What's new

Bangladesh PM Sheikh Hasina May Be Pro-China, But She Is Not Anti-India – Expert Analysis

Black_cats

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 31, 2010
Messages
10,031
Reaction score
-5
FEATURED
Bangladesh PM Sheikh Hasina May Be Pro-China, But She Is Not Anti-India – Expert Analysis

Despite China’s growing investment in Bangladesh, India finds a responsive leader in Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina who does not play a China-card against New Delhi

Published
2 days ago
on
December 31, 2020
By
Prakash Nanda

With China completing a 6.15-km long bridge on the Padma River, Bangladesh’s largest-ever infrastructure endeavor, India has decided to leave no stone unturned in keeping


On December 17, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his Bangladeshi counterpart Sheikh Hasina jointly inaugurated a railway link between Haldibari in India and Chilahati in Bangladesh during a virtual bilateral summit. With this rail link, the total number of railway lines between the two countries has increased to five. India has revived all these five rail links that used to be operational between India and Bangladesh before 1965.

In fact, seven railway lines were operational between the two until 1965. Now, with the Haldibari-Chilahati rail link, five are actively operational, including Petrapole-Benapole, Gede-Darshana, Singhabad-Rohanpur, and Radhikapur -Birol.

Work is ongoing on two more connections. The sixth pre-1965 rail link (Kulaura-Shahbazpur), work on which is underway, will revive the railway connectivity between Karimganj in Assam and Sylhet in Bangladesh.

A railway that links Akhaura in Bangladesh to Agartala is under construction and will be ready by 2022 when India will commemorate the 75th anniversary of its independence. Passenger trains such as Maitree and Bandhan Express already link India and Bangladesh.


China is developing a mega smart city near Dhaka, building an airport in Sylhet in eastern Bangladesh, and developing a defense relationship with Bangladesh. But still, in Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, India finds a responsive leader who does not play a China-card against New Delhi. In fact, she displayed a nice gesture to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi on December 30, that too at a time when the Modi government is beset with agricultural issues with a powerful section of the protesting farmers.

That gesture on the eve of the New Year was its decision to reduce import duty on Indian rice exports to 25% from 62.5%. This will pave the way for Indian rice exporters to export non-basmati rice to the country and fetch better prices for the grain. Bangladesh is expected to import about 500,000 tons of non-basmati rice in this financial year.



Already two Indian companies have bagged contracts for 100,000 tons of rice exports to Bangladesh. The Bangladesh government is now in talks with NAFED (National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation of India) to import another 250,000 tons of rice under a government-to-government trade initiative. The rest of 150,000 tons will be exported to the country by private parties.

Modi and Hasina maintain bonhomie despite China’s increased developmental activities in Bangladesh and despite the controversial political decision of the Modi government to legislate the Citizenship Amendment Act that projected Bangladesh as much as Pakistan to be countries where religious minorities have been persecuted.

Modi is scheduled to visit Bangladesh in March 2021 to join the golden jubilee celebration of Bangladesh’s independence in March 2021.

Modi and Hasina have helped each other politically over the last six years. It was Modi who agreed to solve the knotty territorial issues with Bangladesh by means of the 2015 Land Boundary Agreement (LBA) and the exchange of enclaves (chhitmahals) and adverse possessions between the two countries.

Modi also accepted a United Nations court-directed decision that awarded more than three-quarters of a disputed area to Bangladesh and opened the way for it for more energy exploration in the sea.

On her part, Hasina has solidly backed Indian requests to end aiding and abetting the anti-India elements, including the secessionist organizations in India’s Northeast, on Bangladesh soil. Even on the controversial citizenship laws, her government has described them to be India’s internal matters.

Thanks to concerns over the Chinese inroads into the region, Bangladesh figures prominently in Modi’s Act East policy in general and ‘Neighbourhood First’ policy in particular. And in this, the Modi government’s vision is said to be captured in, what external affairs minister S. Jaishankar says, “the 3 Cs – Connectivity, Commerce, and Cultural Commonalities.”

At another level, India is also working through multilateral initiatives such as BIMSTEC and BBIN or the Bangladesh-Bhutan-India-Nepal grouping.


Apart from the rail links, the two countries are getting “reconnected” (disruption was due to the partition of India in 1947) through rivers and seas. Goods from West Bengal can now reach Tripura through waterways up to Ashuganj port in Bangladesh and further by road up to Agartala. According to Jaishankar, recently, a goods consignment was also moved from Kolkata to Agartala under the India-Bangladesh agreement on the use of Chittagong port for transporting goods to and from Northeast India.

For the first time, Tripura was connected to Bangladesh through the inland waterways route. “This new route can further connect Tripura with the National Waterways of India. These new initiatives provide alternative and shorter routes for transporting goods between the North East and the rest of India through Bangladesh”, the Indian foreign minister said.

Road transportation links are also being improved. Indian and Bangladesh nationals can move by bus between Shillong and Dhaka and between Agartala and Kolkata via Dhaka. Goods and people move by road between the two countries through a network of Land Customs Stations and Integrated Check Posts.

Besides, India and Bangladesh are working on building an India-Bangladesh Friendship Pipeline. Hydrocarbons from refineries in Assam can flow through this pipeline into Bangladesh. LPG now reaches Tripura through Bangladesh entailing lower transportation costs.

India realizes that Bangladesh is a rapidly growing economy with a population of 160 million. It is a large and growing market for Indian products and services. It will certainly not like such an economy to be dominated by China, Chinese projects, and Chinese goods.

 
.
Hasina does not want to be pro-China or anti-India, but she has no choice in either matter. Only China with its economic heft and military sales can provide some leverage to Hasina against Modi's India. This is an India which is determined to eradicate Islam internally and at the same time demand "secularism" within its Muslim neighbors. This is what India has stated to Pakistan as a condition for improving relations. It is fully expected that India will demand the same "secularism" from Bangladesh, which is code for full respect for Hinduism and disrepect (or at least ignorance) of Islam in the public sphere.

Unlike Pakistan with its nuclear umbrella and long-fortified border, Bangladesh is less able to resist Indian pressure. Hence the need for a new partner like China.
 
.
Hasina does not want to be pro-China or anti-India, but she has no choice in either matter. Only China with its economic heft and military sales can provide some leverage to Hasina against Modi's India. This is an India which is determined to eradicate Islam internally and at the same time demand "secularism" within its Muslim neighbors. This is what India has stated to Pakistan as a condition for improving relations. It is fully expected that India will demand the same "secularism" from Bangladesh, which is code for full respect for Hinduism and disrepect (or at least ignorance) of Islam in the public sphere.

Unlike Pakistan with its nuclear umbrella and long-fortified border, Bangladesh is less able to resist Indian pressure. Hence the need for a new partner like China.


Dismal Bangladesh becomes a transit highway and dumping ground for Indian goods. Ruining our industries.
 
.
Hasina does not want to be pro-China or anti-India, but she has no choice in either matter. Only China with its economic heft and military sales can provide some leverage to Hasina against Modi's India. This is an India which is determined to eradicate Islam internally and at the same time demand "secularism" within its Muslim neighbors. This is what India has stated to Pakistan as a condition for improving relations. It is fully expected that India will demand the same "secularism" from Bangladesh, which is code for full respect for Hinduism and disrepect (or at least ignorance) of Islam in the public sphere.

Unlike Pakistan with its nuclear umbrella and long-fortified border, Bangladesh is less able to resist Indian pressure. Hence the need for a new partner like China.

It is not as it may seem. Bangladesh is diplomatically doing great. There is no reason to show hostility if there is no open war. China just provides better economy trade for Bangladesh benefits. Other then being neighbours and trading partners they don't have much in common with India. No one has the right to demand anything of Bangladesh and it pursues it's own political and economical adventures and it is well run government
Bangladesh is India's superior*

Bitc? That is why Bangladesh is not part of India it separated itself because it had the power and it could and had the means to separate itself from the garbage called India. Tamil Nadu is India's bitch and the other regions it absorbed with force but not this Bangladesh it is a sovereign an proud nation. It has also better economy then India and is progressing faster then India. Bangladesh can only be superior to India not the other way around
 
Last edited:
. .
Hasina is actually anti India , so her father Mujib was! Just either win her next election or retire after this term , she will show her tooth and nail to India , I believe!
 
.
Hasina is actually anti India , so her father Mujib was! Just either win her next election or retire after this term , she will show her tooth and nail to India , I believe!
Bangladesh can only be anti Myanmar..
 
.
Bangladesh can only be anti Myanmar..

@-blitzkrieg- ,
Independent homeland for Muslim is a Bengali concept , and west Pakistan completely opposed it . Yet you guys pretend to be the enemy of India . Muslim league was founded In Dhaka by the Nawab Family of Dhaka! And now Where is the family of Jinnah? Also what was the position of your soul mate Jamati Islami during partition of India in 1947 ?

Look at this screenshot's red mark and hide your face with shame, because your ancestors let you down ! Indeed Bangladesh will emerge as India's arch enemy . India Pakistan enmity is actually artificial. Yes it was real when Pakistan was united , and basically for East Pakistan, and without East Pakistan , there was no enmity between India and Pakistan! that is now Bangladesh. And we do not count Myanmar , as they are less than dogs!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1937_Indian_provincial_elections

11.jpg
 
Last edited:
.
Bangladesh is India's bitc*
It's tempting to think that way.

But Bangladesh has done more for Islam in India than Pakistan. Not through some deliberate act or saazish but simple migration. It has successfully brought the Muslim population in Assam and West Bengal close to parity with Hindus population.
 
.
It's tempting to think that way.

But Bangladesh has done more for Islam in India than Pakistan. Not through some deliberate act or saazish but simple migration. It has successfully brought the Muslim population in Assam and West Bengal close to parity with Hindus population.

Did not know RSS koolaid is also drunk by Pakistanis.
There are hardly any Bangladeshi Muslim migrants in India. India has failed to produce any evidence of mass Muslim migration from Bangladesh. Increase in Muslim population in India is purely due to poor family planning of Indian Muslims, just like the rest of the Muslim world.
 
.
Did not know RSS koolaid is also drunk by Pakistanis.
There are hardly any Bangladeshi Muslim migrants in India. India has failed to produce any evidence of mass Muslim migration from Bangladesh. Increase in Muslim population in India is purely due to poor family planning of Indian Muslims, just like the rest of the Muslim world.
West Bengal's Muslim population was 19% in 1947 but it's now 28%. Assam's Muslim population was also 25% in 1947 but it's 35% now. No other state of India has shown such a drastic increase in Muslim population as a total percentage.
 
.
West Bengal's Muslim population was 19% in 1947 but it's now 28%. Assam's Muslim population was also 25% in 1947 but it's 35% now. No other state of India has shown such a drastic increase in Muslim population as a total percentage.
Poor family planning and internal migration. It makes no economic sense for a Bangladeshi Muslim to migrate to WB and Assam. No evidence of mass Bangladeshi Muslim migration produced.
 
.
Poor family planning and internal migration. It makes no economic sense for a Bangladeshi Muslim to migrate to WB and Assam. No evidence of mass Bangladeshi Muslim migration produced.
Well, UP and Bihari Muslims are even poorer and their population has only increased by 2 or 3% percentage points.

There is no explanation for the 10% percentage jump in WB and Assam.
 
.
Well, UP and Bihari Muslims are even poorer and their population has only increased by 2 or 3% percentage points.

There is no explanation for the 10% percentage jump in WB and Assam.


It somewhere in this section, which explains it very well. The Muslims birth rate was much higher than hindu birth rate in West bengal and assam. Also ever where else in India. You into consideration of the compound growth rate, and its about right.

No Bangladeshi would wanna go to assam or west bengal. West bengal begs us for tourism dollars and takas.
 
.
Well, UP and Bihari Muslims are even poorer and their population has only increased by 2 or 3% percentage points.

There is no explanation for the 10% percentage jump in WB and Assam.
What part of high birth rate do you not understand? Do you think Muslims in WB and Assam coordinate birth rates with those in UP and Bihar?
 
Last edited:
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom