What's new

British Company sold Fake Bomb Detectors to Pakistan.

Kompromat

ADMINISTRATOR
Joined
May 3, 2009
Messages
40,366
Reaction score
416
Country
Pakistan
Location
Australia
Fake bomb detectors sold to Pakistan


Murtaza Ali Shah
Thursday, April 25, 2013


4-25-2013_22461_l_T.jpg




LONDON: Serious questions have risen after a British millionaire was convicted here for selling fake bomb detectors to many countries, including Pakistan.

Thousands of Pakistani victims targeted by bombers and blasts could still have been alive if these detectors were not fake and had worked effectively. James McCormick, 56, was found guilty of three counts of fraud at London’s Old Bailey for selling completely ineffective devices based on an American novelty golf ball finder. McCormick made an estimated £50 million from sales of his three models to customers that included Iraq, Belgium, the United Nations, Pakistan, Yemen, Georgia, Niger, and several other countries.

“The devices did not work and he knew they did not work,” prosecutor Richard Whittam told jurors. Each device was sold for £27,000. Bomb detectors are used widely in Pakistan by private and state security forces but public and private agencies will have to buy new and authentic equipment.

“And despite the fact they did not work, people bought them for a handsome but unwarranted profit.” McCormick has been bailed until his sentencing on May 2. The businessman, who is from Langport in Somerset, southwest England, is believed to have made around £37 million from sales to Iraq alone, while other customers included Georgia and Niger.

A source has told The News that the crooked businessman is believed to have sold fake equipment worth millions to Pakistan as well in the last 10 years. When contacted by The News, Pakistani security officials sought more time to find details about the nature of the equipment bought by Pakistan. It will be interesting to see whether the fake bomb detectors were bought by Pakistan’s armed forces or the police services and who facilitated this deal.

This high-profile case with serious ramifications for Pakistan has almost gone unnoticed in Pakistan but questions arise about those who will be found involved in this deal, definitely lining their own pockets. But more importantly, there is an issue of the lives lost in Pakistan.

More than 40,000 Pakistanis have lost their lives since the start of the so-called ‘war on terror’ and since the start of this war, Pakistan has been buying equipment from western countries and these countries have been giving weapons to Pakistan also. Several Pakistanis may have lost their lives due to these ineffectual detectors, used by security forces at check points and elsewhere. Many of the suicide bombings and bomb attacks could have been stopped if these detectors were effective and working but after the trial in London and the expose of the businessman’s fraud it is becoming certain that his company has the blood of Pakistanis on his hands. McCormick stressed during court proceedings that he mainly sold equipment to military establishments but he didn’t say whether he had sold this equipment directly to Pakistan military or through civilian government, if in the last five years.

It has been said that the British government officials advised the conman on how to market his products to the conflict ridden countries. McCormick was able to persuade governments and military chiefs that they could detect tiny traces of explosives, drugs, ivory and even humans at a distance of up to three miles.

British media has focused on how this fraud could have cost the lives of thousands of Iraqis but nothing has been mentioned about Pakistanis who have been killed and maimed in more than 10 years of the ‘war on terror’.

The Iraqi government spent £56 million on the fake bomb detectors, some of which was paid as bribes to senior figures. A spokesman at the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills denied any knowledge about McCormick’s business deal, including with Pakistan.

Fake bomb detectors sold to Pakistan - thenews.com.pk
 
Disgraceful. I hope they send them back ASAP and orders new, authentic, genuine ones.
 
The question is all those buyers, I am more concerned about Pakistan, had no procedure to check the effectiveness of such a critical device?
 
lol...selling is one thing but buying it without testing? epic....

No its not, if you ever lived in the subcontinent you would hear of something called commissions(aka bribes).

The question is all those buyers, I am more concerned about Pakistan, had no procedure to check the effectiveness of such a critical device?

How about we call an apple an apple. We have all the capabilities to TEST these devices, it's just that such tests are ignored on the whims of certain people.. an eg may be the sub standard ECM systems fitted to Mirages in the 80's or the procurement of USELESS equipment within so-called "crucial missile and bumb developing" institutions for ten times its worth on the invoice.

And you a think a Bomb detector is a thing to worry about when your sensitive installations and weapons too have fallen prey to corrupt people & procedures.
This is why good people either leave those organizations or simply resign to the system and join the club..and this is why you are ten.. nay twenty times behind where you really should be.
 
you can't test every singe equipment.
its really easy to pull of this scam.
You give a few working models for testing and then when the order comes you pack in the fake ones.
Does not take a rocket scientists to do it.
 
No its not, if you ever lived in the subcontinent you would hear of something called commissions(aka bribes).



How about we call an apple an apple. We have all the capabilities to TEST these devices, it's just that such tests are ignored on the whims of certain people.. an eg may be the sub standard ECM systems fitted to Mirages in the 80's or the procurement of USELESS equipment within so-called "crucial missile and bumb developing" institutions for ten times its worth on the invoice.

And you a think a Bomb detector is a thing to worry about when your sensitive installations and weapons too have fallen prey to corrupt people & procedures.
This is why good people either leave those organizations or simply resign to the system and join the club..and this is why you are ten.. nay twenty times behind where you really should be.

Actually, I lived all my life in subcontinent, so I am completely aware of bribe scenario. But no body will purchase completely useless systems knowing that these will be used for their own security. IMHO, they just went for marketing gimmick and the "gora" factor.. makes you wonder what other systems went through "same" purchasing track....

you can't test every singe equipment.
its really easy to pull of this scam.
You give a few working models for testing and then when the order comes you pack in the fake ones.
Does not take a rocket scientists to do it.

Not so, there will always be batch testing. Also, these devices NEVER worked, and there is no device on earth work to match the spec of these devices. So it is pretty clear that who ever bought these, never tested hem even once.....
 
you can't test every singe equipment.
its really easy to pull of this scam.
You give a few working models for testing and then when the order comes you pack in the fake ones.
Does not take a rocket scientists to do it.

There is something called random inspection or sampling which is done after the actual shipment is received and if you find more than a certain number of defective units among a certain product you can return everything back and claim damages unless if the agreement signed states on the contrary.
 
Please tell me this isn't the "dowsing rod" sold to Iraq too. But they will "work" in a sense. The guards with them feel more confident.....and as they have a "detector", will look more closely. Sometimes faith in equipment, no matter how misplaced, is an advantage. (ps....read farther....it is the Iraqi dowsing rod....wouldn't even find golf balls)
 
Not so, there will always be batch testing. Also, these devices NEVER worked, and there is no device on earth work to match the spec of these devices. So it is pretty clear that who ever bought these, never tested hem even once.....

Testing what? according to the article, it wasn't a bomb detector to begin with - its a golf ball finder. It might find use in Golf clubs.:)
 
Testing what? according to the article, it wasn't a bomb detector to begin with - its a golf ball finder. It might find use in Golf clubs.:)
Like when the buyer buys, say, 1000 of these believing it to be working, he will randomly take 20 instrument and try to detect bombs under various conditions that the device manufacturer claims that it works (hidden in vehicle for example). This will give positive set. Also some control items (say, vehicles without bombs) are tested which the device should not flag. Since it is better to be on cautious side, hence if there are more false negatives (device failing to detect the bombs) then all devices are returned. Apparantly, manufacturer did this and found out these won't work but kept on selling and some bakras kept on buying...

Please tell me this isn't the "dowsing rod" sold to Iraq too. But they will "work" in a sense. The guards with them feel more confident.....and as they have a "detector", will look more closely. Sometimes faith in equipment, no matter how misplaced, is an advantage. (ps....read farther....it is the Iraqi dowsing rod....wouldn't even find golf balls)

I don't think these are called that but were sold to Iraq too. These give a false sense of security. Imagine insurgents already knowing these won't work and as a result check posts were totally ineffective. Also, no need to pay these exorbitant price for false sense of security...
 
Like when the buyer buys, say, 1000 of these believing it to be working, he will randomly take 20 instrument and try to detect bombs under various conditions that the device manufacturer claims that it works (hidden in vehicle for example). This will give positive set. Also some control items (say, vehicles without bombs) are tested which the device should not flag. Since it is better to be on cautious side, hence if there are more false negatives (device failing to detect the bombs) then all devices are returned. Apparantly, manufacturer did this and found out these won't work but kept on selling and some bakras kept on buying...
.

They got conned plain and simple - it's not a bomb detector - it's a golf ball finder.
 
Like when the buyer buys, say, 1000 of these believing it to be working, he will randomly take 20 instrument and try to detect bombs under various conditions that the device manufacturer claims that it works (hidden in vehicle for example). This will give positive set. Also some control items (say, vehicles without bombs) are tested which the device should not flag. Since it is better to be on cautious side, hence if there are more false negatives (device failing to detect the bombs) then all devices are returned. Apparantly, manufacturer did this and found out these won't work but kept on selling and some bakras kept on buying...



I don't think these are called that but were sold to Iraq too. These give a false sense of security. Imagine insurgents already knowing these won't work and as a result check posts were totally ineffective. Also, no need to pay these exorbitant price for false sense of security...
Not the real name, but dowsing rods are forked sticks to find water. These were given that name derisively. Same as what I meant. Again....even the circuit board was glued on.....not even a golf ball finder....total fakes.
 
This millionaire should be hanged, his fake bomb detectors have taken thousands of lives.
 
They got conned plain and simple - it's not a bomb detector - it's a golf ball finder.
yes, but the question we are discussing is that why did they not find out? if somebody sells you a dog painted with stripes as tiger, you may get conned during purchase, but the moment you take it home you will notice....
 
Back
Top Bottom