What's new

China Threatens India With ‘Liquid Bomb’ That Could Be Much More Dangerous Than Ladakh & Doklam

undercover JIX

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 6, 2008
Messages
9,146
Reaction score
2
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
China Threatens India With ‘Liquid Bomb’ That Could Be Much More Dangerous Than Ladakh & Doklam

Published
November 9, 2020
By
Younis Dar
After troubling India militarily in the Himalayan region of Ladakh, Beijing could now hurt the South Asian country by drying up the crucial rivers that flow into the country through Tibet.


China has indicated that it is going ahead with building mega-dams on the lower reaches of the Yarlung Tsangpo, which flows from Tibet into northeast India.
Beijing’s control over the key rivers flowing into India gives it a chokehold on India’s economy, effectively crippling India’s interests in the North East region.


The country’s occupation of Tibet, which is often called the “Third Pole”, owing to its vast freshwater and glacial resources, gives it a strategic stranglehold to dominate the bilateral discourse with India.

The rivers emerging from the Tibetan plateau remain vital for about nine neighboring nations in the region and the disputes about the distribution of waters have lingered for decades.

However, the new Chinese belligerence is explained by the tensions in Ladakh that have worsened this year with India. At least 20 Indian soldiers were killed while clashing with PLA in the region this year, while the count of Chinese casualties remains unknown.


India now fears Beijing could use dams and other water infrastructure as a strategic tool to expand its control over the region, analysts at South China Morning Post (SCMP) state.

Since 2010, China has planned hydropower projects on the river, known in India as the Brahmaputra, to harness energy in the middle reaches of the river. Now the country is focusing on the lower reaches of the river, closer to India, which could create challenges for the river’s utility in India.

According to SCMP, at least 11 hydroelectric projects along the river have been operating or being planned by China over the past decade. The largest among the three known to be in operation is Zangmu, which started to fully operate in 2015.

Hydropower stations in Bayu, Jiexi, Langta, Dakpa, Nang, Demo, Namcha, and Metok towns in Tibet are either on the drawing board or under construction.
The middle basin of the Yarlung river is closer to the Line of Actual Control (LAC) – a 3,488 km unmarked de facto boundary between China and India that has seen decades of claims and counterclaims.

The country’s new plans for harnessing the lower basin could potentially dry up the resources of the river resulting in a significant challenge to the Indian needs.
“These (dam projects) have instigated worries in India as Chinese construction of dams close to the LAC, mixed with the India-China boundary disputes, assumes to be carrying strategic intents while creating a strategic divide between India and its Himalayan rivers,” SCMP quoted Jagannath Panda, a research fellow at New Delhi’s Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses, as saying.

He also noted the Chinese foreign ministry’s recent claim that Beijing had never recognized Arunachal Pradesh as an alarming sign that China might use the dams and other water infrastructure as “a strategic tool to expand its control over the region”.

And as the recent clashes on the Sino-Indian border have made clear, India needs to assess how China might “weaponize” its advantage over those countries downstream, observes Lowy Institute.

The two rival countries are signatories to the data-sharing treaty signed in 2008, for the Sutlej and Brahmaputra in order to better manage the shared watercourses. Agreements like these can have a positive effect on water management by helping to prepare for and control floods, but since China has access to the data, it could use this dependence to exploit India by withholding that hydrological data.


When the two countries clashed in Doklam in 2017, China refused to divulge critical hydrological data for the Brahmaputra and Sutlej rivers, which reportedly resulted in floods in the states of Assam and Uttar Pradesh.

China is reported to have been responsible for causing the build-up of a lake, in 2004, on the Parechu river, which is a tributary of the Sutlej, threatening to cause floods in lower down in India’s Sutlej valley.

The country refused requests by India to send scientists and engineers to the site, and it was suspected that China knowingly created “a liquid bomb”, an artificial lake unleashed deliberately to devastate downstream areas.

The concerns of China creating another liquid bomb to effectively breach and weaponize the waters of the Parechu lake were again raised in June 2020, when a rise of 12 to 14 meters was observed in the river.

Experts are lamenting the lack of a mutually agreed dispute-settlement mechanism for the two countries to avoid such confrontations, which leaves little options for India. The Lowy Institute also offers a viable solution for India, to lead a counter-coalition of countries that share transboundary rivers, and forge a common institutional set-up for better trans-boundary management of shared rivers.

However, until the bilateral relations improve between the two countries, and an agreement is reached at the tense Ladakh border, any solution to the water wars is unlikely to emerge.

The two countries recently held the eighth round of military talks to diffuse tensions at the border, and there were little indications of the two countries permanently solving the boundary dispute.


--------------------------------------------

Modi can use user as weapon, but china wants to the same ....Indian backside is on fire....Modi hai to mumkin hai.
 
Concern on Upstream Flooding
In 2006, Indian media reported that the NHPC was planning to relocate and scale down the project due to concerns on flooding upstream by Chinese government.[3] However, the Arunachal Pradesh government has awarded contracts and commenced work on the project as per initial plans.

The state government of Arunachal Pradesh signed deals with various Indian power companies to develop hydro projects. A total of 42 schemes are planned to generate electricity in excess of 27,000 MW with the Upper Siang project being one of them.[4]

India ignored China's concerns when they were building their dams, and now they're crying 'liquid bomb'.

Since India has threatened Chinese interests upstream, China of course should take control of its water to minimize the Indian threat. It's done in self-defense, if India insists on using military metaphors.
 
They can't afford to do that since the Indus River also derives its liquid from Tibet. By choking India, they'd be choking Pakistan which would hamper their investments.

It's an empty threat.
 
They can't afford to do that since the Indus River also derives its liquid from Tibet. By choking India, they'd be choking Pakistan which would hamper their investments.

It's an empty threat.
Yeah i doubt it would ever be used since it would affect our allies as well plus its a total war sort of weapon to attack civilians rather than military. With a modernised army in China and a depleted army in India, there is no reason for China to go above and beyond. Plus China has got hundreds of thermonuclear bombs in the megaton range while India only has small nuclear bombs in the kiloton range. There is great shift towards chinese side which is why China will never attack India if it affects Pakistan as well but its fun just poking at the Indians when they talk about closing off the malaca straight.
 
India has been periodically harming Bangladesh by withholding water during dry season and then allowing water to rise to dangerous level during the monsoon season before opening the floodgates in farrakha barrage to flood bangladesh.

It has been indian national policy. I guess karma is a bitch...
 
They can't afford to do that since the Indus River also derives its liquid from Tibet. By choking India, they'd be choking Pakistan which would hamper their investments.

It's an empty threat.

As if chinese govt gives damn about pakistan. They don't care about chinese people. Example: cultural revolution and great leap forward etc.
 
As if chinese govt gives damn about pakistan. They don't care about chinese people. Example: cultural revolution and great leap forward etc.

They care about their investments and a lucrative arms market. Pakistan obtains the former and acts as the latter.
 
As if chinese govt gives damn about pakistan. They don't care about chinese people. Example: cultural revolution and great leap forward etc.
Why do you bring up the past that happened generations ago? Do white people still own slaves and colonise lands? You have very low IQ indian boy.
 
The indians started this with claims they will dry up Pakistan. Enjoy the fruits of your labour
 
They care about their investments and a lucrative arms market. Pakistan obtains the former and acts as the latter.
CPEC is loan. It is not an investment.
Why do you bring up the past that happened generations ago? Do white people still own slaves and colonise lands? You have very low IQ indian boy.
Well it is same CCP.
 
In the event of China blocking rivers to India and hence to downstream nations Pakistan and Bangladesh

North India and Bangladesh will be able to manage due to rainfall
South India has it own rivers
The same cannot be said about large majority of Pakistan-
1605044736758.png





Funny to see Pakistani cheerleader OP celebrating potential water crisis in his nation all for some comparatively minor issues for India
 

Attachments

  • 1605044981775.png
    1605044981775.png
    505.4 KB · Views: 16
Northeast of India has too much water. The region has most rainfall in the world. This article is just bullshit. Actually the water reservoirs upstream can reduce flooding downstream during the raining season. India can build some dam downstream too to smooth out the seasonal difference.
 
In the event of China blocking rivers to India and hence to downstream nations Pakistan and Bangladesh

North India and Bangladesh will be able to manage due to rainfall
South India has it own rivers
The same cannot be said about large majority of Pakistan-
View attachment 687334




Funny to see Pakistani cheerleader OP celebrating potential water crisis in his nation all for some comparatively minor issues for India

Funny to see Pakistani cheerleader OP celebrating potential water crisis in his nation all for some comparatively minor issues for India


You are really a true Indian.

Your Indian media is crying which I posted,
Brahmans did not allow you to read and understand simple things? where you see my celebrations?

No wonder Brahmans own you people.

After troubling India militarily in the Himalayan region of Ladakh, Beijing could now hurt the South Asian country by drying up the crucial rivers that flow into the country through Tibet.


China has indicated that it is going ahead with building mega-dams on the lower reaches of the Yarlung Tsangpo, which flows from Tibet into northeast India.
Beijing’s control over the key rivers flowing into India gives it a chokehold on India’s economy, effectively crippling India’s interests in the North East region.
@Syama Ayas see India crying.....nothing for me to cheer, its just your dhoti is on fire.

Dam it! How China controls flow of rivers into India
Samir K Purkayastha

The Siang river in Arunachal Pradesh has been behaving quirkily since June 9, 2000 — the day it suddenly rose by 30 metres, inundating almost the entire Pasighat town through which it flows south-west to meet Dibang and Lohit to form the Brahmaputra.

From that day, local people had been observing something amiss in the flowing pattern of the river. But even they were not prepared for what they saw on the morning of March 1, 2012. The river had dried out, as if by magic.

The unusual phenomenon expectedly made global news and the fingers were immediately raised at China, which was constructing a massive dam on the upper reaches of the river in Tibet where the Brahmaputra is called Yarlung Tsangpo.

Arunachal Pradesh government too suspected Chinese role in the mysterious drying up of the Siang.

What was more amazing was that by afternoon the flow of the river apparently resumed as magically as it had disappeared.

Surprisingly, the Arunachal government’s concerns did not find resonance with the Centre, which downplayed the occurrence. The then External Affairs Minister S.M. Krishna on March 12 reiterated that there was no evidence of China constructing any dam on the river.

A year later India did wake up to the danger and raised its concerns about the dam construction at the India-China strategic dialogue held in August 2013.

Untitled-design-2020-07-03T141658.943.jpg

Brahmaputra River is called Yarlung Tsangpo in Tibet | Photo: Wikimedia Commons

The Zangmu Dam built on the Yarlung Zangbo/Brahmaputra River at the Tibet Autonomous Region’s Gyaca, near a tri-junction of China-Bhutan-India border is however just the tip of the iceberg. China, the source of 10 major rivers flowing to 11 countries, is now in a hydropower dam-building spree.

According to a report of the International Rivers, a US-base international network of dam-affected people, today there are more than 87,000 dams in China, including the world’s largest Three Gorges Dam.

Apart from the Brahmaputra, another major Indian river Sutlej, known as Langqen Zangbod in China, also originates in Tibet. So, India being a riparian country has a genuine concern over the Chinese move to restrict the flow of these rivers.

Triggering further concern for New Delhi, Beijing signed a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with Pakistan in 2017 to build Bhasha and Bunji Dams on the River Indus in Gilgit-Baltistan, the area India accuses Pakistan of illegally occupying.

Beijing, however, denies any allegation of it leveraging this water-advantage to pressurise India or other neighbours by trying to divert water. But lack of transparency about the projects keeps the fear alive.

Related News: Prime Minister Modi reaches Leh in surprise visit

China has its own compulsion to exploit the world’s water tap Tibet to provide water to its fast-drying northern region, observes Dr. Binoda Kumar Mishra, director Centre for Studies in International Relations and Development.

He says the South-to-North water diversion project undertaken by China will have a long-term impact on India’s water security. The ambitious project to be completed by 2050 plans to divert 44.8 billion cubic metres of water annually from its southern region through three waterways called — Eastern, Middle and Western routes.

Incidentally, with a projected population of 1.4 billion by 2050, India is forecast to become "water-scarce" by then.

Barring an understanding to share hydrological data of the Brahmaputra and Sutlej, India does not have any water-sharing treaty with Beijing to protect its rights as a lower riparian state.

Not that any such treaty would help much with the country that was belligerent to an international convention, points out Mishra who had worked closely with several Chinese think-tanks and policy organisations as part of Kolkata to Kunming (K2K) Forum, that sought to strengthen sub-regional economic cooperation between India and China.


 
Last edited:

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom