The biggest power off Muslims is that they vote as a united front. They did that before independence, Muslim league got almost ALL the seats reserved for Muslims. In face of a divided Hindu vote, they are a potent political power. Hindus have voted as a combined block only recently in 2014 and...
Oh dear!
Do you really believe that Hindus are still standing? Hindus have LOST their homeland to Muslims and "enlightened" seculars. There is NO homeland for Hindus anywhere. Hinduism can be crushed all over world with absolutely no repercussion. There is a secular country called India but...
The fundametal idea behind Hindu Rashtra IMHO is this : The political power lies purely or majorly in the hands of Hindus and Sikh. You cann't have any meaningful political power if you are no Hindu or Sikh. You cann't profess secularism and have any political agency. You cann't criticize...
Do you know, that by constitution, NO political party can change the fundamental structure of constitution? It took Indira Gandhi an emergency to insert the word secular -- though Indian constitution and laws were always imposed secularism on Hindus.
Bhartiya Jana Sangh at that point of time was only 2 year old party. It lacked any political experience that INC had due to its aeons of existence. It was their first election. To be fair, in 1940s, Hindus had NO political representation. There was NO political party based on Hindu nation...
That was POST the fact that a secular constitution was forced on unknowing and unwilling Hindus. Indian constitution went into force in 1950. Besides, this was a fact that once it went into force, its fundamental structure cannot be changed. There were too many hurdles to amend it.
The...
You are getting me wrong. Its not the uprooting and killings that is what is the end goal. The end goal is a Hindu nation. A homeland for Hindus because there is none. A nation which does not forces Hindus to give up their religion to align with secular agenda of elites, like it happens in...
No not exactly true. What happened in Pakistan and later in East Pakistan NEVER happened in India.
West Pakistan became practically FREE of any Hindu and Sikh presence after 1947. East Pakistan also saw a decimation of non-Muslim after 1970.
What happened in India? Hindus are declining. From...
Indeed! Muslims have Pakistan and Bangladesh in subcontinent. Hindus are practically homeless! They don't have a single country they can call their home land which can accepts them. India forces them to quit their religion and accept secularism. There is NO country for 1 billion Hindus, they...
Ever wonder how many hours he spends in gym? Or how his nutrition is decided? Or what kind of medical advice is available to him? If he smokes or not?
If you factor in all that, you most likely don't need to drink piss.
Did the people of that time agreed that they need to share their country with Muslims even though Muslims got their own country? Was there a poll on this? If given an option between a Hindu nation, ( or may be a Hindu-Sikh nation ) and a secular nation, which option would majority of India had...
I don't give a damn what you are. Thanks for dangling your credentials, they mean nothing to me. I am a cook and a farm worker and I care least about your universities. From the looks of it, for all your rocket science you export yarn for living. So, unless you link to proper sources, you won't...
Good question! They get what majority agrees to. Thats democracy. That works in Pakistan, in B'desh. That will work in India too.
There was another option. Dictatorship of seculars. Atleast dictatorship of seculars worked in China. Secularism and democracy won't work in India. One has to give...
Indeed it does. It was there all along. It was not given platform because of left leaning media. The moment that became weak, it became popular opinion. The popular opinion in the past was divided into many caste creeds and languages. Modi combined it into their basic demand. A Hindu nation. It...
This was the thread because of which I joined this forum.
I think these intellectual types are basically silly. Why? Its' very easy to see why. They expect people of India to accept willingly the idea of a secular pluralistic society and be tolerant to minorities. Lets step back just to...