What's new

A Chinese woman accused of painting Washington, D.C. monuments green isn’t

Anees

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Apr 22, 2012
Messages
1,158
Reaction score
-2
A Chinese woman accused of painting Washington, D.C. monuments green isn’t just another tourist behaving badly

lincoln-vandalism-web.jpg


A 58-year-old Chinese woman traveling on an expired tourist visa has been charged with splashing green paint on a cathedral in Washington, D.C. and linked to the vandalism of other national sites in America’s capitol. The woman, Tian Jiamei, is the latest embarrassment for Beijing, which has been trying to rein in the behavior of millions of Chinese nationals who travel abroad every year.

As we’ve reported, Chinese tourists behaving badly has become all too common. There were the parents who let their children urinate in the middle of restaurants, others who ignored attire rules for entering Buddhist temples in Thailand, and those who left their mark for causing general pandemonium in Singapore. In May, a 15-year-old from Nanjing etched “Ding Jinhao was here” on an ancient Egyptian temple along the Nile.

But Tian’s case is different. If the allegations are true, she appears to have been deliberately and somewhat systematically defacing landmarks rather than acting inappropriately because of a culture gap. On Friday, July 26, green paint had been found splattered on the Lincoln Memorial. When Tian was arrested the following Monday inside the Washington National Cathedral, she was holding a can of green paint. A pipe organ inside the church was covered in the paint, as well as urine and feces, police said. Prosecutors said another monument in downtown Washington was found to have green paint on it as well; a witness said she had seen Tian attend church in the area. Symbols in green paint were also found on the Smithsonian museum in the National Mall.

In China, news of Tian’s case—she is currently in jail in Washington, awaiting trial—has spread across online news sites and forums. On Sina Weibo, bloggers have posted over 800 comments about Tian. Several bloggers questioned whether something darker motivated Tian. One wrote, “Yes, Tian’s actions were wrong and she should take responsibility for her behavior, but what’s behind the action? Had she suffered some injustice before?”

It’s a good question. Municipal police and other authorities have been making headlines in China for handling lawbreakers too harshly—in one case police beat a watermelon vendor to death. Just last week, a man in a wheelchair set off a bomb in Beijing’s airport, in protest of a beating by police that left him paralyzed years ago. (He had been running an unlicensed motorcycle taxi service.) The cynicism of other comments about Tian also seem to reflect a bitterness about the state of justice in China now. One blogger wrote, “She really didn’t want to come back and this was her way out.” To which another said, “Staying in jail is still better than returning home.”

Referring to the heavy police presence in Tiananmen Square in Beijing the site of democracy demonstrations in 1989, one blogger said, “She couldn’t vandalize in Tiananmen so she had to go to the US.” If convicted, Tian faces up to 10 years in prison and a fine of $5,000.

A Chinese woman accused of painting Washington, D.C. monuments green isn’t just another tourist behaving badly – Quartz
 
.
What she did must have been captured on CCTV I expect.
 
.
As we’ve reported, Chinese tourists behaving badly has become all too common. There were the parents who let their children urinate in the middle of restaurants, others who ignored attire rules for entering Buddhist temples in Thailand, and those who left their mark for causing general pandemonium in Singapore.

Oh well, am I supposed to look surprised?
 
.
What she did must have been captured on CCTV I expect.

Probably that is how she got nailed for her doings. Why did she not try these painting stunts in the forbidden city, or like $hitting on the great wall? Funny indeed.....
 
.
well,thats simply wrong as a whole..those who deface any memorial or any monument with historical value(don't even bother to check the nationality) is simply should be punished..in this case,it is simply reached into a new height..
 
. .
She did it on purpose to stay in US albeit in a Jail.

One blogger wrote, “She really didn’t want to come back and this was her way out.” To which another said, “Staying in jail is still better than returning home.”
 
.
simpleton cheerleading indians even honour the posting of some random bloggers! no wonder why you have been the super powder in the last 30 years!



taught? we are taught with proper toilet habits and personal hygienes at very young age
there is something wrong in the food which the kid has eaten obviously and we can see the security people was condoning the camera off!

if the same case happened in shining india there is much less hassels and you just do it on the floor!

Those random bloggers are chinese citizens not scared of their government. Not paid CCP worker like you
 
.
She did it on purpose to stay in US albeit in a Jail.

One blogger wrote, “She really didn’t want to come back and this was her way out.” To which another said, “Staying in jail is still better than returning home.”

Maybe. Sometimes a Foreign Jailhouse is a more welcome option than a Hometown......
 
.
The headline made no sense. SO if she isn't just another Chinese tourist behaving badly, then what is she?

Also, the whole point of living in a jail is better than living in China makes no sense. Your freedom is your freedom. If she can travel to the US and stay there, then she definitely has money to live in China comfortably.

On the other hand, if she was on an expired tourist visa, how was she able to remain in the US undetected? Secondly, wouldn't she be deported even if she isn't convicted?

What would our in-house visa expert @Argus Panoptes say about this?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
The headline made no sense. SO if she isn't just another Chinese tourist behaving badly, then what is she?

Also, the whole point of living in a jail is better than living in China makes no sense. Your freedom is your freedom. If she can travel to the US and stay there, then she definitely has money to live in China comfortably.

On the other hand, if she was on an expired tourist visa, how was she able to remain in the US undetected? Secondly, wouldn't she be deported even if she isn't convicted?

What would our in-house visa expert @Argus Panoptes say about this?

You said it right there. It is not all about money but freedom. Lets not even talk about freedom in china.

Why Chinese immigrants choose America | GlobalPost

Why China's Rich Want to Leave - Rachel Wang - The Atlantic
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
The headline made no sense. SO if she isn't just another Chinese tourist behaving badly, then what is she?

Also, the whole point of living in a jail is better than living in China makes no sense. Your freedom is your freedom. If she can travel to the US and stay there, then she definitely has money to live in China comfortably.

On the other hand, if she was on an expired tourist visa, how was she able to remain in the US undetected? Secondly, wouldn't she be deported even if she isn't convicted?

What would our in-house visa expert @Argus Panoptes say about this?

It may not even be about living comfortably or even about having the means to live comfortably.

And then there is freedom and there is Freedom. May not be the same in everybody's eyes or mind?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
.
It may not even be about living comfortably or even about having the means to live comfortably.
And then there is freedom and there is Freedom. May not be the same in everybody's eyes or mind?

You said it right there. It is not all about money but freedom. Lets not even talk about freedom in china.
Why Chinese immigrants choose America | GlobalPost
Why China's Rich Want to Leave - Rachel Wang - The Atlantic

You will have to go back by many levels.

What are the basic necessities for humans: food, shelter and clothing.

Till these basic necessities are not filled, an individual does not think of security, literacy and education, health and safety.

After all of this comes social and political freedom.

To say that a person will care about his human rights on an empty stomach is foolish.

You have out- and in-migrations happening all the time.

The way China and Russia are demonised by the West is unfair to say the least.

Most people move to the US, UK and Australia because opportunities are open and it is easier to assimilate in an English-speaking country than in a non-English speaking country.
 
.
You will have to go back by many levels.

What are the basic necessities for humans: food, shelter and clothing.

Till these basic necessities are not filled, an individual does not think of security, literacy and education, health and safety.

After all of this comes social and political freedom.

To say that a person will care about his human rights on an empty stomach is foolish.

You have out- and in-migrations happening all the time.

The way China and Russia are demonised by the West is unfair to say the least.

Most people move to the US, UK and Australia because opportunities are open and it is easier to assimilate in an English-speaking country than in a non-English speaking country.

I wish I could agree with you.
Let me tell you about an experience that I had in 1974-75. In Iran. That was the time of the Shah's rule and Iran was going great guns with an 'oil-driven economy' Everything looked pretty modern and good around. While my country was a 'wheezing socialist economy' where even telephones were some kind of luxury and cars...........,tauba-tauba. An unnecessary thing for the aam awaam. But we had the freedom of choice, the vote to decide who would rule us.

In Iran I met up with a young school-teacher, a little older than me. Soon enough I came to know of her connection with the underground revolutionary movement that was working to remove the Shah. I remember one discussion with her about our respective countries. I said that Iran seemed to be so well off and everything (in the cities at least) seemed to be so modern and progressive and she seemed to be lucky to be part of it. She looked at me and said that I was lucky to live in my country. I scoffed at that and asked why (after singing a litany of all that was messed up in my country). She replied "All that is there; but you have Jomhouria (Democracy). Do you even understand how lucky you are?"
I laughed at that and said "What good is Jomhouria, it does not bring food to the table; it does not make anyone's life better". She quietly replied "Is food the only nourishment that you need? Is it only the stomach that needs food? Don't you need food for the mind; for the soul? Only Jomhouria can give that. The stomach can face some more want than the mind".
She got her Jomhouria in time; but it was not exactly what she and her compatriots were really looking for. Soon enough, they ran afoul of the new authorities after the Revolution. Somewhere along the way she and some of her friends disappeared.

While I got something to ruminate about: freedom. And what it could mean and what else goes with it.
 
.
It may not even be about living comfortably or even about having the means to live comfortably.

And then there is freedom and there is Freedom. May not be the same in everybody's eyes or mind?

You said it right there. It is not all about money but freedom. Lets not even talk about freedom in china.

Why Chinese immigrants choose America | GlobalPost

Why China's Rich Want to Leave - Rachel Wang - The Atlantic

I wish I could agree with you.
Let me tell you about an experience that I had in 1974-75. In Iran. That was the time of the Shah's rule and Iran was going great guns with an 'oil-driven economy' Everything looked pretty modern and good around. While my country was a 'wheezing socialist economy' where even telephones were some kind of luxury and cars...........,tauba-tauba. An unnecessary thing for the aam awaam. But we had the freedom of choice, the vote to decide who would rule us.

In Iran I met up with a young school-teacher, a little older than me. Soon enough I came to know of her connection with the underground revolutionary movement that was working to remove the Shah. I remember one discussion with her about our respective countries. I said that Iran seemed to be so well off and everything (in the cities at least) seemed to be so modern and progressive and she seemed to be lucky to be part of it. She looked at me and said that I was lucky to live in my country. I scoffed at that and asked why (after singing a litany of all that was messed up in my country). She replied "All that is there; but you have Jomhouria (Democracy). Do you even understand how lucky you are?"
I laughed at that and said "What good is Jomhouria, it does not bring food to the table; it does not make anyone's life better". She quietly replied "Is food the only nourishment that you need? Is it only the stomach that needs food? Don't you need food for the mind; for the soul? Only Jomhouria can give that. The stomach can face some more want than the mind".
She got her Jomhouria in time; but it was not exactly what she and her compatriots were really looking for. Soon enough, they ran afoul of the new authorities after the Revolution. Somewhere along the way she and some of her friends disappeared.

While I got something to ruminate about: freedom. And what it could mean and what else goes with it.

I am quite certain she had more on her plate than what a daily wager whose life depends on having a stable economy than mass demonstration locking down the city.

It really is perspective.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom