What's new

After 17 years of war, top US commander in Afghanistan admits Taliban cannot be defeated

RangeMaster

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Dec 25, 2016
Messages
1,647
Reaction score
1
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Published time: 2 Nov, 2018 10:33Edited time: 3 Nov, 2018 08:57
Get short URL
5bdc5f4edda4c88d5b8b45a6.jpg

© Global Look Press / Yaqoub Azorda
  • 6226
  • 9
The Afghanistan war cannot be won militarily and peace will only be achieved through a political resolution with the Taliban, the newly-appointed American general in charge of US and NATO operations has conceded.
In his first interview since taking command of NATO’s Resolute Support mission in September, Gen. Austin Scott Miller provided NBC News with a surprisingly candid assessment of the seemingly never-ending conflict, which began with the US invasion of Afghanistan in October, 2001.

“This is not going to be won militarily. This is going to a political solution," Miller said.

He mused that the Taliban is also tired of fighting and may be interested in starting to “work through the political piece” of the 17-year-old war.

via GIPHY

But it’s not clear if the Taliban is open to negotiations. Last month, a top Taliban commander told RT, in a rare interview, that the group’s leaders had no desire to negotiate with the Americans.




#Afghanistan is on its way to becoming America's longest war ever, and fewer and fewer Americans like it https://on.rt.com/9g84

9:21 AM - Oct 11, 2018

US veterans overwhelmingly want troops out of Afghanistan – poll — RT US News
A new poll shows a majority of US residents support withdrawing all troops from Afghanistan, 17 years into a war that shows no signs of ending. Support for winding down the interminable conflict is...


Described for years as a stalemate, the conflict has been tipping in the Taliban’s favor in recent months. Even by US military estimates, the Afghan government controls or influences just over half of the country’s 407 districts – a record low since the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction, or SIGAR, began tracking district control in November 2015.

To make matters worse, casualties among Afghan government forces have skyrocketed in recent months. Afghan security forces suffered 1,000 fatalities in August and September, according to the Pentagon.

READ MORE: US veterans overwhelmingly want troops out of Afghanistan – poll

Miller’s desire for a political settlement was echoed earlier by the State Department, which said in August that the US was doing everything it could to facilitate peace talks between the Taliban and the Afghan government.

The new US commander has experienced the deteriorating security situation in Afghanistan first-hand. In October, Miller survived a Taliban attack in Kandahar, which left a prominent Afghan warlord and local intelligence chief dead.
 
. . . . .
Published time: 2 Nov, 2018 10:33Edited time: 3 Nov, 2018 08:57
Get short URL
5bdc5f4edda4c88d5b8b45a6.jpg

© Global Look Press / Yaqoub Azorda
  • 6226
  • 9
The Afghanistan war cannot be won militarily and peace will only be achieved through a political resolution with the Taliban, the newly-appointed American general in charge of US and NATO operations has conceded.
In his first interview since taking command of NATO’s Resolute Support mission in September, Gen. Austin Scott Miller provided NBC News with a surprisingly candid assessment of the seemingly never-ending conflict, which began with the US invasion of Afghanistan in October, 2001.

“This is not going to be won militarily. This is going to a political solution," Miller said.

He mused that the Taliban is also tired of fighting and may be interested in starting to “work through the political piece” of the 17-year-old war.

via GIPHY

But it’s not clear if the Taliban is open to negotiations. Last month, a top Taliban commander told RT, in a rare interview, that the group’s leaders had no desire to negotiate with the Americans.




#Afghanistan is on its way to becoming America's longest war ever, and fewer and fewer Americans like it https://on.rt.com/9g84

9:21 AM - Oct 11, 2018

US veterans overwhelmingly want troops out of Afghanistan – poll — RT US News
A new poll shows a majority of US residents support withdrawing all troops from Afghanistan, 17 years into a war that shows no signs of ending. Support for winding down the interminable conflict is...


Described for years as a stalemate, the conflict has been tipping in the Taliban’s favor in recent months. Even by US military estimates, the Afghan government controls or influences just over half of the country’s 407 districts – a record low since the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction, or SIGAR, began tracking district control in November 2015.

To make matters worse, casualties among Afghan government forces have skyrocketed in recent months. Afghan security forces suffered 1,000 fatalities in August and September, according to the Pentagon.

READ MORE: US veterans overwhelmingly want troops out of Afghanistan – poll

Miller’s desire for a political settlement was echoed earlier by the State Department, which said in August that the US was doing everything it could to facilitate peace talks between the Taliban and the Afghan government.

The new US commander has experienced the deteriorating security situation in Afghanistan first-hand. In October, Miller survived a Taliban attack in Kandahar, which left a prominent Afghan warlord and local intelligence chief dead.
But the Zionist Gog and Magog Judeo-Christian elite that control power don’t want to lose Afghanistan as a military base...
 
Last edited:
.
I think the troops have mostly come home a long tIme ago. I believe there is only a security force of about around 10,000 now.

upload_2018-11-3_16-22-24.gif
 
Last edited:
.
Gen. Austin Scott is right, but many others have said this before.
 
. . .
This is a lesson for everyone -- and I mean really EVERYONE.

For the US, military successes do not guarantee desired political outcomes.

For others, keep your countries to yourselves. Contain your despotism. Do not take sides unless all of you are willing to pay the same price.
 
. .
This is a lesson for everyone -- and I mean really EVERYONE.

For the US, military successes do not guarantee desired political outcomes.

For others, keep your countries to yourselves. Contain your despotism. Do not take sides unless all of you are willing to pay the same price.
Yes a great one,you can't teach those who don't want to change.
 
.
I thought Dubya already defeated the Taliban and Zero brought the troops home victorious.
A military defeat ALWAYS have political effects. The Taliban was militarily defeated. Any question on that is essentially a stupid one. The current situation in Afghanistan is all political and who thinks this generation of the Taliban is going to support any state or non-state belligerent against the US, which was what happened with Mullah Omar, Osama bin Laden, and Al-Qaeda?

The US will withdraw from the idea that we can make major political changes in terms of 'nation building', but no one is under any illusion that he can get away with taking sides against US. The consequences of 9/11? The US can repeat that practically indefinitely.
 
.
A military defeat ALWAYS have political effects. The Taliban was militarily defeated. Any question on that is essentially a stupid one. The current situation in Afghanistan is all political and who thinks this generation of the Taliban is going to support any state or non-state belligerent against the US, which was what happened with Mullah Omar, Osama bin Laden, and Al-Qaeda?

The US will withdraw from the idea that we can make major political changes in terms of 'nation building', but no one is under any illusion that he can get away with taking sides against US. The consequences of 9/11? The US can repeat that practically indefinitely.

Tbh you guys majorly failed at nation building because you have zero idea about the nation you were trying to build. You weren't bespoke enough.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom