What's new

Could Ranjeet Singh's statue in Lahore be torn down like the statues of tyrants in the West?

even nepali general amar singh thapa was in his khalsa army .



yes as much as pakistani masihi share christian heritage with richard the lionheart or george washington .



They probably do as nearly all Christain Pakistanis in the UK marry White English or German people.

PS Northwestern and Western region Pakistanis do have racial and genetic connections to Central and Southern Iranians and SOME Southern Turkish ethnicities. The Pathan in Pakistan are in fact a Persianised Nomadic race that are genetically related to modern day Iranians.
 
.
There is no need for such action. Statues don't do any harm.
 
.
"Maharaja Ranjit Singh's sovereignty was accepted by Afghan and Punjabi Muslims, who fought under his banner against the Afghan forces of Nadir Shah and later of Azim Khan. His court was ecumenical in composition: his prime minister, Dhian Singh, was a Dogra; his foreign minister, Fakir Azizuddin, was a Muslim; and his finance minister, Dina Nath, was a Brahmin. Artillery commanders such as Mian Ghausa were also Muslims. There were no forced conversions in his time. His wives Bibi Mohran, Gilbahar Begum retained their faith and so did his Hindu wives".[77]

Wikipedia is heavily edited by Sikhs who worship him. He was a brutal and ruthless ruler who disrespected holy places of Muslims, They used to burn Muslims alive for accusation of eating beef, most barbarity they committed was against Pashtuns. The hate of Muslims was part of Sikh fighters bcoz their gurus were murdered by Muslim Empires for causing mischief in Muslim lands.

but there is other side of story too, so called Muslim rulers were no saint either, Afghan under Abdali (we have missile named after this guy) sacked Lahore like a terrorist... Sikhs did nothing of this sort yet i see no such ire here against Abdali. the only difference b/w them was that Afghan never burned mosques, just like Sikhs never burned Gurudwara.:rofl:

The Grandson of Abdali Shah Shuja fought his brothers for power with help of Kana Ranjeet and Brits. Afghans killed Muslims from Ganges region fighting Sikhs for liberation of Pashtuns under Syed Ahmed Shaheed Barelvi bcoz they used to consider them inferior, they didnt like their inter community marriages, their Strict adherence to Sharia instead of barbarian tribal laws.

The fact of the matter is no one was saint.
 
Last edited:
.
Respectfully, Most of my brothers who are abusing Maharaja Ranjit Singh should do one thing.
If you are a Punjabi, Ask about him from any of your elders who was born in 40s or 50s and not associated with any Hardcore Religious Jamaat. Ask him how Muslims used to View Maharaja Ranjit Singh before this mindwash galore of late 70s and 80s took place.
Ahmad Shah Durrani Plundered These Lands.He was part of Nadir Shah Armies who Slaughtered Delhi before. Durrani Entered our lands by defeating Shahnawaz Khan of Peshawar. and subsequently Muin ul Mulk of Lahore. These Raids were the reason mughal hold in KPK Punjab Kashmir Region was lost, And Local Sikhs rose to power, Maratha rose to power in northern Hindustan. and the chain of events that caused the rise of Sikh empire. Arch Rival of Ranjit Singh, the Durrani Empire was an offshoot of the chengis khan Incarnate Nadir shah Afsharis empire, not some holy Muslim Empire representing the Caliph in Istanbul. Don't Bring Islam in these wars. People like Mir Temur, Nadir Shah and his followers were open admirers of Mongol Khan Chengis khan. Only Allah knows whats in heart but mass slaughter of cities is not what muslims do, It was what mongols did. And so did these sons of Mongols Calling themselves Muslims and Tainting our religion with their heinous acts.
Ranjit Singh Defeated Ahmad Shah Durrani Son Zaman Shah. He will always remain a son of Punjab who broke the teeth of Durrani Invaders. If some one wants to associate with Nadir Shah Offshoots more then his own ancestors then be my guest. But first read the history without bias. And Ask from your elders who are most reliable source of information instead of Propaganda Books.
Singh wars against Afghans. Like any war, Some local factions sided with durranis some sided with Ranjit. Even Some Tribesmen sided with Ranjit Singh against Durrani Empire. Even Sultan Shuja Khan Durrani sided with Sikhs when he was exiled. (War is war). And Just think why every governor of these Punjabi and Siraiki cities were all Afghans not locals when Ranjit Singh Took over them from Durranis.
Its really Cringe worthy how our Historians try to portray how everyone from west of Pakistan was part of a unified Muslim Rule and savior of Muslims. People here don't even know that Ahmad Shah Durrani (An Afghan Warlord who break away from Nadir Shah Armies after his death to created his own Dynasty) and early muslim conquerers like Sultan Mehmood Ghaznavi were 750 years apart from each other.


If you believe all of the above to be true(He was a tyrant who subdued your ancestors and so on) then you have every right to hate him and as you said P*** on his statue and so on.
But will you rather "P*** on statues" of Mir Temur and Nadir Shah as well? Their cruelty is matched only by Chengis khan and Halagu khan. Muslim Historians write about them that they slaughtered whole cities and made minarates of decapitated Heads outside the defeated cities that resisted their conquests, Just as Mongols did (Confirm it from any sources you believe except Naseem Hijazi saab Of course). Will you sir, in Principle, P*** on them as well,as you will do with Ranjit Singh?

All my elders called Ranjit kanna haramzada. Twaday maseetay’a vich kachra/gand Sut da si te korray kara kar da si, te tussi uno pyo di jagaa samajya.

lakh lanat twaday jaman te.

:lol:
 
. .
I liked @ahmadnawaz22 comment bcoz he showed other side of the coin but then went south by praising Kana Ranjeet for justice and blah blah. He was just another filthy terrorist.

We should condemn both Ranjeet's filth and leftover of Nader Shah called Abdali dynasty.
 
. .
There is no need for such action. Statues don't do any harm.

Completely agree.

Punjabhis should be have Ranjeet Singh's statues

Sindhi's should have Raja Dahir's statues

Pushtuns should have Ahmad Shah Durrani's statues
 
.
This one,

attachment.php


5d1539015de63.jpg


He was a tyrant who made the lives of the Muslim populations of Punjab, Kashmir and modern KPK miserable but his statue was placed in Lahore a couple of years ago by the self-hating "ham bahasiat qaum munafiq hain" brigade in Lahore. So now as we are living in the age of tearing down statutes of tyrants from the past in the wake of current global campaign against the statues of the past racists and tyrants, is it possible that the statue of this tyrant could also meet the same fate. You comments please?
This is brainchild of Shahbaz Sharif... now he already erected the statue so better leave it alone or remove it quickly as possible, before it turn into hate context between Sikh nationalist and Punjabi muslims.
 
.
I liked @ahmadnawaz22 comment bcoz he showed other side of the coin but then went south by praising Kana Ranjeet for justice and blah blah. He was just another filthy terrorist.

We should condemn both Ranjeet's filth and leftover of Nader Shah called Abdali dynasty.
I praised Ranjit singh for Justice? Where? o_O
He was a Knee jerk reaction of the Punjab KPK Kashmir against the onslaught from Durranis.
And he expelled them from these lands.
And he was a son of punjab.
Tyrant or not is debateable. There are so mamy versions that i cant really say which one is conclusively true. So that is that. nothing more nothing less.
We can condemn Ranjeet singh as a ruler. No doubt about it. There are various sources who portray him as such.
But can we deny that he rose from this very land we live in and expelled the Durranis?
History is never Black and white. their is always gray. But he definitely never made Minarates of heads of beheaded enemies did he?
 
.
This is brainchild of Shahbaz Sharif... now he already erected the statue so better leave it alone or remove it quickly as possible, before it turn into hate context between Sikh nationalist and Punjabi muslims.

Fuwwad Chowdary tweeted the Punjabi supremacy tweet.

He worked at Geo and has close links with Musharraf
 
.
Fuwwad Chowdary tweeted the Punjabi supremacy tweet.

He worked at Geo and has close links with Musharraf
Fuwwad Chowdary is opportunist , Musharraf is honest and brave . Musharraf paid his court fee. Musharraf don't ow anything to anyone.
 
. .
All my elders called Ranjit kanna haramzada. Twaday maseetay’a vich kachra/gand Sut da si te korray kara kar da si, te tussi uno pyo di jagaa samajya.

lakh lanat twaday jaman te.

:lol:
Ap per bhi Allah ki rehmat ho.
Anyways Try to live with difference of opinnion when you are talking about history Instead of Abusing some one. Agar koi factual counter argument ho to write it down.

Stay blessed
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom