Wrong. It is not country's law but a company's policy. She has done the right thing in fighting against such policy.
Discrimination on any ground is wrong.
No, if you could not collect personally and somebody else collected on behalf of you, that wont be on the website. Your name will be on the website. You are beyond ridiculous now.
The site mentions 4 names that won the award, there could be many people behind it.
He could not collect the award...
Check the number of people in visual effects category. It runs into more than 50, possibly 100.
A company with branches in 4 cities worked on it. The newspaper completely misread the whole thing.
Or probably it is deliberate paid news. Who knows. I already saw this type of story once...
I agreed with you on that already. Now lots of people worked on visual effects, including the guys whose title does not include effects. All the names are in IMDB. All are winners.
But the newspaper is misleading when it calls him oscar winner. It is the team that wins and usually one leader...
There are many technical directors visual team. There is another lead technical director. Please go through the imdb list. Technical director is not a big shot.
Here is one
Bill Houston Ball .... effects technical director: Rhythm & Hues (as William Ball)
another one
Kathleen Curry ...
Then why do you call him Oscar award winner? How many Indian names do you see in the list. Are they all oscar award winners? The company has two development centers in India, so obviously many Indians will be in the list.
Give me a link where oscar has given Individual award to him.
Also...
Give me a link where his name is mentioned. If he got oscar, his name will be somewhere. Holding an Oscar won by other does not make you a winner. You already know by now what I am talking about. But you chose to go on and on.
If you go to the site of rhythm & hues studio (who made visual effects) the other guy is seen holding it.
It is a team effort, but no mention of Mr Ali's name anywhere in citation.
Rhythm & Hues Studios :: Features :: Credits :: The Golden Compass
The site mentions the following
Rhythm & Hues...
I wish you realize after some days that it is false news yet again. Like that scientist who was selected as top 10 personality of century.
Then please come back and thank me for the post. :)
So he is an employee who worked for various projects. The title is so misleading people are congratulating him as winner of Oscar.
Another comment from same page.
truthard
Jun 14, 2011 - 3:13PM
Reply
Best Achievement in Visual Effects
Michael L. Fink
Bill Westenhofer
Ben Morris
Trevor Wood...
A comment from the Express Tribune, same page.
Ali
Jun 14, 2011 - 1:07PM
Reply
Dear fellow Pakistanis, no Pakistani has ever won an oscar. The oscar that everyone of you is proud of went to a team of four Americans namely Michael Fink, Bill Westenhofer, Ben Morris and Trevor Wood(Best...