied any involvement in the incident.

A sharp change of tone, apart from emotions, can only speak of one thing: regular statements about good-neighborliness are rather diplomatic in nature, and relations between the two countries are not so serene.

There have been a number of unpleasant points in the Iran-Pakistan relations in recent years.

Iran has probably not forgotten that in 2010, when the UN Security Council adopted resolution 1929, Pakistan voted for the imposition of tough sanctions against Iran.

Despite repeated calls by Tehran to complete the construction of the Pakistani section of the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline, which is of strategic importance for Tehran, Islamabad has not made any practical response, referring to the lack of funds or the imposed sanctions regime.

In Afghanistan, the interests of the two countries also differ rather than coincide – take at least the confessional factor (Pakistan supports the Sunni Taliban, while Iran supports the Shiite minority of Afghanistan), or the construction of the TAPI gas pipeline from Turkmenistan to Pakistan through Afghanistan, which can compete with Iran's gas plans.

But the most serious threat and the greatest anger of Tehran is caused by terrorist attacks in the southeastern province of Sistan and Baluchestan, bordering Pakistan. The Iranians have reasons to believe that suicide bombers enter the country from territory of the contiguous state.


In 2010, militants attacked a mosque in the capital of Zahedan province. As a result of the incident, 28 people were killed. In 2013, an attack by militants of the same Jaish al-Adl led to the deaths of 14 Iranian border guards. In 2014, five Iranian border guards were kidnapped. In December last year, three people were killed and about 30 were injured in a suicide bombing in the port city of Chabahar close to Pakistani borders. This is only a part of the deadly list.

Commander of the IRGC Ground Force General Mohammad Pakpour said yesterday the suicide bomber and two other members of a group that committed the recent terrorist attack were Pakistani nationals, Iranian Tasnim agency reported.

Pakistan, willingly or not, is involved in the Saudi-Iranian confrontation, which covers not only Syria, Iraq, Yemen, but also trade and transport communications connecting South Asia and the Middle East through the coast of the Arabian Sea.

During the visit of the Saudi crown prince to Pakistan, the sides signed an MOU in energy, minerals etc. valued at about $20 billion, including a $10 billion refinery and petrochemicals complex near the Pakistani port of Gwadar. This may, to some extent, weaken the significance of the Iranian-Indian project to build and expand the Iranian port of Chabahar, located on the same coast.

At a time when tensions have risen between Iran and Pakistan after the deadly suicide attack and Iran's accusations against Saudi Arabia, an unprecedented diplomatic protocol was observed during the official meeting of the Saudi crown prince in Pakistan.

As world media report, fighter jets escorted the prince’s plane across Pakistani airspace and television stations devoted hours of live coverage to the royal motorcade and ceremony. Prime Minister Imran Khan personally drove the crown prince to the capital Islamabad.

The Saudi prince has been also rewarded with Pakistan’s highest Order, the “Nishan-e-Pakistan”.

In a phone talk with Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif, Pakistani Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi offered his condolences over the martyrdom of IRGC military.

He further said his country is ready for any kind of cooperation with Iran to investigate the terrorist attack near the Iran-Pakistan border and jointly fight against terrorist groups.

Can two almost simultaneous events – the deadly attack on Iranian troops by a Pakistan-based armed group, which, Iran believes, has direct ties with Saudi Arabia and the UAE, and the royal welcome given by Islamabad in honor of the Saudi crown prince – alienate Iran and Pakistan from each other?

The answer is not completely obvious, but Islamabad ought to do everything not to let this happen, and not to involve itself in the Iranian-Saudi confrontation.

Follow Trend on Telegram. Only most interesting and important news
 
.
Referring to Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s recent visit to Pakistan, General Safavi said Pakistan is a neighbor of Iran, and it should know that Saudi government is not reliable because it will not last for long.

The senior official added, 16 research organizations in Europe have announced in a document named ‘World in 2030’ that Saudis will not be existing in 2030 while Iran will be the strongest country of the region.

His comments come while Saudis are using aid packages and investment promises to buy the economically embattled Pakistani government's loyalty and convince it to turn a blind eye to their destructive actions within Pakistan's borders, including the Saudi-funded seminaries that have become breeding ground for extremism and terrorism.

General Safavi also referred to the recent terrorist attack in southeast Iran, which killed and wounded several dozens of IRGC personnel, saying the Pakistani government and its intelligence service have to respond to the Iranian nation and government.

The Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC) announced on Tuesday that two of the perpetrators behind the Zahedan terrorist attack, including the suicide bomber, were Pakistani nationals.

The suicide attack, which targeted a bus carrying Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps personnel near Zahedan in Sistan and Baluchestan province, claimed the lives of 27 people and injured dozens of others.

The so-called Jaish ul-Adl terror group, which is based across the border in Pakistan and is responsible for kidnapping Iranian border guards and carrying out other terrorist attacks of this kind in Zahedan over the past years, claimed responsibility for the Wednesday attack.

He said, “the powerful Iranian armed forces and IRGC ground forces have the right to crack down on the perpetrators of the terrorist attack based on their revolutionary duty to defend the country’s borders.”

MNA/IRN83215764

https://en.mehrnews.com/news/142718/Pakistan-should-know-Saudis-are-not-reliable-Gen-Safavi

(mod edit: provide link to original source).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
Pakistan should take care of own interests instead of trying to appease anyone or balancing without any benefit.


Difficult when you have a weak depended economy. Easier said than done for a nation that is inherently corrupt and depended on foreign loans.

It's a decades old rot that places Pakistan in a position of servitude to foreign powers.

Nothing comes without strings attached.

Real world facts.
 
.
It's not the game of Iran, neither it is the game of Pakistan. Why then Iran is becoming emotional? Take chill pill, we are just supporting characters. Have share, have fun.
 
. .
Difficult when you have a weak depended economy. Easier said than done for a nation that is inherently corrupt and depended on foreign loans.

It's a decades old rot that places Pakistan in a position of servitude to foreign powers.

Nothing comes without strings attached.

Real world facts.

How trying to appease Iran in anyway benefit our economy? Actually we incurred loss because of smuggled oil and goods from Iran and dollars being smuggled to Iran.
 
. . . .
the problem with iranian generals is that they dont know what to speak and when to speak.
 
.
And the same organizations blame Iran for sponsoring terrorism in its neighbouring countries and ME. Europe even black listed Iran for decades.
By Iranian logic, should Pakistan also declare Iran as a terrorist country?
 
.
@Mentee See told you "Peeran hor, te phakian hor" Khadim rizvi is a qoumi assasa i tell you :lol:



Allah don't like this much arrogance general.

I actually still like Iran over the Turks and Saudis that's just my opinion you can have yours agree or disagree from here and Iran does have potential

At the same Pakistan should hedge its bets with everyone and not give a crap about Iran-Saudi s..tshow and focus on bringing Pakistan up
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom