What's new

CIA Chief's Hacked Email: Pak Uses Militant Proxies Against India

Styx

BANNED
Joined
May 22, 2015
Messages
1,972
Reaction score
-14
Country
India
Location
India
Pakistan uses militants as proxies to counter India's growing influence in Afghanistan, according to a set of documents released by WikiLeaks from the hacked personal email account of CIA Director John Brennan.

The documents, released by the whistle-blower website and deemed classified by the CIA, contained reports on Afghanistan and Pakistan, and also ideas for US policy towards Iran.

Brennan, three days after Barack Obama was elected US President in November 2008, wrote to him in a position-cum- strategy paper that Pakistan uses the Taliban to counter India in Afghanistan.

"Pakistan's desire to counter India's growing influence in Afghanistan and concerns about US long-term commitments to Afghanistan increase Pakistan's interest in hedging its bets by ensuring that it will be able to have a working relationship with the Taliban to balance Indian and Iranian interests if the US withdraws," Brennan wrote on November 7 in 2008.

Brennan, then a top foreign policy and counter-terrorism adviser to Obama, then a president-elect, was in the running to be CIA Director. The post, however, went to Leon Panetta.

Obama initially made Brennan his top counter-terrorism adviser, and in January 2013 he nominated him as CIA Director.

Brennan's views on Pakistan was disclosed in a 13-page executive summary of key findings and recommendations on Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Brennan, in the summary, said efforts in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) have been challenged by Pakistan's ambivalence towards, and perhaps outright support for, the Taliban.

"While the US Intelligence Community differs on the extent of the relationships, at least some elements of Pakistan's military and intelligence services appear to be ambivalent about the anti-Taliban and anti-militant mission in the FATA, in part due to their history of close ties to the Taliban in Afghanistan's conflict with the Soviet Union and Pakistan's use of militant proxies in its conflict with India," he wrote.

Coalition forces have won every major battle with Afghan insurgents, but these tactical successes have not resulted in a strategic victory, largely because insurgents are free to regroup in sanctuaries across the Af-Pak border, he wrote.

On Wednesday, WikiLeaks began publishing documents from "Brennan's non-government email accounts". They appear to date back to 2007-09, when Brennan worked in the private sector.

CIA Chief's Hacked Email: Pak Uses Militant Proxies Against India | Oct 26,2015
 
.
Pakistan uses militants as proxies to counter India's growing influence in Afghanistan,

This shouldn't be news to anybody, I don't think even the Pakistanis actually deny this, except of course for official purposes.

Coalition forces have won every major battle with Afghan insurgents, but these tactical successes have not resulted in a strategic victory, largely because insurgents are free to regroup in sanctuaries across the Af-Pak border, he wrote.

This is what there needs to be a solution to. I don't think there is an easy answer.
 
.
Indian starts their propoganda .. if you ask any indian how are you? they say .. i am good but Pakistani are not good..
then if you ask whats going on they say ..Nothing.. but Pakistani are doing somthing and if you ask whats your plan for today they say i do this and that but hey Pakistani are not good they are up to somthing with eye brow raiz..
matter fact their nation obsessed with Pakistan .. they call Pakistan or write more than they do their own name..
no wonder all this type of leaks only come from India or indians.. no wonder it calls leaks..
get a life dude!
 
. .
Nothing new. Old claims without any evidence. Media creates these spicy news. There is nothing substantial.

Even if it is true, so what. They did that in 71 & they are doing now through Afghanistan creating problems.

They will say give proof, we say give proof. Simple as that.
 
.
Even if it is true, so what. They did that in 71 & they are doing now through Afghanistan creating problems.

They will say give proof, we say give proof. Simple as that.

They admitted themself. Ajit dovel advocates defensive offensive strategy and support of BLA and TTP. However Pakistan is not supporting kashmiri freedom fighters since 9 /11.
 
.
They admitted themself. Ajit dovel advocates defensive offensive strategy and support of BLA and TTP. However Pakistan is not supporting kashmiri freedom fighters since 9 /11.

If they had not been doing it, it has been a mistake. Its now time that we reconsider that policy.
 
.
its now even a open top secret that these leaks are on purpose ... thats how Arab uprising started and thats how they leak when make things difficult and they can cash on it ...

2 Questions need to be answered ..
1- WHY only those are leaked whats needed by USA
2- Even if this is correct, that does not tell us whats the truth, does it ? its the understanding of one american person who is telling the bosses what they want to hear .. job done.. it does not tell the true realities on the ground ..
 
.
Topic header created by Indians

CIA Chief's Hacked Email: Pakistan Uses Militant Proxies Against India.

This is what he Actually said.

Brennan, three days after Barack Obama was elected US President in November 2008, wrote to him in a position-cum- strategy paper that Pakistan uses the Taliban to counter India in Afghanistan.

"Pakistan's desire to counter India's growing influence in Afghanistan and concerns about US long-term commitments to Afghanistan increase Pakistan's interest in hedging its bets by ensuring that it will be able to have a working relationship with the Taliban to balance Indian and Iranian interests if the US withdraws," Brennan wrote on November 7 in 2008.


Off course its our desire to to counter Indians in Afghanistan, Indians aren't in Afghanistan because they have solved the poverty at home and now out to spread the wealth and well wishes, they are in Afghanistan to train, arm and finance terrorist to be used against Pakistan. It would be foolish for any government in Islamabad to ignore Indian activities in Afghanistan.
 
.
Topic header created by Indians

CIA Chief's Hacked Email: Pakistan Uses Militant Proxies Against India.

This is what he Actually said.




Off course its our desire to to counter Indians in Afghanistan, Indians aren't in Afghanistan because they have solved the poverty at home and now out to spread the wealth and well wishes, they are in Afghanistan to train, arm and finance terrorist to be used against Pakistan. It would be foolish for any government in Islamabad to ignore Indian activities in Afghanistan.
?????


Afghanistan Pakistan Executive Summary
 
.
If they had not been doing it, it has been a mistake. Its now time that we reconsider that policy.

After 9/11 we acted against every extremist/terrorist organisation. We co operated with US on WOT meanwhile india fueled insurgency in Pakistan.
We need to pay back in same currency as soon as possible.
 
.
After 9/11 we acted against every extremist/terrorist organisation. We co operated with US on WOT meanwhile india fueled insurgency in Pakistan.
We need to pay back in same currency as soon as possible.

Well in these kinds of games there are no winners but still the country having deeper pockets, more men and less enemies usually has an upper hand.

If Pakistan does want to continue playing proxy-proxy then things indeed would get worse and then worse again because now India is no longer going to be a passive observer of 90s taking hits upon hits on the chin and still holding back.
 
.
Well in these kinds of games there are no winners but still the country having deeper pockets, more men and less enemies usually has an upper hand.

If Pakistan does want to continue playing proxy-proxy then things indeed would get worse and then worse again because now India is no longer going to be a passive observer of 90s taking hits upon hits on the chin and still holding back.

You are one of the sane Indian posters I encountered with on PDF. But sorry mate india and Pakistan both are capable to completely destroy each other. No one is stronger or weaker when you cross certain thresholds considering N factor in mind.
So move down to conventional options. As already debated and concluded that you cannot limit conventional option once launched to below N kind of stuff. So MAD is not intelligent decision. Sanity must prevail.
Talk about proxies. Balochistan almost neutralized , we effectively managed against TTP. so hope for the best............ continue with your assets TTP and BLA ........rest you know........ wait for pay back time.
I hope no argument for sake of argument.
Relax
 
.
You are one of the sane Indian posters I encountered with on PDF. But sorry mate india and Pakistan both are capable to completely destroy each other. No one is stronger or weaker when you cross certain thresholds considering N factor in mind.
So move down to conventional options. As already debated and concluded that you cannot limit conventional option once launched to below N kind of stuff. So MAD is not intelligent decision. Sanity must prevail.
Talk about proxies. Balochistan almost neutralized , we effectively managed against TTP. so hope for the best............ continue with your assets TTP and BLA ........rest you know........ wait for pay back time.
I hope no argument for sake of argument.
Relax

1. My argument was restricted to proxies not conventional or nuclear confrontation.
2. I hope none of us employ proxies to destabilize the other but it one does then it is inevitable that the other will payback. No arguments on that and in that case of proxy war one with more resources will have an upper hand.

Regards
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom