Search results

To be honest, you would be hard pressed to find some mention of 'Pashtun' or 'Afghan' in pre-Islamic times much less a mention of some Jewish connection.

Yes, genetically they dont have much affinity with Ashkenazi, Mizrahi or Sephardic Jews. Which are those pre-Islamic sources?

Well, anyway it's been disproved pretty much via actual historic evidence (mass migrations like such would be very unlikely not to mention logistical problems) and genetics. Only some early 20th century British writers started it.

How are Ashkenazies and Yemeni Jews being converts relevant here? Pashtuns don't have any such documented history of conversions to Judaism. And even among Jews, there are many different groups such as Sephardi, Mizrahim etc. The Jewish theory was pretty outlandish to begin with and with...

Lol, the genetic evidence isn't that inconclusive or inconclusive at all. It's pretty obvious that this Jewish connection isn't true.

Analysis of partition. Just by the way. Here is a pre-1947 map of British Colonial India, showing Muslim majority and Hindu majority regions: With provinces represented: Further, the focus being on Punjab, here is a map of Muslim-Hindu-Sikh percentages, in the Punjabi speaking areas of...

Again, I would tell you to refer back to previous pages in the thread, you are making the same argument which already has been addressed. Its pointless to repeat the same thing over and over again.

Please read the previous two pages of this thread, I have addressed your point.

Thank you, I appreciate it.

Lol, I think all those Afghan kids need to update their maps of Loy Afghanistan made on MS Paint ;)

Well, basically different Prakrits including Sauraseni from which it descended from as you have mentioned. But that's not what I was arguing about. And I think, in this context, it's rather pointless to delve into the deep history of the (Hindustani) language, given that most of it's...

So the word 'بدیسی' badesi, is used for Europeans, as the book says? It also says that 'badesi maal' is referred to as 'wilayati maal' with specific reference to Europeans/British only.

Interesting. So North-Western South Asian territories mentioned here refer to Afghanistan? Btw do Pashtuns use 'wilayati' term for Europeans/British or not?

Do you think people use 'waleti' for Pashtuns?

Just thought to post this here. Have to say, really nicely made. Regions of the Indus Basin - Pakistan: @Kaptaan @Mentee @Kambojaric @Max @Zibago @django @DESERT FIGHTER @Pakistani Exile @Moonlight @WAJsal

Yeah, lol. I don't know exact place, it was in anthrogenica as HRP0402 (HarappaWorld) as 'Punjabi Jatt Muslim-Pakistani'. As for DNA land, yeah there could be some discrepancies, but its become really better after their 2016 update and free too and so its really popular now. Btw, have you...

Google's doodle for Pakistan's 70th Independence Day:

Lol, just read this. Would you not consider Maulana Fazlur Rehman as Marwat due to his complexion? As for giving daughters/ marrying and all, even Barakzai Afghan king Sher Ali Khan gave his daughter to Gakhar chief Jahandad Khan. It is a repsectable union, nothing insulting in it. Yeah, thats...

Btw, do you have any screenshot of Soomro/Sindh Kingdom region in CKII?

Thanks and please do post your article. This is in 'Sword of Islam' expansion, right?