What's new

Cook Booked for 'Posing as Brahmin' Finds Support in VHP, Bajrang Dal

thesolar65

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 3, 2012
Messages
4,922
Reaction score
-12
Country
India
Location
India
A controversy erupted after Medha Khole, who is a senior scientist at the India Meteorological Department here registered a cheating case against her cook, Nirmala Yadav, for allegedly religious sentiments by hiding her caste and marital status and posed as "Brahmin" to get the job.

Pune: A day after a IMD scientist registered a cheating complaint against her cook, claiming she hurt her "religious sentiments" by posing as a Brahmin, several organisations, including the VHP and the Bajrang Dal, came out in support of the 60-year-old woman.

A controversy erupted after Medha Khole, who is a senior scientist at the India Meteorological Department registered a cheating case against her cook, Nirmala Yadav, for hurting religious sentiments by allegedly hiding her caste and marital status and posed as "Brahmin" to get the job.

Members of Sambhaji Brigade on Friday met Joint Commissioner of Police Ravindra Kadam and sought action against Khole for allegedly creating a caste divide.

"Do not look at this case as a standalone one as it has created a very strong social impact. The case has been filed by a person who holds an important position in a key department of the government and calls herself a scientist. The case shows the complainant's casteiest mindset," Santosh Shinde of the Sambhaji Brigade said.

The cook received support from organisations like the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) and Bajrang Dal as their members visited her house and extended support to her.

"We met Yadav and extended our support and we also demand that Khole should tender an apology and withdraw the case," Sampat Charwad of the Bajrang Dal said.

Meanwhile, Akhil Bhartiya Brahman Mahasangh, a body representing the Brahmin community, termed the police case by the scientist as "unwarranted" and said the issue should be resolved mutually.

"Who to employ to prepare food on religious occasions and rituals at home is the personal choice, but looking at the age of the cook, we believe that the police case was unwarranted and we also think that the issue should be resolved mutually," Anand Dave of the organisation said.

Khole had said in the complaint that she needed a married Brahmin woman to cook food at her house during religious occasions.

Yadav, who approached Khole in 2016 for the job, had then introduced herself as Nirmala Kulkarni, a senior police official had said.

"The complainant had even gone to her house to cross check her claim in 2016. Thereafter, Yadav started going to Khole's house on such occasions to prepare food," the officer added.

The officer had said that Khole came to know on Wednesday that the cook was not a Brahmin.

After this, Khole went to the cook's house to seek an explanation and found out her real name, the officer added.

Khole also claimed that the cook abused and intimated her, police said.

A case under Sections 419 (cheating by personation), 352 (punishment for assault or criminal force) and 504 (intentional insult with intent to provoke breach of the peace) of the Indian Penal Code was registered at the Sinhgad Police Station, the official said.

http://www.news18.com/news/india/co...finds-support-in-vhp-bajrang-dal-1513561.html
@Levina @ranjeet @anant_s @jbgt90 @Skull and Bones @Joe Shearer

Who gave her the designation "Scientist"? These kind of people give us a bad name. Agreed, the cook must have told a lie in order to get the job for an good income. But that lie becomes negligible considering the nature of Scientist's mind.
 
.
I posted from TV18 as other papers did not point out the reports of support from VHP or Bajrang parties.
 
.
Just don't know how to react.

We have had Brahmin cooks for ages, until shifting to Calcutta, when that stopped and my Mum compromised. As a unitary family, we hired whichever cook could, well, cook. But to take it to these extremes is a little obsessive, a little over the top, I think. What shook me was that organisations that I dislike intensely seem to have taken the right side, and supported the poor cook. I should have expected things to be the other way around; at first glance, my heart sank, as I thought this would be one of those 'let's_go_kill_ourselves_this_Yadav' stories.

I just hope that the police take a view (one that I usually feel they have no right to do, and that interfering with a complaint is a bit of social engineering that inhibits recourse to the law in favour of irregular mediation techniques) that the complaint was crap, and leave it to the aggrieved woman to make a civil case of it.
 
.
I have nothing to contribute in this thread, given that I, myself is not a brahmin (not by birth, atleast).
 
.
I spent around 5 years of life before getting married and during my postings at several places, we as a group of fellow engineers (6 in all) employed cook. Our only criteria used to be that cook should be a strict vegetarian and good health. We even paid for basic medical examination but never asked for caste or anything. Don't think me or my group ever faced any issues with food.
Times are changing and am sure there are many like our group, who saw no point in living in past.
 
.
Cast stupidities aren't going to end overnight but Orthodox people in villages talking like this, i can atleast make some sense. But a scientist talking such nonsense is utter disgusting. What horrible stupidities these people follow. This is 2017 not 600AD.
 
.
Where can i find these type of Brahmins in India ?

We Gujarati Brahmins dont give 2 hoots about our employees caste.
 
.

Who gave her the designation "Scientist"? These kind of people give us a bad name. Agreed, the cook must have told a lie in order to get the job for an good income. But that lie becomes negligible considering the nature of Scientist's mind.

This is a case of cheating by impersonating as clearing mentioned in the FIR filed by Medha Khole.
 
.
I have nothing to contribute in this thread, given that I, myself is not a brahmin (not by birth, atleast).

But by Karma you can be :)

anyone can be a brahmin by karma for that matter.

thats my personal understanding of my Sanatan Dharma.
 
.
This is a case of cheating by impersonating as clearing mentioned in the FIR filed by Medha Khole.
yes, that I have mentioned. it's a lie, but told out of greed to get some money. Rebuke her...ok, but FIR?

I have nothing to contribute in this thread, given that I, myself is not a brahmin (not by birth, atleast).
I am an Ilishi (Hilsa) pagal Bramhin...:D
 
.
But by Karma you can be :)

anyone can be a brahmin by karma for that matter.

thats my personal understanding of my Sanatan Dharma.
No You can not.

Brahmins are the people who can trace their lineage back to Vedic priests.
 
.
No You can not.

Brahmins are the people who can trace their lineage back to Vedic priests.

bhai inna load na le.

let me have my personal understanding and you have yours.

thanks !
 
.
bhai inna load na le.

let me have my personal understanding and you have yours.

thanks !
There is no hate for you or anyother person in my post.

It is simple to be a Brahmin you have to take birth in Brahmin family. Just like rajput, baniya, jat etc etc.
 
.
There is no hate for you or anyother person in my post.

It is simple to be a Brahmin you have to take birth in Brahmin family. Just like rajput, baniya, jat etc etc.
Theek+Hai.jpeg
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom