Dhaka-Syria-Dhaka

[Nabil365]

Now I know why Bangladesh is way more tolerant than west bengal.Majority of the Bangladeshi don't mind when minorities gets privileges.Look at the west bengalis bunch of sore loser whinning whenever the minority receive previleges.

 

[dray]

Now I know why Bangladesh is way more tolerant than west bengal.Majority of the Bangladeshi don't mind when minorities gets privileges.Look at the west bengalis bunch of sore loser whinning whenever the minority receive previleges.

Nobody should receive any special privilege because of one's religion.

 

[Mage]

That's a total off topic discussioin, but still replying here, for your sake, dada @Rain Man .

1. She announced monthly salary for Imam and Moyajjen (not sure if the term) in all mosques, no other religion gets such benefits.

Its not a bad thing to give them monthly salary though. Maybe temple purohits(not sure if the term) gets enough donations from other so they are well off compared to imams? If not then they should demand monthly wage too. I doubt WB govt has enough money though.

2. She announced scholarships for Muslim students only, students of other religions don't get it, it's not that in a village non-muslim students are financially any better than muslim students.

C'mon, what's the big deal here? Sometimes you need to offer some facilities to lift a backward community. It doesn't harm anyone. Isn't it better for WB if more Muslim gets to study? In Bangladesh we have quota system for Adibashis for govt service. My college had quota system for Christians and only Christians had to attend mandatory religious lessons, once every month. And I love my college despite being a Muslim.
What's the big problem? At least the money is spent on education.

3. She wanted to do a hospital for muslims only, then there were some protests, people questioned if a hindu and a muslim going together meet with an accident near that hospital, should the hindu be left to die? We don't have the luxury of plenty of options in hospitals in rural areas. She had to postpone the ridiculous plan till she finds the answer.

wtf!!!!! I doubt even the Saudi govt does anything of that sort. Sounds bull crap to me.

4. She started a special Eid bonus for muslim state government employees, that means they earn more compared to the employees of other religions for the same job. Nothing creates more divide than money.

Doesn't others get any bonus like that? Can you give me the source? I find it among many other things you wroote quite unbelievable.

7. Durga Puja bisarjana dates coincide with Eid almost every year, so she has barred all Durga Puja bisarjana during 1 or 2 days of Eid. That's directly interfering with one religion against the other.

8. There were at least a couple of incidents that got reported in the media where she has closed down or banned Durga Puja because of the protests of local muslims there. This year just a few days ago a 65 years old Saraswati Puja in a school was stopped on local muslims' demand, and her police has brutally beaten up minor girl students demanding continuation of their puja.

Come to Bangladesh. We celebrate Durga Pooja quite festively. It's our biggest festival after the Eids(along with Pahela Baisakh.)
And Swarswati pooja was 3 days ago right? It was celebrated in schools in Bangladesh. The day is a holiday for educational institutes. I find it sad(and quite unbelieveable) that these things can be banned in WB(30% Muslim) but not in Bangladesh(90% Muslim)

10. She gives a free hand to every demand of radical Muslims, they wanted to ban a women's football tournament, she allowed the ban. They would prevent any supposedly anti-muslim writer like Rushdie or Nasrin to enter West Bengal and hold protest, she would agree. Very recently she has banned a seminar with some international guests where Pakistan & Balochistan issue was a topic...she banned it to safeguard 'muslim sentiment'!!

She probably does this to keep things quiet. Not like I agree with them but govts sometimes need to(are forced to) do things like that not to let racial/communal tensions get too high.

11. She apparently has given instructions to the police to not touch any Muslim during any law & order issue, heck, they don't even catch muslim bikers without helmet!

Police can tell who is Hindu and who is Muslim just by looking at them? They must be damn skilled. Or you just assume any biker who doesn't wear helmet to be a Muslim?

Secularism is anything but pandering to one religion over others. She is doing everything to ensure that people turn against each other, just to secure some muslim votes. You will see many WB muslims are very happy with her, but they are missing the bigger picture.

I don't know.......Mamata is rather popular in WB from what I've heard. She can't simply win with Muslim votes alone. I'd agree that her communist type mentality might harm the state's economy...but what you accuse her to be is rather...I don't know what to say. And also not every Muslim vote based on religious issues. Muslims care about state's economy structural PROBLEMS and other issues too. I don't get it how can she win fair elections like this. I'm sorry but I can't believe half of what you wrote here........
this
And I sincerely hope what you wrote is wrong. Bengali people should stick together regardless of religion.....there is a saying like "Bengali Bengali bhai bhai" They need to watch each others back and not fall into communal trap which only serves the interests of the extremists of both sides.

 

[dray]

It was all around social media how hindu men in that locality were harassing Muslim women during a scuffle over the procession. can't expect the Muslims there to just bear it. They simply reacted.

Hafiza Begum er ransacked house. Meyeder porhar ghor gulokeo chareni bandor gulo. hat e poruk ekbar tokhon buzhbe dholai kake bole

When i read about the Incident - I immediately knew there was something wrong . " Muslims while taking Milad Un Nabi procession through the Hindu Area started attacking the Hindu Homes"

The procession was a holy Joyous moment, Not a military drill. Hindus must have done something to irritate the Passing Muslims.

Most probably they want a Danga - So religious sentiment soar up and BJP can set a foot in.

Oh right! Muslims are always victims, they can't do any wrong...ever!

There is a reason why one community doesn't take their religious processions through the the areas of other communities, it create unnecessary tension. This year Muslims did observe Nabi Diwas in surprisingly strange ways unlike any other year! In Dhulagarh's case they took their procession through a Hindu area with loudspeakers when Hindus were also doing their Sankranthi pujas, the problem started with the use of loudspeakers near Sankranthi puja, and it settled down initially after police and RAF took control. Real problem started the next day when Bengal government strangely withdrawn RAF from Hindu areas for a few hours and hoards of Muslims attacked and burnt down Hindu houses. There is a reason why current CM is being blamed for blatant communal politics.

 

[Hold up]

^^Bangladeshi musolman ra to arek level er hoye gese. era ekhon hindu puja te part nise. bhalo hoyese toder theke ahlada hoye gesi. ekhankar musolmanra toder seye on ek bhalo. za giya pujo kor boshe boshe ar kopal e bindi pore thak. musolmander nam e dhabba tora

 

[Kandari-Hushiyaar]

^^Bangladeshi musolman ra to arek level er hoye gese. era ekhon hindu puja te part nise. bhalo hoyese toder theke ahlada hoye gesi. ekhankar musolmanra toder seye on ek bhalo. za giya pujo kor boshe boshe ar kopal e bindi pore thak. musolmander nam e dhabba tora

E dekhi Jaite kate ashteo Kate. Kon dik e Jabo vai @Rain Man and @Ehtesham96

 

[Hold up]

E dekhi Jaite kate ashteo Kate. Kon dik e Jabo vai @Rain Man and @Ehtesham96

apnar ei philia namok poster bolse Bangladesh e naki soroswoti puja manay musolmanra. eshob ki. mane ta ki eshob er. Salaam apnader ei culture ta Bangladesh ei thakuk wb te musolman ra kokhono soroswoti puja manabe na, hain. ota hindu der festival hindu ra manabe.

 

[Mage]

^^Bangladeshi musolman ra to arek level er hoye gese. era ekhon hindu puja te part nise. bhalo hoyese toder theke ahlada hoye gesi. ekhankar musolmanra toder seye on ek bhalo. za giya pujo kor boshe boshe ar kopal e bindi pore thak. musolmander nam e dhabba tora

Aye. It is always better to stick together in a community. You know Hindus in Bangladeshi offices, get Eid bonuses too. And they celebrate Eid too. I had Hindu friend in my schools who wouldn't bring water bottle to school during Ramadan time. And we don't cook anything with Beef when we have Hindu guests visit our house. Its called and respecting each others values.

 

[Kandari-Hushiyaar]

apnar ei philia namok poster bolse Bangladesh e naki soroswoti puja manay musolmanra. eshob ki. mane ta ki eshob er. Salaam apnader ei culture ta Bangladesh ei thakuk wb te musolman ra kokhono soroswoti puja manabe na, hain. ota hindu der festival hindu ra manabe.

amra dawat pele Jai dekhe ashi. etey Kharap kichu na vai. amak swaraswati pujay golper Boi dewa hoto elakar valo chatro chhilam bole. To boi ante Jabo na?

 

[Mage]

apnar ei philia namok poster bolse Bangladesh e naki soroswoti puja manay musolmanra. eshob ki. mane ta ki eshob er. Salaam apnader ei culture ta Bangladesh ei thakuk wb te musolman ra kokhono soroswoti puja manabe na, hain. ota hindu der festival hindu ra manabe.

Amra Swaraswati Puja manai na, ota ekta holiday for educational institutions. Oneke puja dekhte jay. If you have problems with it, then I guess I'm sorry.

 

[Hold up]

Aye. It is always better to stick together in a community. You know Hindus in Bangladeshi offices, get Eid bonuses too. And they celebrate Eid too. I had Hindu friend in my schools who wouldn't bring water bottle to school during Ramadan time. And we don't cook anything with Beef when we have Hindu guests visit our house. Its called and respecting each others values.

amake eshob bolsen keno amar o bohut hindu dost ase. lekin amra kokhono hindu festival e part ni na. We become Muslims after saying the shahadah. true muslim never breaks it by taking part in pagan worship. its a one way street. Won't disrespect the Tawheed just to mix with hindus. Get this in your head

 

[Mage]

amra dawat pele Jai dekhe ashi. etey Kharap kichu na vai. amak swaraswati pujay golper Boi dewa hoto elakar valo chatro chhilam bole. To boi ante Jabo na?

Amader school e swaraswati pooja e program hoto kintu keu jetam na, emon ki Hindu student rao na. Ekta din bondho pawa gese, ke chay school e jeye chaipash dekhte.

 

[Hold up]

amra dawat pele Jai dekhe ashi. etey Kharap kichu na vai. amak swaraswati pujay golper Boi dewa hoto elakar valo chatro chhilam bole. To boi ante Jabo na?

oi puja te boi deowa hoy na boi rekhe deowa hoy oder goddess er kase. For like 3-5 days. Haha zai hok ki ar bolbo your wish

 

[dray]

That's a total off topic discussioin, but still replying here, for your sake, dada @Rain Man .


Its not a bad thing to give them monthly salary though. Maybe temple purohits(not sure if the term) gets enough donations from other so they are well off compared to imams? If not then they should demand monthly wage too. I doubt WB govt has enough money though.

C'mon, what's the big deal here? Sometimes you need to offer some facilities to lift a backward community. It doesn't harm anyone. Isn't it better for WB if more Muslim gets to study? In Bangladesh we have quota system for Adibashis for govt service. My college had quota system for Christians and only Christians had to attend mandatory religious lessons, once every month. And I love my college despite being a Muslim.
What's the big problem? At least the money is spent on education.

wtf!!!!! I doubt even the Saudi govt does anything of that sort. Sounds bull crap to me.

Doesn't others get any bonus like that? Can you give me the source? I find it among many other things you wroote quite unbelievable.

Come to Bangladesh. We celebrate Durga Pooja quite festively. It's our biggest festival after the Eids(along with Pahela Baisakh.)
And Swarswati pooja was 3 days ago right? It was celebrated in schools in Bangladesh. The day is a holiday for educational institutes. I find it sad(and quite unbelieveable) that these things can be banned in WB(30% Muslim) but not in Bangladesh(90% Muslim)

She probably does this to keep things quiet. Not like I agree with them but govts sometimes need to(are forced to) do things like that not to let racial/communal tensions get too high.

Police can tell who is Hindu and who is Muslim just by looking at them? They must be damn skilled. Or you just assume any biker who doesn't wear helmet to be a Muslim?

I don't know.......Mamata is rather popular in WB from what I've heard. She can't simply win with Muslim votes alone. I'd agree that her communist type mentality might harm the state's economy...but what you accuse her to be is rather...I don't know what to say. And also not every Muslim vote based on religious issues. Muslims care about state's economy structural PROBLEMS and other issues too. I don't get it how can she win fair elections like this. I'm sorry but I can't believe half of what you wrote here........
this
And I sincerely hope what you wrote is wrong. Bengali people should stick together regardless of religion.....there is a saying like "Bengali Bengali bhai bhai" They need to watch each others back and not fall into communal trap which only serves the interests of the extremists of both sides.

Everything I wrote is fact, including the Muslim hospital thing, we had big debates on TV channels over this. In a secular country like India benefits on the basis of religion is prohibited, but she is doing exactly that. She can give benefits to poor, but irrespective of their religion, otherwise it creates religious divide. And the helmet issue, actually there are bikers' gangs in Topsia/Tiljala areas in Kolkata, Muslim chaps, who ride dangerously without helmet, police would do nothing, police know from where they are, sometimes they would just wear skull caps and cause nuisance, ask any muslim taxi driver who knows the roads, recently petrol pumps have been instructed to not give petrol to bikers without helmet, but these fellows have unofficial relaxation...she is going to any extent to secure her votes. Bikers are small issue, but what about other things...you want links? I am travelling now, but can give you links of newspapers later if you want. For now google for 'howrah school saraswati puja' or something similar..

 

[Hold up]

ota ekta holiday for educational institutions

Really, why do Muslims take holiday on that day, after all its not your festival. Confusing lot. Whatever, your wish