CIA declassified documents Air War 1971 - PAF v IAF

[KhanBaba2]

The said report also clearly States that the third planned attack on Karachi was thwarted after Pakistan Navy counter attacked which resulted in the sinking of an Indian warship....... after that no attacks were executed on Karachi ........

now if Karachi was neutralized altogether then why the third attack was planned???
if karachi was left inoperable, then why the Pakistan Navy clearly outnumbered bothered to counter attack???


as I said before,
given the presence of resources.... Karachi was adequately defended....... unfortunately it happened later then it should have.

US being able to blockade is another conversation better left non-discussed.

There was no need to execute any attack on Karachi because Karachi was not operational. Read the CIA report I have linked to. That is a neutral source. Your source is Pakistani.

 

[ebrahym]

There was no need to execute any attack on Karachi because Karachi was not operational. Read the CIA report I have linked to. That is a neutral source. Your source is Pakistani.

quoted extracts are from Indian sources actually....
they claim third attack was planned.....
CIA report merely reports sinking of IN vessel aftermath of second attack on Karachi....

Its still fake on PDF-(Sarcasm)



Great line- I am going to save this so I dont have to waste my time to respond to the guy who only talks about links and wieners- (You dismiss BBC as Jewish. Pak links are Indian agents. American links are Indian allies. So don't waste your time and mine. Google if you care about the truth).

yeah on google most of links are again either Indian or Indian websites claiming "inside sorces"......
can you see the conundrum here sir?????
if you want the truth you would get the truth
if you wanted validation of your perspective you would get that as well ...
you seem to focus on latter

 

[Shah_G]

Lol. Lost East Pakistan. Lost Turtuk in Gilgit Baltistan. Lost 5000 sq km in Sindh, West Pakistan. Surrendered 90k + troops. Lost 55% of population. Signed a humiliating Treaty of Surrender in a public display in former capital of East Wing. Evacuated from East Pakistan by Indian troops under protection.

And yet... "Hey look at this CIA report. We did so well!".

Took half India, independence Pakistan. Took half of Kashmir, 1965 gave you a big danda. 1971 had no balls to step into our territory until the Russian fleet approached Bay of Bengal. 1999 gave you big danda once again and got humiliated by our forces who wrecked hovac on Indians. 2002 again no balls, 2008 no balls again, 27th feb is recent and again we made you a laughing stock around the world. How much humiliation more would India like from a country which is 5 times smaller it size. Such a Daam shame kid.

 

[Jackdaws]

Took half India, independence Pakistan. Took half of Kashmir, 1965 gave you a big danda. 1971 had no balls to step into our territory until the Russian fleet approached Bay of Bengal. 1999 gave you big danda once again and got humiliated by our forces who wrecked hovac on Indians. 2002 again no balls, 2008 no balls again, 27th feb is recent and again we made you a laughing stock around the world. How much humiliation more would India like from a country which is 5 times smaller it size. Such a Daam shame kid.

Chalo in lockdown someone is scoring some good ganja.

 

[arjunk]

Lol. Lost East Pakistan. Lost Turtuk in Gilgit Baltistan. Lost 5000 sq km in Sindh, West Pakistan. Surrendered 90k + troops. Lost 55% of population. Signed a humiliating Treaty of Surrender in a public display in former capital of East Wing. Evacuated from East Pakistan by Indian troops under protection.

And yet... "Hey look at this CIA report. We did so well!".

India is at a net loss of territory. You got one village in Gilgit Baltistan. Congratulations. Meanwhile you lost Azad Kashmir, all of Gilgit Baltistan, Chamb (1971), Kutch (1965) and much more that the dhoti brigade has wiped off the internet. And if you buy into a delusion that akhand bharat ever existed, you also lost Tibet, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bhutan, Banlgadesh, and Burma. Any competent military would laugh their asses off at anyone trying to pass 1971 as an amazing Indian victory against Pakistan.

 

[Jackdaws]

India is at a net loss of territory. You got one village in Gilgit Baltistan. Congratulations. Meanwhile you lost Azad Kashmir, all of Gilgit Baltistan, Chamb (1971), Kutch (1965) and much more that the dhoti brigade has wiped off the internet. And if you buy into a delusion that akhand bharat ever existed, you also lost Tibet, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Bhutan, Banlgadesh, and Burma. Any competent military would laugh their asses off at anyone trying to pass 1971 as an amazing Indian victory against Pakistan.

Tsk Tsk. We didn't lose not so "Azad" Kashmir. We never had it. Ditto with Gilgit-Baltistan. 10% of Pakistan's claim on Rann of Kutch was awarded to it via a neutral tribunal. But dream on little boy. Keep surrendering, losing and keep thumping your chest. Works well for us.

 

[ChennaiDude]

quoted extracts are from Indian sources actually....
they claim third attack was planned.....
CIA report merely reports sinking of IN vessel aftermath of second attack on Karachi....


yeah on google most of links are again either Indian or Indian websites claiming "inside sorces"......
can you see the conundrum here sir?????
if you want the truth you would get the truth
if you wanted validation of your perspective you would get that as well ...
you seem to focus on latter

We as humans are smart enough to understand what is fake and what is not!- The first important attribute one has to have for understanding fake or not fake is to have an open mind in truthfully listening (Not agreeing)-to both sides of the story- (Google is only an example- Use Yahoo/Bing etc as well)

 

[KhanBaba2]

quoted extracts are from Indian sources actually....
they claim third attack was planned.....
CIA report merely reports sinking of IN vessel aftermath of second attack on Karachi....

Are you talking of https://www.aaj.tv/english/national...-which-changed-the-course-of-1971-war-at-sea/ as the source or some other one.

 

[Shah_G]

Chalo in lockdown someone is scoring some good ganja.

When you get put on your place all you remember is ganja. Okat par aa gaya

 

[PradoTLC]

Chalo in lockdown someone is scoring some good ganja.

yes..

as of today we can nuke india in 15 min...

think.. what a strategic failure that is for you.

Rann of Kutch was awarded

lovely little battle ... you guys got a pounding there...

 

[ebrahym]

We as humans are smart enough to understand what is fake and what is not!- The first important attribute one has to have for understanding fake or not fake is to have an open mind in truthfully listening (Not agreeing)-to both sides of the story- (Google is only an example- Use Yahoo/Bing etc as well)

Are you talking of https://www.aaj.tv/english/national...-which-changed-the-course-of-1971-war-at-sea/ as the source or some other one.

aaj tv is a Pakistan source
you can hop on any Indian forum and look for that ......
as I previously said
google it
either you will find the truth or validation of your perspective
it all depends on you

 

[KhanBaba2]

aaj tv is a Pakistan source
you can hop on any Indian forum and look for that ......
as I previously said
google it
either you will find the truth or validation of your perspective
it all depends on you

You said "quoted extracts are from Indian sources actually....". I just want to know the source.
I am not on any Indian forum.

 

[SQ8]

71 was a fairly decent performance by the PAF considering the odds it faced - especially by 14th sq.. and the objectives set for it to support the fizzled Tikka counter offensive.

 

[ebrahym]

You said "quoted extracts are from Indian sources actually....". I just want to know the source.
I am not on any Indian forum.

well you should be ........
goto bharat rakshak or indi defence ...
dont try to lay in a dug grave do some research ...
I would do it for you but its ramadan,,,, i have been fasting and getting quite lazy

regards.

71 was a fairly decent performance by the PAF considering the odds it faced - especially by 14th sq.. and the objectives set for it to support the fizzled Tikka counter offensive.

it absolutely was....

 

[KhanBaba2]

well you should be ........
goto bharat rakshak or indi defence ...
dont try to lay in a dug grave do some research ...
I would do it for you but its ramadan,,,, i have been fasting and getting quite lazy

regards.

Why would you need to research. You already know the Indian source.