What's new

Another warship accident hits the Navy - Rajat Pandit TOI

nik22

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Aug 17, 2013
Messages
930
Reaction score
-1
Country
India
Location
India
How common is it for ships to run aground? Is it because India has shallow waters? in A&N too?
Writer is certainly trying to make it a major thing. I put "Rajat Pandit" in title so people know what to expect.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NEW DELHI: In yet another warship accident, missile corvette INS Khutar was damaged after it recently ran aground at the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. The Navy has ordered a board of inquiry (BoI) into the accident, which is the 15th such incident after submarine INS Sindhurakshak sank in August 14 last year.

The 1,350-tonne Khutar, which was commissioned in 1990, was entering the harbour to dock at one of the two jetties at Port Blair when it ran aground in "rough weather" towards end-June. "The propeller of the corvette was damaged ... it will undergo repairs at Vizag," said an officer.

Though INS Khutar is part of the Eastern Naval Command, the Khukri-class corvette was on a long-range patrol in the Bay of Bengal. The BoI is being headed by a captain from the A&N tri-service command.


38329612.cms

File photo of INS Sindhurakshak.


It was the string of accidents, especially the two serious ones on board submarines INS Sindhurakshak and INS Sindhuratna that killed five officers and 15 sailors, which led Admiral D K Joshi to "own moral responsibility" and resign as the Navy chief on February 26.

The then UPA government had appointed Admiral Robin Dhowan as the chief after a gap of 50 days, superseding the then Western Naval Command chief Vice Admiral Shekhar Sinha, who then had also put in his papers. The politico-bureaucratic combine itself, however, cannot escape responsibility for ignoring the Navy's repeated warnings about its ageing submarines, all of them over 20 years old.

The Navy, on its part, stripped at least three warship captains from their command after the accidents. This included Captain Gopal Suri, who was removed after the Russian-origin stealth frigate INS Talwar rammed a fishing vessel off Ratnagiri on December 23. Four officers and two sailors of INS Talwar are facing a court-martial after being held guilty in the BoI.


38329645.cms

File photo of INS Sindhuratna.


The probes into the other cases are still in progress. The biggest accident was the sinking of Kilo-class submarine INS Sindhurakshak after a series of internal explosions at the Mumbai naval dockyard, killing three officers and 15 sailors on August 14. The wrecked submarine was recently fished out of water for forensic and other examination, which will help the BoI conclude its investigation.

"Lessons learnt from the Bols are being implemented. Corrective steps have been taken by naval headquarters with extensive checks on weapon related safety systems and audit of standard operating procedures on all operational naval units," defence minister Arun Jaitley told Parliament last week.

Another warship accident hits the Navy - The Times of India
 
.
How common is it for ships to run aground? Is it because India has shallow waters? in A&N too?
Writer is certainly trying to make it a major thing. I put "Rajat Pandit" in title so people know what to expect.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NEW DELHI: In yet another warship accident, missile corvette INS Khutar was damaged after it recently ran aground at the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. The Navy has ordered a board of inquiry (BoI) into the accident, which is the 15th such incident after submarine INS Sindhurakshak sank in August 14 last year.

The 1,350-tonne Khutar, which was commissioned in 1990, was entering the harbour to dock at one of the two jetties at Port Blair when it ran aground in "rough weather" towards end-June. "The propeller of the corvette was damaged ... it will undergo repairs at Vizag," said an officer.

Though INS Khutar is part of the Eastern Naval Command, the Khukri-class corvette was on a long-range patrol in the Bay of Bengal. The BoI is being headed by a captain from the A&N tri-service command.


38329612.cms

File photo of INS Sindhurakshak.


It was the string of accidents, especially the two serious ones on board submarines INS Sindhurakshak and INS Sindhuratna that killed five officers and 15 sailors, which led Admiral D K Joshi to "own moral responsibility" and resign as the Navy chief on February 26.

The then UPA government had appointed Admiral Robin Dhowan as the chief after a gap of 50 days, superseding the then Western Naval Command chief Vice Admiral Shekhar Sinha, who then had also put in his papers. The politico-bureaucratic combine itself, however, cannot escape responsibility for ignoring the Navy's repeated warnings about its ageing submarines, all of them over 20 years old.

The Navy, on its part, stripped at least three warship captains from their command after the accidents. This included Captain Gopal Suri, who was removed after the Russian-origin stealth frigate INS Talwar rammed a fishing vessel off Ratnagiri on December 23. Four officers and two sailors of INS Talwar are facing a court-martial after being held guilty in the BoI.


38329645.cms

File photo of INS Sindhuratna.


The probes into the other cases are still in progress. The biggest accident was the sinking of Kilo-class submarine INS Sindhurakshak after a series of internal explosions at the Mumbai naval dockyard, killing three officers and 15 sailors on August 14. The wrecked submarine was recently fished out of water for forensic and other examination, which will help the BoI conclude its investigation.

"Lessons learnt from the Bols are being implemented. Corrective steps have been taken by naval headquarters with extensive checks on weapon related safety systems and audit of standard operating procedures on all operational naval units," defence minister Arun Jaitley told Parliament last week.

Another warship accident hits the Navy - The Times of India



When proper planned expenditure and non-lapseable funds are not present for MRO, stocks and spares (specially for older vessels, for example a defined stocking of spares/rotables/replaceables system needs to be instituted for vessels of a certain vintage, in fact there have been officials who've presented proper data on the same, that ships must be categorized by their vintages and on the basis of that appropriate stores must be made available and kept at hand) and just plain and simple real estate (the IN has grown, its on-shore facilities have not been able to keep track at all, thank the good lord that at least Project Seabird is a go) are scarce and not provisioned for then accidents are bound to occur.

Add human error to the above, and it can quite often be human error, and sh!t can get VERY messed up.
 
. .
How common is it for ships to run aground? Is it because India has shallow waters? in A&N too?
Writer is certainly trying to make it a major thing. I put "Rajat Pandit" in title so people know what to expect.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NEW DELHI: In yet another warship accident, missile corvette INS Khutar was damaged after it recently ran aground at the Andaman and Nicobar Islands. The Navy has ordered a board of inquiry (BoI) into the accident, which is the 15th such incident after submarine INS Sindhurakshak sank in August 14 last year.

Lol. Coincidence or design?
 
.
How common is it for ships to run aground? Is it because India has shallow waters? in A&N too?
Writer is certainly trying to make it a major thing. I put "Rajat Pandit" in title so people know what to expect.

Running aground is not all that rare. Mostly it is due to human error and a common accident the world over, but
in some conditions, more so. Usually it does not cause any major damage...even the corvette INS Kamorta had
run aground during trials, damage was minor & it was fixed up within weeks.
 
.
Speechless。Lost for words。
 
. .
Back
Top Bottom