Search results

I have already refuted your attempt at disconnecting local populations with their ancient counterparts. Bheels are a nomadic people native to the southern Aravalli range in West Central Indian. Some have migrated as far East as Bengal while some have migrated West into Gujarat and Eastern...

What Punjabi, Sindhi, Baloch, Pashtun or Kashmiri did they assimilate with?

What culture or bloodline did the Mughals leave here? Mughals didn't assimilate with locals of modern-day Pakistan, they assimilated with locals of modern-day India.

Memons, Lohanas and Khojas are originally from Sindh but many migrated Eastwards.

Lahore was only the capital for a mere 30 years and was seen as a staging-grounds for what the Mughals considered their real prize: Delhi. Also the amount of Mughal structures (which they built for themselves by excessively taxing the locals) in Pakistan is only a drop in the ocean compared to...

No, they were foreigners that conquered and occupied our lands. They formed their heartland in Hindustan (Delhi/UP region) and saw modern-day Pakistan as an over-taxed backwater to be exploited. We are instead heirs to Khushal Khattak, Abdullah Bhatti, Shah Inayat Shaheed, Pir Roshan, Muqarrab...

Yes they do.

Your statement is a prime example of nonsense babble by a person who has neither the knowledge nor intelligence to grasp any portion of this topic and discussion. What I stated is a fact not an opinion. People of Tharparkar are not ethnic Sindhis nor have they ever even historically considered...

No, people of Thar are not ethnically Sindhi. They are a Rajasthani ethnic group. Similar to how most people of Northern Balochistan are not ethnically Baloch, but are instead Pashtun. Tharparkar region is ethno-culturally a part of Rajasthan. The people of Tharparkar speak Rajasthani...

Bringing in random pictures when your argument has already been debunked by genetics is futile. Especially considering the second picture is edited and the third picture is not even of a Sindhi. As you can see here, Sindhis and Pakistani ethnic groups in general are remarkably close...

This is such an absurd statement. Sindhis along with most other Pakistani ethnic groups are among the few ethnic groups in the world that have overwhelmingly retained their genetic admixture since the Iron Age. There is no Arab, Iranian or Central Asian genetic influence among Sindhis. Arabs...

Urdu is spoken in Pakistan today because of the British, not Akbar. Prior to the British; Urdu, mainly known as Hindustani or Hindi back then was primarily concentrated in the Hindustan (UP and Delhi) region. Early British agents that travelled to modern-day Pakistan (then principally comprised...

This is a nonsensical article, Urdu was not even dominant in modern-day Pakistan at that time let alone Afghanistan.

The Gulf countries are far closer to India than Iran is. No country would risk harming their relations with India, a country with nearly a fifth of the world's population, to appease Pakistan on the basis of "Muslim Brotherhood".

Grew up with Afghan refugees, some of the best and hardest working people I've ever met.

MQM has killed far more than PTM. PTM comes nowhere close to the damage that MQM has done.

PTM allied with the party (PPP) which defended Rao Anwar.

I never understood this point. Urdu was as foreign to modern-day Pakistan as it was to Bengal. Hardly anyone spoke it prior to the 1940's in modern-day Pakistan.

The original founding fathers (before ML endorsed Pakistan) wanted Bengal to be it's own independent Muslim country, they also wanted Indian Muslims to have their own country as well centered in Central India instead of having them migrated to Pakistan. They believed religion to be only one of...