What's new

Citizenship for Afghans, Bengalis opposed by KP businessmen and traders

Kabira

BANNED
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
14,383
Reaction score
-20
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
PESHAWAR: Businessmen and traders on Thursday rejected the prime minister’s announcement for the grant of Pakistani citizenship to Afghan nationals living in the country for decades and warned that if the government made such a move, they would stop paying taxes and utility bills.

In separate statements, All Pakistan Commercial Exporters Association chairman Abdul Jalil, Peshawar Chamber of Small Traders and Small Industries senior vice president Haji Mamoor Khan and Markaz Tanzeem-i-Tajiran Khyber Pakhtunkhwa president Malik Mehr Ilahi urged the premier to withdraw announcement on citizenship for Afghans, Bengalis saying it has caused serious unrest among businessmen and traders.

Mr Jalil said the country had around four million Afghans and most of them lived in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where they completely controlled different businesses.

“These Afghan nationals are not paying any kind of tax and are in the habit of fleeing to own country whenever the Federal Board of Revenue or other tax collecting agency cracks down on tax evaders,” he said.

He said Pakistanis regularly paid taxes but didn’t get incentives.

Mr Mamoor said the premier had issued the citizenship statement without knowing ground realities.

“We (businessmen and traders) have been left with no option but to stop paying utility bills and taxes as the foreigners doing different businesses don’t pay taxes,” he warned.

Mr Ilahi said the grant of Pakistani citizenship to Afghans would turn the local population into a minority as the Afghan nationals had a majority in many areas, especially in markets.

He said various trader bodies of the province would hold a joint meeting after Ashura to take a unified stand on the matter.

“The traders of Peshawar have unanimously rejected the premier’s announcement on citizenship for Afghans,” he said.

The trader leader said Khyber Pakhtunkhwa had already suffered heavily due to militancy but the successive governments had never considered it serious to support the people affected by it.

He said instead of awarding citizenship to foreigners, the government should focus on the resolution of the problems of own tax-paying citizens.

Mr Ilahi said Afghanis had controlled business in the country and if they were given citizenship, then the local traders won’t be able to do business.

He said before granting citizenship to Afghans, the government should seek proposals from stakeholders to make a decision in the best national interest.

Published in Dawn, September 21st, 2018
https://www.dawn.com/news/1434169/citizenship-for-afghans-bengalis-opposed
 
.
It baffles me how Pakistan have allowed afghanis to set up businesses. You can't compete with smugglers and non-tax payers. I hope Peshawar traders stick to their promise of not paying bills and taxes till illegal afghanis businesses are closed down.

Its good thing Peshawaris know who's afghani because in punjab and Karachi they will start playing pathan victim card. Same have happened in Balochistan but they don't say it out loud and fire from shoulders of Baloch nationalists instead.

@Desert Fox @django
 
.
PESHAWAR: Businessmen and traders on Thursday rejected the prime minister’s announcement for the grant of Pakistani citizenship to Afghan nationals living in the country for decades and warned that if the government made such a move, they would stop paying taxes and utility bills.

In separate statements, All Pakistan Commercial Exporters Association chairman Abdul Jalil, Peshawar Chamber of Small Traders and Small Industries senior vice president Haji Mamoor Khan and Markaz Tanzeem-i-Tajiran Khyber Pakhtunkhwa president Malik Mehr Ilahi urged the premier to withdraw announcement on citizenship for Afghans, Bengalis saying it has caused serious unrest among businessmen and traders.

Mr Jalil said the country had around four million Afghans and most of them lived in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where they completely controlled different businesses.

“These Afghan nationals are not paying any kind of tax and are in the habit of fleeing to own country whenever the Federal Board of Revenue or other tax collecting agency cracks down on tax evaders,” he said.

He said Pakistanis regularly paid taxes but didn’t get incentives.

Mr Mamoor said the premier had issued the citizenship statement without knowing ground realities.

“We (businessmen and traders) have been left with no option but to stop paying utility bills and taxes as the foreigners doing different businesses don’t pay taxes,” he warned.

Mr Ilahi said the grant of Pakistani citizenship to Afghans would turn the local population into a minority as the Afghan nationals had a majority in many areas, especially in markets.

He said various trader bodies of the province would hold a joint meeting after Ashura to take a unified stand on the matter.

“The traders of Peshawar have unanimously rejected the premier’s announcement on citizenship for Afghans,” he said.

The trader leader said Khyber Pakhtunkhwa had already suffered heavily due to militancy but the successive governments had never considered it serious to support the people affected by it.

He said instead of awarding citizenship to foreigners, the government should focus on the resolution of the problems of own tax-paying citizens.

Mr Ilahi said Afghanis had controlled business in the country and if they were given citizenship, then the local traders won’t be able to do business.

He said before granting citizenship to Afghans, the government should seek proposals from stakeholders to make a decision in the best national interest.

Published in Dawn, September 21st, 2018
https://www.dawn.com/news/1434169/citizenship-for-afghans-bengalis-opposed
Ok that is sad but that is a legislation problem which the old govt (not just in KPK coz this is problematic on National level not just provincial level) was never questioned about and the new govt has to address in different forms all over the country...Not just "foreigners" are evading taxes but our own as well!
 
.
Ok that is sad but that is a legislation problem which the old govt (not just in KPK coz this is problematic on National level not just provincial level) was never questioned about and the new govt has to address in different forms all over the country...Not just "foreigners" are evading taxes but our own as well!

Your own don't have any place to run if FBR come looking for them. They can't go to Afghanistan and bring smuggled goods to dump in Pakistani markets. Afghanis have 1 leg in Pakistan and rest of body in Afghanistan.
 
.
I dont think AFGHAN NATIONALS are being granted citizenship but REFUGEES who are people with problems not necessary with illegal business! And if this is happening than such SPECIFIC people should not be given citizenship coz even a criminal citizen of Pakistan is more a criminal than a citizen!
 
. .
Your own don't have any place to run if FBR come looking for them. They can't go to Afghanistan and bring smuggled goods to dump in Pakistani markets. Afghanis have 1 leg in Pakistan and rest of body in Afghanistan.
Well my own still managed to evade TAX for decades! Explain that?!

Afghanis who are doing this need to be dealt with coz they are criminals....Citizenship was suggested for struggling Refugees not criminals and claiming each refugee is a criminal is way and above!
 
.
I dont think AFGHAN NATIONALS are being granted citizenship but REFUGEES who are people with problems not necessary with illegal business! And if this is happening than such SPECIFIC people should not be given citizenship coz even a criminal citizen of Pakistan is more a criminal than a citizen!

Don't worry, no one is being granted citizenship. We are talking about how to send them back.

Well my own still managed to evade TAX for decades! Explain that?!

Afghanis who are doing this need to be dealt with coz they are criminals....Citizenship was suggested for struggling Refugees not criminals and claiming each refugee is a criminal is way and above!

Well your own can get caught anytime if FBR started doing its job.
 
.
He said instead of awarding citizenship to foreigners, the government should focus on the resolution of the problems of own tax-paying citizens.
Tax reforms is a must no doubt!

Mr Ilahi said Afghanis had controlled business in the country and if they were given citizenship, then the local traders won’t be able to do business.
This I believe is a problem with the law...How can foreigners come and "control business" without paying TAX? THIS is what corruption leads to and should be addressed! But you are by extension claiming that EVERY REFUGEE is a criminal just coz he/she is an Afghani?

He said before granting citizenship to Afghans, the government should seek proposals from stakeholders to make a decision in the best national interest.
Kindly tell me which govt has asked stakeholders anything thus far?

I mean when the bills to relax tax on rich was made who was consulted (During Nooni and PPP era)? Were the Middle class consulted?
 
.
If IK tries to implement this decision, I would like to see his government going home. I don't care how much I like him but if he will try to give my country's citizenship to traitors like Afghans then I would like to see IK going home.
 
.
Tax reforms is a must no doubt!


This I believe is a problem with the law...How can foreigners come and "control business" without paying TAX? THIS is what corruption leads to and should be addressed! But you are by extension claiming that EVERY REFUGEE is a criminal just coz he/she is an Afghani?

Indeed because no where else refugees are allowed to run business. Only happen in banana republics.
 
.
Don't worry, no one is being granted citizenship. We are talking about how to send them back.
Send them back? Criminals should just be dealt with as criminal irrespective of their nationality! They should pass a bill that states that criminals will lose a hand or arm if involved doing criminal activities....or worse capital punishment...We have enough people burdening our lands to kill a few off...And NGO should just adopt these criminals in their respective countries if they cry for them! THAT should be the msg! ANYONE who is gonna cry for criminals can pay the fine and adopt them off our lands! SIMPLE!
 
. . . .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom