What's new

China, India's interests in Myanmar spell a bleak future for Rohingyas

bluesky

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 14, 2016
Messages
16,515
Reaction score
-4
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Japan
September 08, 2017 / LAST MODIFIED: 02:50 AM, September 08, 2017
1,64,000 ROHINGYAS FLEE TO BANGLADESH SO FAR
Caught in the thick

China, India's interests in Myanmar spell a bleak future for Rohingyas

violence_on_rohingya_4.jpg

A section of the over 10,000 Rohingyas, top, who have gathered at Bagghuna of Jamtali in Cox's Bazar. Photo: Anisur Rahman/AFP

Inam Ahmed and Shakhawat Liton

Indian Premier Narendra Modi's stance on the Rohingya issue has emerged as another example of how the plights of the ethnic minority get trampled at the altar of geo-political considerations.

China's support for Myanmar in whatever it does regarding the Rohingyas also fits into the same picture.

As these two superpowers position themselves on the issue, the haze lifts -- the most persecuted people of modern times, the Rohingyas, have a dark future.

A complex mesh of military, economic and strategic issues now stand solid before the Rohingya issue.

China, for example, holds the biggest influence on Myanmar and also has stakes in energy, in its ambitious $1 trillion “one belt, one road” project, in securing a military base in the deep sea to have a sway over the Indian Ocean, and in ensuring that Muslim extremists cannot threaten either of the countries.

As relations with the US turned bitter over the South China Sea, China now wants to have better relations with the Southeast Asian nations, using its deep pocket in infrastructure investments, defence deals and diplomatic overtures.

The Philippines with which China has a long-standing spat over the Spratly Islands purchased Chinese submarines recently.

China was successful in persuading Thailand in sending back 100 Muslim Uighur leaders, involved in brewing separatist movement in China, back in 2015.

Beijing has moved to put relations with South Korea back on track following months of tension over the deployment of a US anti-missile system in the region. Chinese President Xi Jinping called South Korean leader Moon Jae-In to congratulate him shortly after his election victory in early May.

violence_on_rohingya_5.jpg

A refugee, Taslima suffers from a tragedy no parent should witness. She breaks down in tears every time she thinks about the seven-year-old son she left behind. Her husband too was lost in the chaos and now she clings onto her two-year-old son, the only family member she now has. Photo: Anisur Rahman/AFP
China is playing a key role in negotiation between the Myanmarese rebels and the government. Chinese military hardware is the mainstay of Myanmar's military might.

Myanmar, which is in a solid position both militarily and politically, is now ranked 31 in world military firepower, according to Global Firepower that uses CIA data.

China is at the final stage of building a deep-sea port in Rakhine, the current Rohingya hotspot, which will give it access to the eastern side of the Indian Ocean. And it wants to keep its oil and gas pipelines running through Rakhine to China safely.

Min Zin, executive director of the Institute for Strategy and Policy in Myanmar, told The New York Times that as the US influence on the country waned after the initial breakthrough, “Aung San Suu Kyi is relying more and more on China in Myanmar and on the international stage”.

India also sees Myanmar as an economic and geo-political interest.

violence_on_rohingya_6.jpg

Zahed Alam is tied to a tree by his wife. His eyes stare into the abyss. Zahed witnessed the brutal murder of both his parents when riots broke out on October 16. Since then, his mental state has deteriorated and this is the only way his wife can ensure his safety. Photo: Anisur Rahman/AFP
India plans to train Myanmar army in special operations, read as anti-insurgency warfare against Rohingyas. There lies a common interest as many of India's insurgents in the north-east region hole up in Myanmar.

India is also building a port in Rakhine State. It is also building a road from Mizoram to Sittwe of Myanmar. It is eyeing more infrastructure projects in Myanmar as a first step to grow influence in Southeast Asia and counterbalance China.

It is understandable that India will back Myanmar on the Rohingya issue as well.

So when the two Asian giants -- China and India -- have more at stake than the Rohingya miseries, Myanmar can remain unscathed in the face of any international move like that initiated by the UN secretary general who has written to the Security Council to take steps on the Rohingya issue.

turkish_help.jpg

Turkish president's wife Emine Erdogan and Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu giving an aid box to a Rohingya woman as they visit the Kutupalong refugee camp in Cox's Bazar. Photo: Anisur Rahman/AFP
Russia remains with Myanmar as well. And so China backed by Russia blocked a UN Security Council draft resolution on the Rohingyas. At a closed-door meeting at the Security Council last week, China even opposed effective engagement of the UN in Myanmar.

So for now, the Rohingyas are left in the lurch, under the open sky, in the muddy camps of Bangladesh.
 
India has to back Myanmar and, especially, having seen the havoc radical Islam can wreak on a country, we should support the Buddhists even more. Heck, it even took Hindus' most sacred temples from us.

Don't let Islamists do to the Buddhists (whether in Myanmar or in Ladakh) what they did and are doing to the Hindus in India and other parts of the world.

India has more in common with Buddhists than it will ever have with Islamists.
 
India has to back Myanmar and, especially, having seen the havoc radical Islam can wreak on a country, we should support the Buddhists even more. Heck, it even took Hindus' most sacred temples from us.

Don't let Islamists do to the Buddhists (whether in Myanmar or in Ladakh) what they did and are doing to the Hindus in India and other parts of the world.

India has more in common with Buddhists than it will ever have with Islamists.

for terrorist state of india ruled by hindu terrorists, that is the thinking. An indian journalist was killed by hindu terrorist just other day.
 
for terrorist state of india ruled by hindu terrorists, that is the thinking. An indian journalist was killed by hindu terrorist just other day.

Yeah well you're free to live in your delusions.

World needs stupid people. Only then are intelligent people like yours truly worth anything.
 
Frankly speaking iam not seeing any good future either for rohingya as whole world is blind for their own interest rather then humanity. Only way we can safe them maybe given 1.3 million rohingya citizenship by different Muslim majority countries and other European countries if they interested. Any negotiation regarding returning them back is worthless as it happened earlier without stopping the state sponsored oppression.
 
Frankly speaking iam not seeing any good future either for rohingya as whole world is blind for their own interest rather then humanity. Only way we can safe them maybe given 1.3 million rohingya citizenship by different Muslim majority countries and other European countries if they interested. Any negotiation regarding returning them back is worthless as it happened earlier without stopping the state sponsored oppression.
Rohingya needs Bangladesh far more than anybody else. Are we true to our word? Bangladesh by itself can solve 80 percent of rohingya cause.
 
Take the Rohingyas for the sake of humaity. Accept the situation. And give them citizenship.

Very few care in the world. And the two major powers in the region have their own interests which run against the welfare of the Rohingyas.

Damn man.

Also take note of the vermin who support the Myanmar government and attempt to twist the narrative.
 
Take the Rohingyas for the sake of humaity. Accept the situation. And give them citizenship.

Very few care in the world. And the two major powers in the region have their own interests which run against the welfare of the Rohingyas.

Damn man.

Also take note of the vermin who support the Myanmar government and attempt to twist the narrative.

The biggest supporters of Myanmar are China followed by Pakistan.
 
India has to back Myanmar and, especially, having seen the havoc radical Islam can wreak on a country, we should support the Buddhists even more. Heck, it even took Hindus' most sacred temples from us.

Don't let Islamists do to the Buddhists (whether in Myanmar or in Ladakh) what they did and are doing to the Hindus in India and other parts of the world.

India has more in common with Buddhists than it will ever have with Islamists.
what the fk you doing here then, get the fk out, there are no Buddhist here and you don't have any commonality and respect here. Where is Aurangzeb, India needs you......
 
Aurangzeb rotted in his grave and his flesh eaten by Hindu worms. Don't know if even his bones are intact or not...
what the fk you doing here then, get the fk out, there are no Buddhist here and you don't have any commonality and respect here. Where is Aurangzeb, India needs you......
 
Frankly speaking iam not seeing any good future either for rohingya as whole world is blind for their own interest rather then humanity. Only way we can safe them maybe given 1.3 million rohingya citizenship by different Muslim majority countries and other European countries if they interested. Any negotiation regarding returning them back is worthless as it happened earlier without stopping the state sponsored oppression.
Take the Rohingyas for the sake of humaity. Accept the situation. And give them citizenship.

Very few care in the world. And the two major powers in the region have their own interests which run against the welfare of the Rohingyas.

Damn man.

Also take note of the vermin who support the Myanmar government and attempt to twist the narrative.
Countries acts in self interest rather than any humanitarian principle, isn't it happening all the time? Just not in this case but in every case.And regarding UN, two opposing block always veto each others resolution, thus made UN a worthless organization.There is no point lamenting it.Whatever humanitarian intervention happened in the world, happened by sidelining the UN security council.Like NATO bombing of Serbia to protect the Kosovo civilian and forcing Serbia to accept UN rule in Kosovo.Russia and China vehemently opposed that.But it happened in anyway.It also happened in wrong ways like Iraq attack by US/UK.Russia, China and UN opposed that but happened that anyway.

The main ball in the court in this world still in the western camp.Myanmar fear nothing more that a re-imposition of western sanction, which can ruin their all the achievement done in the last several years and back them isolated pariah state which they were for 50 years.Bangladesh and other Muslim countries need to put pressure on EU and USA to re-impose sanction against Myanmar.At least EU and US try to maintain some sort of human rights principle.

57 states OIC block is the biggest after UN.It can be a big force if acts in a co-ordination.OIC's own sanction will itself will cause a lot of damage to burmese economy.It can influence powerfully to the policy of US and EU.Before Muslim countries forced to accept Rohingya refugee why not teach some hard lesson to burma? We(Muslim countries) may have to ultimately accept all the Rohingya people in a long run, but before that, burn burma with the fire which they created. Support each of the 40 insurgency creating havoc in burma, Arm to the teeth the Rohingya resistance.Let burma bled through thousand cut.Why should we give the genocidal burmese a Rohingya free country on a silver platter?
@TopCat @UKBengali @StandForInsaf @hussain0216
 
Last edited:
Countries acts in self interest rather than any humanitarian principle, isn't it happening all the time? Just not in this case but in every case.And regarding UN, two opposing block always veto each others resolution, thus made UN a worthless organization.There is no point lamenting it.Whatever humanitarian intervention happened in the world, happened by sidelining the UN security council.Like NATO bombing of Serbia to protect the Kosovo civilian and forcing Serbia to accept UN rule in Kosovo.Russia and China vehemently opposed that.But it happened in anyway.It also happened in wrong ways like Iraq attack by US/UK.Russia, China and UN opposed that but happened anyway.
The main ball in the court in this world still in the western camp.Myanmar nothing fear more that a re-imposition western sanction, which can ruin their all the achievement done in the last several years and back them isolated pariah state which they were for 50 years.Bangladesh and other muslim countries need to put pressure EU and USA to re-impose sanction against Myanmar.At least EU and US try to maintain some sort of human rights principle.

57 states OIC block is the biggest after UN.It can be a big force if acts in a co-ordination.OIC's own sanction will itself will cause a lot of damage to burmese economy.It can influence powerfully to the policy of US and EU.Before Muslim countries forced to accept Rohingya refugee why not teach some hard lesson to burma? We(muslim countries) may have to ultimately accept all the Rohingya people in a long run, but before that, burn burma with the fire which they created. Support each of the 40 insurgency creating havoc in burma, Arm to the teeth the Rohingya resistance.Let burma bled through thousand cut.Why should we give the genocidal burmese a Rohingya free country on a silver platter?
@TopCat @UKBengali @StandForInsaf @hussain0216

Everything is possible as long as BD backs it. Without BD's backing nobody can do nothing.
Only today our PM called ARSA a terrorist organization. Yesterday our food minister gone to Myanmar to buy rice. You think anybody on earth will take BD seriously and will believe what Rohingyas or BDians are saying? We are the biggest joke of a race on the face of earth.
 
Frankly speaking iam not seeing any good future either for rohingya as whole world is blind for their own interest rather then humanity. Only way we can safe them maybe given 1.3 million rohingya citizenship by different Muslim majority countries and other European countries if they interested. Any negotiation regarding returning them back is worthless as it happened earlier without stopping the state sponsored oppression.
On top of everything BD needs to bolster her own defense. But, the problem is China is also a part of the equation here. So, they need to go beyond that. Now, the importance of having indigenous military industrial complex is felt!! Hopefully, Turkey and other Muslim countries can come up with some urgent solutions!!!! But as @TopCat has rightly observed, BD herself needs to come forward!!!!!
 

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom