What's new

Arakan Army keen for stronger ties with Bangladesh

F-6 enthusiast

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Feb 27, 2021
Messages
1,433
Reaction score
0
Country
Bangladesh
Location
United Kingdom
Arakan Army keen for stronger ties with Bangladesh
'In regard to Bangladesh’s authorities, it’s (the relation) not that bad, but not yet so good either,' said Major General Tun Myat Naing


File photo: Tun Myat Naing, commander-in-chief of the Arakan Army, in Shan State on May 6, 2015 <strong>Reuters</strong>

File photo: Tun Myat Naing, commander-in-chief of the Arakan Army, in Shan State on May 6, 2015 Reuters
Tribune Desk
January 19, 2022 4:59 PM
The chief of Myanmar’s armed rebel group the Arakan Army (AA) has said that their relation with Bangladesh needs to be improved despite it being so-so.
Major General Tun Myat Naing said: “In regard to Bangladesh’s authorities, it’s (the relation) not that bad, but not yet so good either. We haven’t noticed that the Bangladesh government has a clear policy or strategy for a formal or informal relationship with us yet.”
Talking to the Asia Times recently, he hoped: “It (the relation with Bangladesh) should be improved though; they (Bangladesh authorities) should take a step forward and do so proactively.
ADVERTISEMENT

A better relationship, Naing stated, would be mutually beneficial for both the rebel group and Bangladesh government, and, more importantly, in coping with the refugees, aid delivery, the pandemic and security issues.
“In order to better serve the interests of the people on both sides, the relationship could also be extended to include health care, education, trade and commerce and other sectors,” he opined.
Talking on the situation in the Rakhine state, where the group and Myanmar military agreed an informal ceasefire agreement soon after the November 2020 election, he said the truce was so stable.
ADVERTISEMENT

“We have been at daggers drawn. It’s uncertain how long the ceasefire will last, but we wish to have a meaningful ceasefire for mutual benefit and interests,” said observed the 43-year-old rebel commander.
‘Aiming to stay together’
Asked if an independent Rakhine is their final goal or they want it to be an autonomy within a federal union, he said: “The right to self-determination and sovereignty is at the heart of our national movements.
“We will see whether a Federal Union of Myanmar will have the political space for the kind of confederation that our Arakanese people aspire for.”
The rebel group, he said, aims to remain with ethnic people.
“But if our rightful political status which we desire is not accommodated within this union, it would behoove us to be a member of the international community on our own,” he added.
No Rohingya return now?
He recently told a Bangla daily that they recognize the human rights and citizenship rights of Rohingyas.
Replying to a question whether he now wanted their repatriation from Bangladesh, he reiterating the recognition for all residents of Rakhine state.
ADVERTISEMENT

But a massive repatriation of refugees in the current situation could unleash a new wave of unrest, he feared, suggesting: “Any repatriation would have to be voluntary and be done by legal means under international supervision.”
China, Japan can be gamechangers
Regarding the potential efforts that China and Japan can make for a peaceful solution to the conflict in Rakhine and the rest of Myanmar, he finds the countries crucial.
“In theory, they can play a vital role but reality is more complex. Changes have to come from within, and that would sound more probable and realistic to me. But the odds are still unclear.
‘Rohingya an offensive term’
A major issue for most Arakanese would also be the name with which the refugees would want to be identified, according to him.
“Rohingya is not a term that most Arakanese accept. They find it offensive as they feel that it deprives them of their history. They are the original inhabitants of the land,” he said.
The AA chief is confident about Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus and Christians being able to live together peacefully in the state.
But he thinks it is only achievable when no outsiders manipulate them and use one group against another.
ARSA at fault in Cox’s Bazar camps?
Comparing between the Rohingya Solidarity Organization (RSO) and the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), he said the latter is politically less mature.
“… You can see what ARSA has been doing against their own community leaders at the villages inside Rakhine and at refugee camps in Bangladesh. Some educated Muslims in the diaspora are irresponsibly manipulating ARSA and exploiting the troubled political environment,” he said.

Arakan Army keen for stronger ties with Bangladesh (dhakatribune.com)
 
.
Arakan Army keen for stronger ties with Bangladesh
'In regard to Bangladesh’s authorities, it’s (the relation) not that bad, but not yet so good either,' said Major General Tun Myat Naing


File photo: Tun Myat Naing, commander-in-chief of the Arakan Army, in Shan State on May 6, 2015 <strong>Reuters</strong>

File photo: Tun Myat Naing, commander-in-chief of the Arakan Army, in Shan State on May 6, 2015 Reuters
Tribune Desk
January 19, 2022 4:59 PM
The chief of Myanmar’s armed rebel group the Arakan Army (AA) has said that their relation with Bangladesh needs to be improved despite it being so-so.
Major General Tun Myat Naing said: “In regard to Bangladesh’s authorities, it’s (the relation) not that bad, but not yet so good either. We haven’t noticed that the Bangladesh government has a clear policy or strategy for a formal or informal relationship with us yet.”
Talking to the Asia Times recently, he hoped: “It (the relation with Bangladesh) should be improved though; they (Bangladesh authorities) should take a step forward and do so proactively.
ADVERTISEMENT

A better relationship, Naing stated, would be mutually beneficial for both the rebel group and Bangladesh government, and, more importantly, in coping with the refugees, aid delivery, the pandemic and security issues.
“In order to better serve the interests of the people on both sides, the relationship could also be extended to include health care, education, trade and commerce and other sectors,” he opined.
Talking on the situation in the Rakhine state, where the group and Myanmar military agreed an informal ceasefire agreement soon after the November 2020 election, he said the truce was so stable.
ADVERTISEMENT

“We have been at daggers drawn. It’s uncertain how long the ceasefire will last, but we wish to have a meaningful ceasefire for mutual benefit and interests,” said observed the 43-year-old rebel commander.
‘Aiming to stay together’
Asked if an independent Rakhine is their final goal or they want it to be an autonomy within a federal union, he said: “The right to self-determination and sovereignty is at the heart of our national movements.
“We will see whether a Federal Union of Myanmar will have the political space for the kind of confederation that our Arakanese people aspire for.”
The rebel group, he said, aims to remain with ethnic people.
“But if our rightful political status which we desire is not accommodated within this union, it would behoove us to be a member of the international community on our own,” he added.
No Rohingya return now?
He recently told a Bangla daily that they recognize the human rights and citizenship rights of Rohingyas.
Replying to a question whether he now wanted their repatriation from Bangladesh, he reiterating the recognition for all residents of Rakhine state.
ADVERTISEMENT

But a massive repatriation of refugees in the current situation could unleash a new wave of unrest, he feared, suggesting: “Any repatriation would have to be voluntary and be done by legal means under international supervision.”
China, Japan can be gamechangers
Regarding the potential efforts that China and Japan can make for a peaceful solution to the conflict in Rakhine and the rest of Myanmar, he finds the countries crucial.
“In theory, they can play a vital role but reality is more complex. Changes have to come from within, and that would sound more probable and realistic to me. But the odds are still unclear.
‘Rohingya an offensive term’
A major issue for most Arakanese would also be the name with which the refugees would want to be identified, according to him.
“Rohingya is not a term that most Arakanese accept. They find it offensive as they feel that it deprives them of their history. They are the original inhabitants of the land,” he said.
The AA chief is confident about Muslims, Buddhists, Hindus and Christians being able to live together peacefully in the state.
But he thinks it is only achievable when no outsiders manipulate them and use one group against another.
ARSA at fault in Cox’s Bazar camps?
Comparing between the Rohingya Solidarity Organization (RSO) and the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), he said the latter is politically less mature.
“… You can see what ARSA has been doing against their own community leaders at the villages inside Rakhine and at refugee camps in Bangladesh. Some educated Muslims in the diaspora are irresponsibly manipulating ARSA and exploiting the troubled political environment,” he said.

Arakan Army keen for stronger ties with Bangladesh (dhakatribune.com)

These fault-lines in Myanmar need to be exploited, but covertly...

I am sure our govt. is doing what needs to be done...

However Arakan Army will always push for ethnic Rakhine majoritarianism in Arakan and will sideline Rohingyas.

Rohingyas have serious dearth of educated leadership and don't have any stellar one person leaders yet. Mostly uneducated folks lacking organized representation.

An independent Arakan (and eventual balkanization of Myanmar), and drastic reduction of Bamar influence in Arakan are all in Bangladesh' best interest.

Chips have to fall into the right places but not yet...
 
Last edited:
.
These fault-lines in Myanmar need to be exploited, but covertly...

I am sure our govt. is doing what needs to be done...

However Arakan Army will always push for ethnic Rakhine majoritarianism in Arakan and will sideline Rohingyas.

Rohingyas have serious dearth of educated leadership and don't have any stellar one person leaders yet. Mostly uneducated folks lacking organized representation.

An independent Arakan (and eventual balkanization of Myanmar), and drastic reduction of Bamar influence in Arakan are all in Bangladesh' best interest.

Chips have to fall into the right places but not yet...

Burma is such a huge, and sparsely populated country...
 
.
An independent Arakan (and eventual balkanization of Myanmar), and drastic reduction of Bamar influence in Arakan are all in Bangladesh' best interest.

I would prefer a border with an independent Arakan over one with Burma any day, regardless of how it affects Rohingyas.

A weak, tiny (potentially) unreasonable entity is easier to deal.
 
.
Burma is such a huge, and sparsely populated country...

It is too big. Bamars are incapable IMHO to rule the whole area by themselves and I predict the fault lines among ethnicities (in absence of any unifying force or philosophy) will get stronger by the day and lead to balkanization eventually. Right now Bangladesh does not IMHO want to be involved in any of that process. It will happen naturally regardless.

Arakan itself has physical and natural barriers from the rest of Myanmar. Defence wise also this is the case, presenting natural terrain barriers (easily exploitable) non-conducive to troop movements. I am sure some of the more knowledgeable Bangladeshi brothers adept at defence strategy will chime in on this and yes - I could be wrong on some counts.

Ultimately - we have to look at not only peaceful repatriation of Rohingya to Arakan who are rightfully Myanmarese citizens and Arakan residents - but, also a prosperous (and possibly independent) Arakan at our borders as buffer state - as a raw material hinterland to Bangladeshi economy (just like the Indian North East) and build/help-build the following at Thilawa Port,

1. A facility for LNG Re-Gasification from ocean vessels and pipeline transport of Natural gas to Kunming area past Chinese border
2. A thriving container and bulk cargo handling facility for use by the rest of Myanmar.
3. Development of a local SEZ and ensuing employment for a Rohingya and Rakhine workforce, ensuring a prosperous future
4. A marine fishery hub,
5. And hopefully also development of tourist infra, which Bangladesh can initiate and invest in (as it has done in nearby Cox's Bazaar.
 
Last edited:
.
Chips have to fall into the right places but not yet...
all in good time, notice how he says ''stronger'' meaning there is some contact (although gov will not admit). This is the remnant of the Ershad policies.
Any kind of co-op with them or other rebel groups should be limited to intelligence sharing at this point.(we don't know their true ambitions) If the Burmese dont want to play ball then chaos it is...

amader ''bondhu rasthro'' rakhine rajje ekti shomudro bondor banachhe. Amra AA ke support dile ei porikolpona oder poschat deshe bhore dibe. BD needs to adopt some machiavellian policies


I would prefer a border with an independent Arakan over one with Burma any day, regardless of how it affects Rohingyas.

A weak, tiny (potentially) unreasonable entity is easier to deal.
i agree with you , however wouldn't this cause instability in the neighbourhood (see Afghanistan war effects on Pakistan) ?
Some may argue that the damage is already done (Rohingya crisis).
 
Last edited:
.
These fault-lines in Myanmar need to be exploited, but covertly...

I am sure our govt. is doing what needs to be done...

However Arakan Army will always push for ethnic Rakhine majoritarianism in Arakan and will sideline Rohingyas.

Rohingyas have serious dearth of educated leadership and don't have any stellar one person leaders yet. Mostly uneducated folks lacking organized representation.

An independent Arakan (and eventual balkanization of Myanmar), and drastic reduction of Bamar influence in Arakan are all in Bangladesh' best interest.

Chips have to fall into the right places but not yet...
Burma is Jugoslavia 2.0
 
.
Guys, note two points. The Burmese Junta has sent a letter wishing to solve the Rohingya issue. On the other hand, there is a large Arakan Army (Buddhists) who are fighting the Junta troops.

One social media guy was claiming that there are 8,000 AA troops inside BD and they each receive Tk8,000 per month to meet their living expenses. He cited the name of the place where they are staying but I forgot the name.
 
.
I would not wish to deal with these nutters unless they recognise rohingya and their history and even then with extreme suspicion.

They are under pressure hence the outreach. BD should maintain status quo nothing more. BD should however train and raise a rohingya force to be unleashed at a time of our choosing. BD must acquire the military power to impose a positive solution first.

If AA has any presence in BD these should be expelled or liquidated with extreme prejudice.
 
. .
amader ''bondhu rasthro'' rakhine rajje ekti shomudro bondor banachhe. Amra AA ke support dile ei porikolpona oder poschat deshe bhore dibe. BD needs to adopt some machiavellian policies

Right - Dadara ekta bondor bananer taley chhilo thik-e tobey beshidur agaitey pare nai. Eminiteo shalara dheela, are dui nombor kotha poishar-o ovab.

Tobey ha, AA ke aula laganer kajey bhalo babohar korano jaitey parey.
i agree with you , however wouldn't this cause instability in the neighbourhood (see Afghanistan war effects on Pakistan) ?
Some may argue that the damage is already done (Rohingya crisis).

Aula ekta lagley amader dikey ganjam ashbey kina bhaiba dekhtey hobey.

Shesh brittanto jodi shadhin desh hoi oikhaney, tobey ektu risk to nitei hobey.

Shesh kotha hoilo amader uddessho ta ki. End justifies the means.
 
.
i agree with you , however wouldn't this cause instability in the neighbourhood (see Afghanistan war effects on Pakistan) ?
Some may argue that the damage is already done (Rohingya crisis).

Burma is no Afghanistan and we are no Pakistan. Afghan problems affect Pakistan because the people on both sides of the border are same (Pashtuns).

Instability inside Burma is good. Let it break into thousand pieces. The piece next to us will be simpler to deal with.
 
.
Shesh kotha hoilo amader uddessho ta ki. End justifies the means.
Ultimately - we have to look at not only peaceful repatriation of Rohingya to Arakan who are rightfully Myanmarese citizens and Arakan residents
we know it needs to be done, but how ?

Eminiteo shalara dheela, are dui nombor kotha poishar-o ovab.
poishar obhab kintu tader উচ্চাকাঙ্ক্ষা ase (maybe too much )
they want to supply the NE via sea route . off topic but what happened to that port ? completed ? stalled ?
 
.
Sandal clad lungiwala with a rag tag army demanding concessions from a country of almost 170 million, the audacity 😂
 
.
Back
Top Bottom