Thum I Kaun Aata Hai ? is rather an interesting blog name ..
but I love this site ...they always have something extra which other blogs , sites don't ....
@SledgeHammer
Netaji was supposed to be Yarkutsk prison cell number 45 ...I do not see any cell number . this does not look like Prison ...and Netaji looks rather content if not happy when the photograph was taken
Opps this does not look like Siberia also ....why netaji is wearing suit in...
India will be a bright spot in mediocre economic environment: World Bank chief
World Bank President Jim Yong Kim called Prime Minister Narendra Modi a "visionary leader" during his address at the Vibrant Gujarat Summit today.
"India is on the cusp of major progress in reducing the number of...
Daughter of Lady Mountbatten has elaborated on the platonic relationship that Nehru shared with Edwina - her mother . this is largely based on the extensive correspondence between two . she was too young to understand and know the personal chemistry between two ....Her inference is based on...
I will not qualify any reply to your obviously biased posts which have no bearing upon whatsoever towards discussion with regards to Netaji's death .
I am not interested in conversing with you ...while you have nothing worthwhile to say besides your rants .
@SledgeHammer has been posting about the sources for his assertion and I am responding to him in very cordial and civil manner . I am not stifling any discussion . I have just told you to stop making unnecessary personal attacks on public figure on Nehru which are out of context .
the so called...
Well please speak for yourself alone .
@SledgeHammer , @SarthakGanguly do not need spokeperson , they can speak for thelselves .
You did ask me to leave thread . go and read post 52 . " you are welcome to leave this thread ...."
it implied same ....I can also say same thing to you ..." you...
Both reports you posted are emails .
they do have lot of details such as specific dates , names , places mentioned which could have been easily verified .
off course from the very language of those reports it seems that the very commissions which were constituted to find the truth were biased...
Of course how will you see your own actions as wrong ? that takes a whole lot of self introspection....
can you please talk for yourself ?
since when you became " we " ???
who are you to tell me to leave the thread ?
No I am not the one who has already split and slice who dares to talk...
nobody says that Nehru did not made blunders ..
but just because of those blunders ....it does not mean one go on disinformation drive to heap all that happened in a period on one person .
It has become fashionable to blame Nehru to all and sundry ...
Let there be objective evaluation ...not...
Well with your fertile imagination ...you should be able to come out with some fantabulous explanation why Nehru listened to Edwina Mountbatten to go to UN .
this is height of distortion of history ...
so Edwina was honey trap ???
wow Pandit Nehru ...the greatest victim of Booby trap ....and...
I have read that ..and so what ?
Nehru always believed that professionals do the job. He gave free hand to Homi Jehangir Bhabha ..made him technocrat .
If he felt need to appoint British officer as in charge when India was going through turmoil ..was it such a crime against Nation ???
when...
well in your earlier posts you have said that Nehru entered in agreement with British to hand over Netaji if he entered India . You must have some documentary proof ?
you also posted excerpt of a letter by Nehru to atlee ....which Shymalal Jain had provided to Khosla commission .
You should...
The individual testimonials of commission ...when did they become the final absolute truth ?
so if individual testimonials is all that we need to incriminate a person ...then we should hang Mr Modi ...because of individual testimonies of persons involved .
Let the commission which had...
" it was possible that Edwina's influence played a role in Nehru's decision to refer Kashmir to the UN "
" It was possible ...." those words sum up everything .
since nothing is impossible ...everything is possible ...
so it was possible ....
BJP had been in power before and had acces to said papers . They have been aware of the truth . If that is the case then why Modi and other BJP leaders made tall claims of declassifying these files ?
so modi is not a ' feku ' as he is purported by his adversaries ...rather is a great...