Search results

:cheesy: The incorrigible EastSea is just another culture/history thief. But I suppose that's what happens to jealous people who make up a glorious past in an attempt to whitewash the truth.

Do you really think that Taiwanese worship Japanese as much as you do? Neither do they consider themselves as Christian democracy.

Taiwanese Hokkien is a dialect of Minnan, however it is separate language from Cantonese or Mandarin and Min languages are either descended from either Old Chinese or a sister branch,while some variants of Min have more Middle Chinese influence than others while proto Min also borrowed from a...

You don't seem to realize that DPP is just another platform for Hokkien supremacy,they don't want to be annexed by Japan. Thankfully most Taiwanese are completely opposite of Kolaps.

I asked for sources written by the Chinese not Vietnamese ones. Show me the the petitions he sent to the Song emperor to invade Dai Viet.

I don't have access to Song era maps,Yongzhou is today's Nanning which doesn't even border Vietnam. Neither the Song or the Ly directly ruled western Guangxi they were instead controlled by Zhuang chieftains that held allegiance to whoever was stronger. You don't seem to understand that the...

No,I'm just tired of the fairy tales that Vietnamese try to pass off as history,but I suppose thieves will be thieves. ie Chinese stole Vietnamese land in southern China,Chinese stole surnames from Vietnamese,Chinese stole architecture from Vietnamese,Chinese stole Shennong from Vietnamese,the...

Are tall tales of one individual equivalent to the myth that Vietnamese ruled southern China? I deny your myths not because they're Vietnamese but because they defy archaeology and historical sources same reason why I don't believe in Chinese mythology. You must have trouble comprehending...

I already stated that Chinese myths don't exist,how can I take Vietnamese member seriously if they insist on using mythology to back up their statements. How is asking for proof smearing?

Except the Hung Kings never existed its rooted in myth not history.

Vietnamese logic: Vietnamese invasions of Cham,Tai,Khmer,Chinese etcs are legitimate,whenever someone else invades Vietnam they go ballistic. It doesn't matter that Vietnamese covet southern China, they never have and never will have the power to hold onto it. Ly Nhan Tong,Ho Quy Ly and...

You do realize that Wang Anshi only advocated for a Song invasion when the Ly dynasty forcibly took control of Qinzhou and Lianzhou which breached Song borders as well making excuses that the Ly were apprehending a criminal. Before this Wang Anshi didn't want the Nong Zhigao rebellion to play...

宋史/卷446/列傳第205/忠義一/蘇緘

The Ly dynasty took 42 days to siege one city ie Yongzhou showing how terrible they are at sieges ie 80,000 Vietnamese vs 2,800 Chinese:woot: They love to blame Chinese for invading Vietnam when Vietnamese were the ones provoking the invasions.

Yawn,more Vietnamese who can't read classical Chinese and claim they understand it better than Chinese. They cry "dirty Chinese aggressor" when Vietnamese were the ones raiding Chinese provinces therefore provoking a invasion.

Japanese Imperial household never intermarried with the Chinese nobility or scholar-elite. Japanese have blood relationships with Koreans,while Han Chinese didn't historically mix with Japanese in large numbers.

Except that Vietnamese did copy Hanzi,just like most of your culture is derived from China. Then again you're trying to deny that 漢 means Chinese,so its not surprising you'll try to deny Hanzi as well.

I insult those who rely on nationalistic reinterpretations of history,relying on myths and legends as proof how mighty their kingdom/state/ethnicity was(this also includes Chinese). If you're going to prove that the Hung Kings existed then provide some sources other than texts written thousands...

Not this nonsense again,all you do is repeat the same lies over and over again. China invaded Vietnam because Vietnamese raided Chinese provinces or killed Chinese embassies. Considering how Kinh Vietnamese have Chinese blood in them you would be insulting your own ancestors. Then again you...

You don't seem to realize that Vietnamese elites literally spoke a Sinitic language,and shifted to a Muong language after Le Loi won. Some O3a subclades originated in Sino Tibetans ie JST002611,M134,M117. Even so how can you explain the Y haplogroup similarities of Henan and Fujian Han?