What will happen to Pakistan as a fallout of unstable Afghanistan

[FaujHistorian]

Guys this thread is meant for a serious discussion on the topic.

I feel that post 2014 Afghanistan will probably continue getting stable under the control of Kabul government, ANA, and NATO presence until 2024.

However in case there is no long term agreement between Kabul and NATO, and all Western troops leave, there may be another Iraq in the making.

If God forbid that happens, and Afghanistan becomes a hotbed of wars of war lords, Pakistan could suffer from terrible consequences.

 

[Imran Khan]

as before we will take one side and put fuel shear on fire . TBH we didn't try for peace since 20 years in afghanistan and they are enimies of themselves . our bad luck we have border with them .

 

[farhan_9909]

We should not consider what will happen if Afghanistan fall

What we need to do is to take few steps

*Fence the border and than Mine it
*Completely Ban the supply route of both NATO and Afghan govt through Pakistan,Afghan govt already has now access to iranian route
*End this refugee drama and set a visa on arrival policy,No one from Afghanistan should be allowed without proper visa and the stay should be for max 15-30days.
*Don't interfere in Afghanistan internal affair

Now after this Not only we will become immune to afterwards situation in Afghanistan but will also be able to defeat TTP easily than before.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

We should not consider what will happen if Afghanistan fall

What we need to do is to take few steps

*Fence the border and than Mine it
*Completely Ban the supply route of both NATO and Afghan govt through Pakistan,Afghan govt already has now access to iranian route
*End this refugee drama and set a visa on arrival policy,No one from Afghanistan should be allowed without proper visa and the stay should be for max 15-30days.
*Don't interfere in Afghanistan internal affair

Now after this Not only we will become immune to afterwards situation in Afghanistan but will also be able to defeat TTP easily than before.

That is the best solution. There are enough problem already... but do you think the politicians will allow it?

 

[FaujHistorian]

We should not consider what will happen if Afghanistan fall

What we need to do is to take few steps

*Fence the border and than Mine it
*Completely Ban the supply route of both NATO and Afghan govt through Pakistan,Afghan govt already has now access to iranian route
*End this refugee drama and set a visa on arrival policy,No one from Afghanistan should be allowed without proper visa and the stay should be for max 15-30days.
*Don't interfere in Afghanistan internal affair

Now after this Not only we will become immune to afterwards situation in Afghanistan but will also be able to defeat TTP easily than before.

unfortunately who will bell the cat?

 

[farhan_9909]

That is the best solution. There are enough problem already... but do you think the politicians will allow it?

Few steps are already taken
*New refugees are not accepted.
*mining of the border was started few years back but dropped due to funding issues

Though these are big decision and would also need alot of political approvements aswell as funds.But if these are done.We won't be affected be it afghanistan fall or survive after nato withdrawal

unfortunately who will bell the cat?

We,

When we can go on for so many dharna's.Than why not one for fencing the border and mining it with Afghanistan when we do it even if the Vegetables price is increased or inflation increases.

We should not care What Afghanistan govt say since the Pak-Afghan border is already recognized by throughout the world except Afghanistan.

 

[FaujHistorian]

Few steps are already taken
*New refugees are not accepted.
*mining of the border was started few years back but dropped due to funding issues

Though these are big decision and would also need alot of political approvements aswell as funds.But if these are done.We won't be affected be it afghanistan fall or survive after nato withdrawal



We,

When we can go on for so many dharna's.Than why not one for fencing the border and mining it with Afghanistan when we do it even if the Vegetables price is increased or inflation increases.

We should not care What Afghanistan govt say since the Pak-Afghan border is already recognized by throughout the world except Afghanistan.

Well said

Dharna's are easy

working for a mission? very very tough.

 

[Finer]

Pakistan will never recover nor will be stable unless Pakistan implements well-controlled border between Pakistan and Afghanistan. That will be short-term solution for a while, as well as Pakistan's investment on Afghanistan must go on at the same time. The stability will return sooner or later. Insha Allah!

 

[k_arura]

That is the best solution. There are enough problem already... but do you think the politicians will allow it?

I think the question is will AFGHANIS allow it since they DO NOT recognize Durand Line as the border.

 

[Kompromat]

I think the question is will AFGHANIS allow it since they DO NOT recognize Durand Line as the border.

Godspeed.

No - D line means that Afghanistan is our 5th province. Not a bad bargain at all!

 

[karan.1970]

Godspeed.

No - D line means that Afghanistan is our 5th province. Not a bad bargain at all!

Is one KPK not enough that you want another war torn province.. You have seen what one restive province has done to your country.. Another one for the want of strategic depth will actually be the proverbial last straw in my view...

 

[Kompromat]

Is one KPK not enough that you want another war torn province.. You have seen what one restive province has done to your country.. Another one for the want of strategic depth will actually be the proverbial last straw in my view...

Precisely what Afghanis SHOULD be thinking.!

We are ready to take Oxus river if they are fed up with it.

Anaxing Afghanistan can solve a whole heap of issues.... @farhan_9909 - no?

 

[Dazzler]

the Yanks created a mess here, we were fine back in the 90s were we not? The region will remain as it was i.e. stable.

 

[RescueRanger]

For all those who laughed at our analysis of 2014:
BBC News - Afghanistan Taliban 'confident of victory' over Nato

Truth is bitter.

 

[T-123456]

It all depends on Pakistan,
Will Pakistan act like a country for the interests of all,or will all the different factions in Pakistan act on their own.
Btw,i disagree with the OP,Afghanistan will never be stable(wish it was)the way things are going.